The 5 Best Horse Tail Butt Plugs for Pleasing Pony Play
| Test Winner | Cheapest | Unicorn | Metal | Vibrating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |  |
| Pink Pony Butt Plug | gläs Butt Plug | Rainbow Pony Tail | Rosebuds Anal Plug | Pony Vibrating Plug |
| Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
Horse tail butt plugs; how I tested 'em!
I tested and reviewed these horse tail butt plugs by first asking the opinions of the people who have actually used them. They provided their own unbiased and honest opinions! I then took a closer look at each of the toys in order to find out as much as I could about them. This also meant that I was able to rate them in a few key areas, including quality, ease of use, and even price. So not only was I able to provide you with a detailed and in-depth review, but I also included a star rating that you could look at and understand at only a glance. You’re welcome!
What to Look for in a Horse Tail Butt Plug
When shopping for horse tail butt plugs, there are several things that you need to consider before you buy. So here are a few of the main things you need to bear in mind!
- Size – You can get big butt plugs and small but plugs, and which you choose all comes down to what you can and can’t handle. If you’re a beginner, I’d recommend going with a smaller one. You can always work your way up to something larger!
- Materials – Are you looking for a soft and flexible butt plug material, or would you prefer something harder and more unforgiving?
- Design – Your eyes are going to be the first things that really enjoy these horse tail butt plugs, so make sure that it’s a design that you love. Think about how it will look while it’s inside you or your partner!
- Color – The color of your tail matters! Do you want something bright and unmissable, or do you want something darker and more natural? There are lots of options, so make your choice!
- Length of tail – Some tails are longer than others, and it’s down to you to think about whether you want a longer more swishy one, or something shorter and more perky. Both have their pros and cons!
Table of contents (11)
The 5 Best horse tail butt plugs in Test
Tailz Pink Pony Faux Fur Butt Plug
5% coupon available
Show coupon
Coupon verified
Enjoy hot equine action in a fun, flirty color with the Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug With Pink Pony Faux Fur Tail! Braid it, brush it, swish it, show it off! The tail is a full 20 inches of synthetic fiber, topped with a phthalate-free and silky smooth silicone plug. The classic spade shape inserts easily, with a flared base to keep it firmly in place.
The Tailz Pink Pony Faux Fur Butt Plug was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
| Materials | Silicone and faux fur |
| Length | 24.25 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.5 inches |
| Width | 1.3 inches |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
The Tailz Pink Pony Faux Fur Butt Plug is a bright and colorful butt plug that will certainly catch your eye. The length is fantastic, and the silicone butt plug will sit comfortably inside of you. I like that it is made of premium silicone, making it not only lifelike and natural feeling, but also giving a certain amount of flexibility to it, too. The faux fur feels pretty realistic, and can easily be styled and made to look however you want it to look. It gives you some great customization options! I can see why not everyone will like the Tailz Pink Pony Faux Fur Butt Plug – it is a little bright and garish, and won’t suit everyone. Also, those that want a harder butt plug sliding back there may not find it to be tough enough. But for most people, the Tailz Pink Pony Faux Fur Butt Plug is a winner that will feel great time after time!
gläs Horse Tail Butt Plug
Sized for anal players with at least a little experience under the belt, the chubby gläs Horse Tail Butt Plug will definitely stretch and stimulate, plus, the neck is a little thicker than average. Pop it into place with the help of some slippery lube, and enjoy! A nice big circular base helps prevent any too-deep slips, so you can play worry-free. Tug and twist the tail for some deep-down stimulation.
The gläs Horse Tail Butt Plug was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
| Materials | Glass and faux fur |
| Length | 24 inches |
| Insertable length | 2.4 inches |
| Width | 1.5 inches |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
For a horse tail butt plug that will not only please your ass, but also your wallet, then check out the gläs Horse Tail Butt Plug! Not only is it super affordable, but it also works pretty well too. The glass looks great and feels firm and secure inside your butt, and the long sail swishes nicely between your legs, allowing the plug to be gently pulled on while wearing it. It’s definitely fun…but I can’t say that it’s the most fun anal toy that I’ve ever reviewed. I will admit that while the design of the gläs Horse Tail Butt Plug is pretty simple and straightforward, it’s also not very inspiring or interesting, which might turn some people off to this particular horse tail butt plug. Also, the quality of the faux fur could be higher. Still, for the price, you can’t complain toooo much!
Tailz Rainbow Pony Faux Fur Tail
5% coupon availableShow coupon
Coupon verified
Enjoy hot equine action in a fun, flirty color with the Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug With Rainbow Pony Faux Fur Tail! Braid it, brush it, swish it, show it off! The tail is a full 20 inches of synthetic fiber, topped with a phthalate-free and silky smooth silicone plug. The classic spade shape inserts easily, with a flared base to keep it firmly in place.
