The 7 Best Heart Butt Plugs for a Romantic Rear
How did I select and test the heart butt plugs in this review?
I searched far and wide to find only best heart butt plugs with the highest ratings and best customer reviews to include in this review.
As the one of the main appeals of heart butt plugs is the cute look, how they look was an important criteria when choosing the best heart shaped butt plugs to include in this review. I also ruled out any plugs made of porous or toxic materials, opting for body safe silicones or metal instead!
On top of that, I’ve included reviews from our testers who have actually tested the product and written a full, in-depth review of their experience!
What are the best materials for a heart butt plug?
As always, you should look for a body-safe, non-porous materials, such as metal (e.g. stainless steel or aluminium), silicone, or borosilicate glass.
- Silicone is more flexible so might be more comfortable in different positions. It can be boiled to be sterilised (if there are no electrical components) and should only be used with water-based lubrication.
- Metal and glass are completely rigid and feel more intense as they don’t flex to your body. They are great for temperature play and can also be boiled.
Who Can Use a Heart Butt Plug?
Anyone with a butt and a curiosity for anal play can use a heart butt plug but they are best suited to those who love the cute aesthetic! The cutesy design also makes them a great accessory for sissy play or DDLG play!
FAQ
What is a heart butt plug?
A heart butt plug is a butt plug that has a heart shaped base to add a touch of cuteness to your anal play! Many also have a heart shaped gem for a little extra sparkle and shine! They tend to made of either metal or silicone and sometimes come in a set with multiple sizes for you to progress through.
Table of contents (13)
The 7 Best Heart Butt Plugs in Test
Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Metal Butt Plug
You partner won’t be able to resist your cutie booty with this pink heart gem butt plug!
The bulb shapes creates a delicious sensation of fullness while the heart base keeps the plug safely anchored outside your body.
Made from metal, the plug is lovely and smooth and is perfect for exploring temperature play!
The Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Metal Butt Plug was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Love sleek metal plugsAre a butt plug beginnerWant to explore temperature play
Prefer a silicone plugAre more experienced with anal playPrefer a bigger base| Length | 3 inches |
| Insertable length | 2.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.1 inches |
| Waterproof | Yes |
| Materials | Metal |
Beginner-friendly sizeSmooth metalSuitable for temperature playBulbed shape for a full feelingCompatible with all lubes
Too small for those with more experienceBase could be a little biggerThis jewelled heart butt plug was a clear winner thanks to it’s cute design, great price, and approachable size!
While the plug is a beginner-friendly size, the bulb shape still provides a satisfyingly full feeling for anyone new to anal play. It might however be a little underwhelming for those with more experience.
The only thing I would improve with this plug is making the heart base just a little bigger for safety and peace of mind.
PinkCherry I Love You....Butt Red Heart Anal Plug
Channel the Queen of hearts with this racy red heart jewel butt plug!
This sleek metal plug measures 1.25 inches in diameter making it a perfect plug for those with some anal experience.
You can use any lube you like with this plug and you can even warm it or cool before use for some teasing temperature play.
The PinkCherry I Love You....Butt Red Heart Anal Plug was rated 30 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Are looking to size up from beginners toysHave some experience with anal sex Prefer metal anal plugsAre totally new to anal play Prefer a soft, silicone plugWant a vibrating plug| Length | 3.25 inches |
| Insertable length | 2.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.25 inches |
| Materials | Aluminum |
Smooth metal slides easily Bulbed shape feels filling Compatible with all lubesCan be heated or cooledSome found the base too small Might be too big for complete beginnersYou’d be hard pressed to find a cheaper heart butt plug that’s still great quality! While it might be a little big for anyone new to anal play of any kind, if you’ve had a little experience, this plug should be a great fit!
Although this is slightly bigger than the test winner, the tapered shape ensures that it’s still easy to insert, and the red heart will look super cute peeking out from between your cheeks!
First Time Fun Crystal Booty Duo Set
Unlock your inner princess with this sweet duo of silicone butt plugs with heart gems!
With two different size plugs, you can start with the smaller, beginner-friendly one and work your way up to the bigger one or share the set with a partner.
Each silicone plug is topped with a perfect pink heart gem that sparkles as you move your booty!
The First Time Fun Crystal Booty Duo Set was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want two different sized plugsPrefer silicone to metal Love the cute pink look Prefer bigger plugsWant to explore temperature play | Insertable length | Small: 2.5, Large: 3.2 inches |
| Diameter | Small: 1.1, Large: 1.4 inches |
| Waterproof | Yes |
| Materials | Plug: silicone, Gems: acrylic |
Two different sized plugsLovely soft siliconeRounded tip for comfortCute heart gem baseWill be underwhelming for more experienced usersRounded tip more difficult to insert than tapered tipThis silicone butt plug set is great if you prefer a softer, more flexible plug to a rigid metal one. The size is definitely better for beginners or anyone who enjoys a smaller toy, and I love that you can start with the smaller one before moving onto the bigger one!
