The 5 Best Fisting Dildos and Other Toys
I’ll admit it: normal dildos are good…but fisting dildos are even better! A hand shaped dildo really do take those masturbation sessions to the next level. In this review I took a look at and ranked the 5 best fisting dildos available! I left no stone unturned and didn’t pull my punches. I did all this in the name of helping you make your decision on what hand shape you want for your fisting dildo!
Test Winner | Cheapest | Fist Dildo | Forearm Dildo | Flexible |
---|---|---|---|---|
Magic Hand Dildo | "Fist It Up" Dildo | Bitch Fist Dildo | The Fister Dildo | "Give A Hand" Dildo |
Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons |
Table of contents (9)
Fisting dildo test and reviews explained
When it comes to fisting dildos is can be quite difficult to find honest and unbiased reviews. That’s why I’ve put together this comprehensive guide that covers all aspects of the toys. I looked at everything, from the shape, to the size, to the firmness or flexibility, to the materials, to even the price! What I was looking for wasn’t only the good stuff – I wanted the bad stuff too! That’s the only way I can be sure that the reviews are as truthful as possible! I spent over 60 hours on this post alone, exploring everything – answering those questions that you didn’t even know you had! And in the end I think this fisting dildos review is going to be an absolute favorite for those that want a little fisting fun!
Fisting Dildo Buyer’s Guide
Fisting dildos are somewhat of a specialist kind of toy, and when making your purchase you have to take a lot of things into consideration. So here are a few things you need to bear in mind if you want a fisting dildo that will make you feel like a million dollars!
- Material – There are lots of materials out there that are used to make sex toys! When it comes to fisting dildos we’d always recommend body-same materials such as silicone, metal, and glass. Not only are they body-safe, but there are also non-porous and easy to clean. Very useful!
- Size – Don’t forget to think about the size of your fisting dildo. It’s important to take not of the length (how long it is) and girth (how round/wide it is). After all, you want a toy that feels amazing and will fit inside you perfectly!
- Hand shape – You can get fisting dildos in several different shapes. The obvious one is the clenched fist, a brutal rounded shape that will stretch you immediately. You can also get a hand in a more pointed ‘cone’ shape, one that is longer and will more gradually stretch you the further inside it goes.
- Price – “Money, money, money, must be funny, in a rich man’s world!” You could spend a fortune on fisting dildos, but here’s a secret: you don’t have to! There are affordable options out there that look and feel just as good as any expensively priced premium fisting dildo. Just keep your eyes peeled for those bargains!
Feel like these types of dildos are getting to big, then take a look at our ranking of the best dildos.
Reviews of the 5 best fisting dildos
Test Winner Belladonna's Magic Hand Dildo
Modeled after the porn star Belladonna’s actual hand, the Magic Hand dildo is definitely a few steps beyond your traditional dildo, but is still thin enough to provide a gentle-ish introduction into the world of fisting!
The hand—complete with fingernails & finger knuckles for added realism—is positioned in a manner that tapers the dildo for smooth insertion. Of course, you’ll need a lot of lube and a bit of patience, since this hand dildo is 2.62 inches thick at its widest point and measures in at a foot long in total length. You’ll have plenty of PVC to penetrate yourself with as you let Belladonna work her magic inside your vagina or anus, so if you’ve ever been curious about fisting, you might as well start your journey here!
Pros
- ✅ 2.62 maximum width
- ✅ 12 inches total length
- ✅ Molded from Belladonna herself
- ✅ Realistic texture
Cons
- ❌ Only available in one size
- ❌ Hard to clean
- ❌ Lacks base for easy control
Verdict
The idea of fisting might be appealing to a lot of people, but when it comes down to it, most people don’t actually want to start with a fist. That’s where this dildo comes in! Although you still get the experience of a human hand, this fisting dildo is much more gentle in its design, making it an excellent product for beginners. Naturally, it’s a bit more pricey than other dildos due to its size, but it provides a good value for your money since you’ll likely be using this toy for years to come. With a lot of water-based lube on hand, unwrap this fisting dildo and gently insert it into your vagina or anus to begin your journey into the world of fisting!
Buy, if you...
- Want to try fisting
- Love a challenge
- Enjoy realistic toys
Don't buy, if you...
- Have never been penetrated
- Use small sex toys
- Want a vibrating toy
Show coupon
15% coupon available
Cheapest "Fist It Up" Fisting Dildo
Ready to take your penetration game to the next level? If you’ve outgrown the fisting dildo above then this rubber fist dildo is a great next toy! Although it is a bit short compared to other dildos, the Fist It Up compensates for this with a massive maximum diameter of 3.38 inches. Fortunately, although this toy is extremely wide at its thickest point, the positioning of the fist means you’ll benefit from a tapered (albeit ribbed from the knuckles) shape for a slightly easier insertion process. The flexible material used ensures that you’ll be comfortable the entire time you’re using this toy, so if you can’t fit it all in the first time, don’t worry: you might have to work up to this one!