The Tailz Rainbow Pony Faux Fur Tail was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
| Materials | Silicone and faux fur |
| Length | 24.25 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.5 inches |
| Width | 1.3 inches |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
There’s nothing better than a brightly colored horse tail butt plug, and that’s exactly what you get with the Tailz Rainbow Pony Faux Fur Tail. It has that bright and eye-catching unicorn coloration and a fantastic length to both the tail AND the plug itself. I love the high quality of this toy, and I especially like how you get quality like this for such a relatively normal price. Some would say that because of how this butt plug looks, it’s gay pride friendly, which I would agree with, though that should not limit it to just gay people. Anyone can enjoy it! There will be those that are looking for a more natural colored horse tail butt plug, but if that doesn’t matter to you, then the Tailz Rainbow Pony Faux Fur Tail is one that I would highly recommend.
Julian Snelling Rosebuds Anal Plug
10% coupon available
Show coupon
Coupon verified
Pony play and anal fun unite in this elegant Stainless Steel Horse Hair Anal Plug by Rosebuds. This well crafted, nicely weighted plug has a pleasing tear drop shape for ease of entry. The slim post that connects to the tail ensures this plug will stay right where you want it while you play as hard as you like. While the sensation is similar to other plugs, this French design is far and away the choice for chic, yet quirky adventuring.
The Julian Snelling Rosebuds Anal Plug was rated 60 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
| Materials | Metal and faux fur |
| Length | 18.5 inches |
| Insertable length | 2.75 inches |
| Width | 1.2 inches |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
If you love the feel of steel then the Julian Snelling Rosebuds Anal Plug is a great cool choice. Made out of stainless steel it is heavy and can be used for temperature play. That is of course attached to a long and elegant tail, that swishes sexily as your body moves. I will say that the quality of this butt plug is super high, and it does feel fantastic. However, the biggest issue with the Julian Snelling Rosebuds Anal Plug is that it is very expensive, for what it is. Also, the design is not the most fun or interesting, meaning that it’s not going to grab anyone’s attention, really. Does it work? Undoubtedly! But you can definitely get a butt plug that feels just the same but looks better for a far cheaper price.
Tailz Rainbow Pony Vibrating Anal Plug
When the sun goes down and the moon comes up, all the animals come out to play – and that goes for the mythical/magical ones, too! Rouse your inner rainbow pony with this premium pleasure tool meets dress up (dress down, more like) showstopper from Tailz. Inside, you or you and your partner will find a super sexy vibrating silicone butt plug in deep black.
The Tailz Rainbow Pony Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
| Materials | |
| Length | inches |
| Insertable length | inches |
| Width | inches |
| Waterproof |
The Tailz Rainbow Pony Vibrating Anal Plug is a pretty damn solid vibrator. The materials are all very high quality and look fantastic, and the best part is that this is a very versatile vibrator. It has many different speed and pattern functions that can all be controlled by the handy remote control. That means that you can even give it to a partner to let them be in charge! The only downside that I can see is that not everyone wants their horse tail butt plug to vibrate, so if that’s the case, then this might not be the one for you. Overall, though, the Tailz Rainbow Pony Vibrating Anal Plug is a fun, exciting, and sexily realistic butt plug that will leave you buzzing. Literally. This isn’t a difficult choice!
Comparison of the 5 best horse tail butt plugs
| Best | Test Winner | Cheapest | Unicorn | Metal | Vibrating |
| Overall score | - | 3.5 / 5.0 | 4.8 / 5.0 | 4.3 / 5.0 | 5.0 / 5.0 |
| Bedbible rating | 5.0 / 5.0 | 4.0 / 5.0 | 5.0 / 5.0 | 3.5 / 5.0 | 5.0 / 5.0 |
| User rating | - | 3 / 5.0 from 1 users | 4.5 / 5.0 from 8 users | 5 / 5.0 from 1 users | 5 / 5.0 from 2 users |
| Price | Low | Low | Low | Medium | Low |
| Design | 90 / 100 | 70 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 95 / 100 |
| Ease of use | 90 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 90 / 100 |
| Quality | 95 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 95 / 100 |
| Sound | - | - | - | - | - |
| Power | - | - | - | - | - |
| Buzzy/Rumbly | - | - | - | - | - |
| Materials | Silicone and faux fur | Glass and faux fur | Silicone and faux fur | Metal and faux fur | null |
| Length | 24.25 inches | 24 inches | 24.25 inches | 18.5 inches | null inches |
| Insertable length | 3.5 inches | 2.4 inches | 3.5 inches | 2.75 inches | null inches |
| Width | 1.3 inches | 1.5 inches | 1.3 inches | 1.2 inches | null inches |
| Waterproof | Splashproof | Splashproof | Splashproof | Splashproof | null |
Embrace Your Inner Unicorn!