The rounded ends can be more comfortable to wear in different positions as they won’t stick in as much as a tapered end. This does make them a little more difficult to insert though, so you might want to warm up with a finger or two.
b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug
Discreet shipping & billing20% off by email sign-upFREE shipping on orders $50+
Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+
Discreet shipping & billingShipping rate: $8FREE shipping on orders $99+
Discreet shipping & billingHighly ratedFREE shipping on orders $59+Beauty and the buzz! This heart butt plug from B-Vibe packs some powerful vibrations to tingle your tush and with 6 speeds and 15 patterns, there’s plenty to explore!
You can control the settings using the remote or hand it over to your partner and let them take control from up to 30 feet away.
The plug has a nice taper so it slips in easily and measures 1.45 inches at it’s widest point, putting it in the medium size range. If you’re looking for something more challenging, it’s also available in M/L version.
The b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Rating: b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is quiet.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug felt to the reviewer.
Rating: b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug was rated 4 out of 5, which means it is very powerful.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug felt to the reviewer.
Are looking for a medium sized plugWant a vibrating heart plugPrefer remote controlled toysAre totally new to anal playAre on a budget Aren't bothered about vibrations| Vibration speeds | 6 |
| Vibration patterns | 15 |
| Length | 3.85 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.1 inches |
| Diameter | 1.45 inches |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
| Materials | Silicone |
| Rechargeable | Yes |
| Battery Life | 90 minutes |
| Charging Time | 90 minutes |
| Travel Lock | Yes |
| Storage Bag Included | Yes |
Powerful vibrations Remote control Long battery lifeTravel lock Available in S/M and M/LPricey Splashproof but not waterproofToo big for anyone new to anal playWhile a lot of butt plugs are weak and buzzy, this vibrating butt plug really delivers in terms of power and vibration quality, while still being quiet enough to be discreet!
Unfortunately, that quality does come at a price and this is quite the investment, but if you love cute butt plugs and want a remote control option, this is a fantastic plug.
Our tester, Emily, loved how much extra stimulation this plug added to partnered sex and how much it intensified her orgasms.
She was also super impressed with the thoughtful extras that came with the plug, like the anal play guidebook and storage bag!
While this is listed as a small/medium it is definitely more of a medium and is likely to be a little big for complete beginners, so keep that in mind when deciding if this is heart shaped butt plug for you.
Booty Sparks Pink Heart Plug Set
Take your butt on pleasure journey with this heart butt plug set.
The kit contains three different sized plugs for you to slowly progress through. The small measures just 1 inch in diameter and 2.4 inches insertable length, making it perfect for beginners who want to work up to bigger things!
The large measures a juicy 1.5 inches in diameter and 3.4 inches in insertable length, giving you a satisfying stretch to look forward to!
The plugs are made of smooth sleek metal that feels fantastic when heated or cooled in water before use!
The Booty Sparks Pink Heart Plug Set was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want a training setPrefer metal butt plugsWant to try temperature play Only want one plugPrefer silicone or flexible plug| Length | Small: 2.8, Medium: 3.2, Large: 3.7 inches |
| Insertable length | Small: 2.4, Medium: 3, Large: 3.4 inches |
| Diameter | Small: 1, Medium: 1.3, Large: 1.5 inches |
| Waterproof | Yes |
| Materials | Aluminium alloy |
Three sizes to explorePerfect for anal training Suitable for temperature play Filling bulbed shapeMight not be big enough for more experienced usersThis set really puts a cute twist on anal training kits! It’s a great option for anal play newbies who wants to slowly build up to anal sex or using bigger anal toys. The small size is really non-intimidating and a great way to get accustomed to anal plugs.
However, if you are looking for an anal training kit for more experienced users who want a challenge, this isn’t going to satisfy and you should look for something a little bigger!
This is a little pricier than some of the other products in this review but when you consider you are getting three plugs, it’s actually very good value for money!
Play With Me Naughtier Candy Hearts Silicone Butt Plugs
Get cheeky with this candy heart plug that comes with a naughty message on the base that tells your partner exactly what you want them to do!
Made of body-safe silicone, the plug features a finely tapered end to help the plug slip in easily. It measures 1.6 inches in diameter and 3 inches in insertable length so this one for those with more anal experience!
Plus the plug is easy to clean and can even be boiled to be sterilised.
The Play With Me Naughtier Candy Hearts Silicone Butt Plugs was rated 60 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Have considerable anal play experienceLove the cheeky messageEnjoy silicone butt plugsAren't comfortable with larger anal toysPrefer a metal plugWant a vibrating toy| Length | 4.25 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.75 inches |
| Diameter | 1.75 inches |
| Waterproof | Yes |
| Materials | Silicone |
Sexy message on the baseTapered tip for easy insertion Body safe siliconeDifficult to clean lube out of the letteringPointed tip can be uncomfortable in some positionsAs this is one of the biggest plugs in this review, this is a really great option if you have some more anal play experience or are looking for a more intense stretch.
The end is quite dramatically tapered to help with insertion but there is the possibility for it to dig in certain positions.
I really love the nod to candy hearts and the cheeky message on the base but it can be difficult to clean out the lettering, so try not to get any lube in there.
Rear Assets Small Jeweled Rainbow Heart Butt Plug
Ride the rainbow to pleasure town! It really doesn’t get any cuter than than rainbows and sparkly heart gems!
This beautiful butt plug measures 1 inch at it’s widest point, making it a great first time butt plug.
The aluminium slides easily with a slick of lube and holds temperature well for some tantalising temperature play.