Pros
- ✅ 3.38-inch maximum width
- ✅ Excellent “filled” feeling
- ✅ Available in “flesh”, pink, & black colors
- ✅ Flared base for easy removal
Cons
- ❌ Made of PVC
- ❌ Hard to insert
- ❌ Shorter than alternative dildos
Verdict
If you’re a big fan of feeling “full” then this black fist dildo certainly won’t disappoint you! Its diameter is actually impressive, but unfortunately, the same can’t be said for its overall design. The PVC used is body-safe (which is definitely a plus) and flexible, which can make it challenging to insert this toy. The wrist poses a particular issue since this part of the dildo tends to flop around as you’re trying to insert the toy into your vagina or anus. We like the toy as a whole, but if you’re hoping for a toy that can just be easily slid in and out at will then you’ll want to “Fist It Up” with something else.
Buy, if you...
- Want a fisting dildo with a tapered design
- Already own a beginner fisting dildo
- Enjoy having multiple color options
Don't buy, if you...
- Haven’t tried a fisting dildo before
- Want a hyper-realistic rubber fist dildo
- Prefer firm dildos
Show coupon
5% coupon available
Fist Dildo Belladonna's Bitch Fist Realistic Fisting Dildo
If you already own the Magic Hand then why not buy the Bitch Fist as well!? Molded directly from Belladonna’s own fist, the Bitch Fist is ideal if you want a more aggressive way to pleasure your vagina or anus with the hand of a goddess! Measuring in at 12 inches long (8 inches of insertable length) and over three inches thick at the widest point, you’ll definitely need to pour on the lube as you try & fit this fist inside of yourself. Fortunately for you, Belladonna positioned her hand with the thumb pointed out, so you’ll at least be able to start small and work your way up from there!
Pros
- ✅ Molded from Belladonna’s actual hand
- ✅ Realistic detailing
- ✅ 3.02” wide at the thickest point
- ✅ Waterproof
Cons
- ❌ Made of PVC
- ❌ A warm-up toy is nearly essential
- ❌ One size only
- ❌ No color options
Verdict
As a realistic fisting dildo, the Bitch Fist is an excellent and visually appealing product! Although it’s not made from silicone (which would have been preferred), Doc Johnson has at least used phthalate-Free PVC for this dildo. Unfortunately, that means you won’t be able to sterilize it so you’ll have to make sure to clean it very thoroughly instead. However, this is where realism works against you, since the various textures, grooves, and crevices on this hand dildo can be somewhat challenging to clean completely. Still, this seems like a small price to pay for eight inches of fisting fun, so I’d still recommend this hand-shaped dildo (especially if you already own the Magic Hand!).
Buy, if you...
- Are a Size King/Queen
- Like realistically molded dildos
- Love Belladonna
Don't buy, if you...
- Don’t have any “warm-up” toys
- Want color options
- Are looking for silicone toys only
Show coupon
15% coupon available
Forearm Dildo The Fister Hand and Forearm Dildo
Beginners steer clear: this massive forearm dildo dildo is ready & waiting to split you in half! Appropriately part of the “Master Series”, The Fister Hand and Forearm Dildo measures in at an intimidating 15 inches long, with 13.75 inches that remain ready to be inserted into your vagina or anus (that is, if you can take that much!). Of course, as a fisting dildo, girth is also of the utmost importance, and this dildo doesn’t skimp there either. At its widest point, your choice of hole will be stretched out to a gaping 2.9 inches wide. Are you ready to take this dildo on? If so, now would be a good time to stock up on lube: you’ll surely need it!
Pros
- ✅ Suction-cup base
- ✅ 13.75 inches of insertable length
- ✅ Realistic design
- ✅ Tapered hand positioning
Cons
- ❌ PVC construction
- ❌ Way too big for many users
- ❌ Must be cleaned before & after use
Verdict
The pure size of this huge fisting dildo can be impressive, awe-inspiring, or even intimidating, depending on how experienced you are using fisting dildos. Combining a length forearm with a tapered hand design, you might be able to insert The Fister a bit easier than fist-shaped dildos, but that doesn’t mean just anyone will be able to use this sex toy. Unfortunately, this is another toy that uses PVC rather than silicone, but at least it offers a suction cup base (a feature sadly lacking on many other models). This allows you to use the toy completely hands-free. Instead, mount it to your favorite surface and do your best to ride this bad boy to completion!
Buy, if you...
- Love hands-free masturbation
- Are looking for a lifelong toy
- Want the ultimate dildo for your harness
Don't buy, if you...
- Want color options
- Won’t use the suction cup feature
- Don’t like PVC toys
Flexible "Give A Hand" Fisting Dildo
Liked the hand-shaped sex toys listed so far, but none of them seemed quite flexible enough to fit fully inside of you? You won’t have that problem with this hand dildo: it’s flexible & more than ready to “Give A Hand” to your favorite holes! Like many other fisting dildos, this toy uses a tapered hand positioning to aid in the insertion process, although you’ll still need loads of lube to fit the entire girth of this toy inside you. Measuring at nearly a foot long, this dildo is great for anal training as well as intense solo fisting sessions. The flared base means that you’ll never have to worry about struggling to remove the toy: just grab the base and pull!