There’s nothing quite like letting your imagination run free and embracing your inner unicorn! Here’s a tail that will help you do just that!
Unicorn Plug Limited Edition Set
Featuring a uniquely magical twist texture to our medium-sized plug, this vibrating hole horn is specially designed to send you into euphoria with 6 vibration patterns and 10 levels of intensity. Find a treasure trove of fun at the end of the rainbow with the plug’s 19″ removable tail. Made from easy-to-wash synthetic fibers, the multicolor locks are perfect for fantasy play and can be easily removed to enjoy your mystical plug anywhere.
More Kinky Accessories to Complete Your Pony Play
If you really want to up your pony play, then here are a few more accessories that will really help you out!
Rubber Bit Trainer Gag
The Rubber Bit Trainer Gag is an adjustable, locking bit gag in a head-harness style. This item uses a stylish rubber horse-bit for the mouthpiece, much like The Rubber Bit Gag, but this trainer version incorporates a head harness as well. The black leather straps go over and around the head and neck, as well as under the chin. This gag features two lockable buckles for added security.
Leather Leash
This 2.5-foot leather bondage leash is about 0.75 inches wide, with a wrist loop on one end, and a solid claw-style spring hook on the other end for easy attachment to a bondage collar or fetishwear harness. Available in black or red leather. Use two leashes together (simply attach one on each side of a head harness or bit gag) as reigns for pony play to ride and guide your pony during training.
Pony Head Bridle
You could search the finest stables in the world for the rest of your life and never find a bridle set as intricate and beautiful as this one. Crafted by Stockroom’s in-house design team, this set consists of a harness, a blindfold, blinders, and a muzzle. The harness has four adjustable straps: three to fit snugly around the skull, and one to secure under the chin.
Bondage Boutique Slim Leather Riding Crop
The crop’s curved wooden handle and the leather wrist loop give you a firm grip every time, meaning you can dish out your punishments with accuracy. An extra-long flexible stem is superb for stark slapping, sharp spanking or gentle teasing, while the classically-slim leather tip is the perfect thickness for creating that kinky thwip-thwack sound.
How to use horse tail butt plugs
You may find yourself wondering about how you actually use horse tail butt plugs. Well, I’m here to tell you exactly how it’s done!
Choose wisely!
With so many horse tail butt plugs out there it can get a little wild when trying to choose the perfect one for you and your partner! Make sure that you consider everything that you can in order to make the best choice! Start off small and work your way up until you can’t take any more!
Lube up!
Lubrication is one of the most important things that you can use! It keeps things slippery and sliding along nicely. The idea is to avoid any kind of friction that may cause you any pain or damage. A good water-based lube is definitely the way to go with these horse tail butt plugs!
Insert and enjoy!
Now that your plug is all lubed up, slowly and gently insert it and enjoy the sensation of being filled up. You’re going to feel that horse tail dangling down against you, brushing your skin and tickling and teasing you. They’re certainly fun! Just keep things safe and you’re sure to have an amazing time!
How to clean horse tail butt plugs
Keeping your horse tail butt plugs nice and clean is super important if you want to keep using them time after time. So here's a handy chart that will help you keep these toys (and all of your sex toys, for that matter) nice and clean and sanitized.
materials
Soft plastic, hard plastic, jelly, rubber, Cyberskin are all porous materials, meaning that small particles and bacteria can penetrate the surface. This makes it impossible to completely clean these types of materials.
Therefore, it is recommended that you use a condom with these types of toys, especially if you are sharing them. Clean these toys with mild soapy water and dry gently with a towel. These materials are more easily damaged, so be sure to be gentle and make sure your toys are completely dry before storing.
materials
Silicone, glass, stainless steel and some hard plastics can all be washed using a mild soap (like you would use on your body) and warm water. Just be careful if your toy contains electrical parts.
Silicone and stainless steel toys without any electrical parts can also be boiled for sterilisation.
components
If your toys contain electrical components, be extra careful when cleaning them and always check the instructions provided with the toy. You can use a gentle cloth and soap to wipe or sex toy cleaner or cleaning wipe to down your toy, making sure that no water comes into contact with the electrical parts.
FAQ
What are horse tail butt plugs?
Horse tail butt plugs are a kind of anal toy that allows you to live out your animalistic side! They are butt plugs with long, faux fur horse tails attached to the back! These toys are fantastic for pony play and living out your fantasies!