Pros
- ✅ Flexible design
- ✅ Comes in multiple colors
- ✅ 11.8 inches long
- ✅ Affordably priced
Cons
- ❌ Flexibility may make insertion challenging
- ❌ Texture could look more realistic
- ❌ Can’t be sterilized due to the material used
Verdict
Arguably the best feature of this hand sex toy is the highly flexible PVC used to create it! Negatives first: it’s a porous material, which means that sterilizing it is impossible. Also, the PVC doesn’t look like real skin so it’s fairly easy to tell that it’s a toy, despite having fingernails and knuckle wrinkles for added realism. On the plus side, the PVC is extremely flexible, and this allows the toy to shape itself to whatever orifice you decide to shove it into. Unlike many jumbo size toys, this is one you might actually manage to fit entirely inside of you! The flared plug makes removal a breeze, although I probably wouldn’t recommend trying to use this toy for long-term wear. If flexibility is more important to you than realistic texturing, this toy is worth a second glance. At only $40, I definitely think it’s more than worth the price!
Buy, if you...
- Want a tapered design fisting dildo
- Prefer toys with a base
- Want color options
Don't buy, if you...
- Don’t like PVC toys
- Prefer less flexible toys
- Want a “closed fist” design
Show coupon
5% coupon available
Comparison of the 5 best fisting dildos
Best | Test Winner | Cheapest | Fist Dildo | Forearm Dildo | Flexible |
Overall score | 4.3 / 5.0 | 4.2 / 5.0 | 4.4 / 5.0 | - | 4.5 / 5.0 |
Bedbible rating | 4.1 / 5.0 | 4.0 / 5.0 | 4.0 / 5.0 | 4.2 / 5.0 | 4.0 / 5.0 |
User rating | 4.5 / 5.0 from 177 users | 4.3 / 5.0 from 7 users | 4.8 / 5.0 from 21 users | - | 5 / 5.0 from 1 users |
Price | Affordable | Cheap | Affordable | Moderate | Affordable |
Design | 90 / 100 | 85 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 80 / 100 |
Ease of use | 90 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 85 / 100 |
Quality | 70 / 100 | 75 / 100 | 70 / 100 | 70 / 100 | 80 / 100 |
Sound | - | - | - | - | - |
Power | - | - | - | - | - |
Buzzy/Rumbly | - | - | - | - | - |
Materials | PVC | PVC | PVC | PVC | PVC |
Insertable length | 12 inches | - | 8 inches | 13.75 inches | 8.62 inches |
Diameter | 2.62 inches | 3.38 inches | 3.02 inches | 2.9 inches | 2.95 inches |
Flexibility | Firm | Semi-flexible | Firm | Flexible | Flexible |
Length | - | 9.8 inches | 12 inches | 15 inches | 11.8 inches |
Get a Hand in the Action
Sure, using a fisting dildo feels great, but if you have the opportunity, wouldn’t you rather have the actual thing? If your partner is down and you’re able to make their hand fit, then check out these gloves that will make the whole process a lot cleaner and easier!
Shots Fist It Latex Gloves
These latex gloves work great with silicone lubes, meaning you won’t need to be constantly lubricating & can instead enjoy the black rubber fist in your backside!
Master Series Pleasure Fister Textured Fisting Glove
If you’re after the most varied partner hand-based penetration pleasure possible then this glove is a God-send! Each finger is shaped differently to provide different sensations when inserted, and the forearm of the glove is even ribbed for fisting-specific stimulation!
Why Do People Enjoy Fisting?
Fisting offers a couple of different benefits. For some, fisting provides added stimulation to their g or p-spot that regular penetration can’t. For others, it’s just sexy to know that they can trust their partner to safely insert their entire hand into them: trust is sexy! However, basically everyone who enjoys fisting gets a lot of pleasure from the “fullness” that the act provides.
How to Work Up to Fisting
If you want to try fisting then you’ll likely need to train up to it (unless you already use massive sex toys). The process is similar to anal training: you’ll need to determine which size you want to train up to and then purchase multiple toys that gradually work up to that size. For example, if you wanted to use the Magic Hand dildo (2.62 maximum diameter) but your current dildo was only 1.59 inches wide, you’d need to purchase a few different toys (think 1.8, 2.0, 2.2, and 2.4 inches wide). Over time you’d use progressively larger toys until you could finally fit the Magic Hand inside of you!
FAQ
What Is a Fisting Dildo?
A fisting dildo is a dildo that’s designed to look like a human hand and forearm. Generally, the dildo will be in the shape of a balled-up fist, but they also have models that feature hands in different positions as well. Some people want something a little more than your average dildo, you see. Don't get me wrong, I know that your average dildo looks and feels amazing, but there's something a little spicy about using a dildo shaped like a fist. You get a sensation that's unlike anything a dildo could give you!
Reviewed by:
Kevin Foley