The 7 Best Penis Butt Plugs for Phallic Filling

Kevin Foley
by Kevin Foley
best penis butt plug in test
As the name implies, a penis shaped buttplug is a penis butt plug that’s at least partially shaped like a penis! Just like with real penises, these toys come in all different shapes and sizes, which can make finding an option you like quite overwhelming. Fortunately, I’ll be going over a bunch of different penis shaped butt plugs today to help you find the right one for you. While some of you may be going purely for size, others may be more interested in visual accuracy. Don’t worry: I’ve found an option for everyone! If you’re just looking to buy one right away, I recommend the “Test Winner” plug, the Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug. Offering 2” of width and an insertable length of 5.25”, it’s a good go-to option. Of course, there are many more products out there, each with its own pros and cons. Keep reading if you’d like to learn about the various butt plug penis toys around (and find your new favorite toy!).
Test WinnerCheapestVibratingGlassGirthyFantasyLarge
Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug
Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug
Vibrating Anal Plug
Glass Penis Anal Plug
Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug
The Sentio
The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug
Fluke Silicone Dildo PlugPlatinum Silicone Rocket PlugVibrating Anal PlugGlass Penis Anal PlugHoncho 1 Rainbow Butt PlugThe SentioThe Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug
Check priceCheck priceCheck priceCheck priceCheck priceCheck priceCheck price

How I Rated Each Penis Butt Plug

I’ve assessed each penis butt plug the same way, for the sake of fairness. There were a number of different standardized factors that I used to rate each plug, such as value for money and overall quality.

Of course, relying on my own opinions entirely would be sure to produce biased results, which is why I used a number of different sources to gather information.

By comparing the manufacturer information against the feedback of real-life customers, I was able to separate the advertisements from the reality (which is reflected in the pros & cons of each butt plug penis toy!).

When comparing your options, I strongly recommend reading all the way through before making your decision. Each product has its own strengths and weaknesses, making it extremely important to know the full story about each one before deciding!

How I Rated Each Penis Butt Plug

FAQ

Are all penis butt plugs textured?
No. Most plugs are smooth, but others may feature textures on part of—or even the entirety of—the plug.
What lube can I use with my penis butt plug?
It depends entirely on the material(s) your plug is made from! I recommend sticking to water-based lubricant as this is safe with all sex toy materials.
What’s the best material for a penis butt plug?
Non-porous materials like metal, glass, or silicone are best. Porous materials like PVC are also an option, but these can contain unwanted chemicals and harbor bacteria.
How long can I wear a penis butt plug?
Opinions vary depending on who you ask. While experts state maximum limits ranging from as little as 30 minutes to as long as two hours, how long you can wear the plug really depends on personal limitations. That said, I do not recommend wearing a plug overnight (and don’t forget to re-apply lube as needed!).
Who can a penis butt plug?
Anyone can use a penis butt plug! However, the ones that you personally can use will vary depending on your previous experience and physical limitations. Fortunately, there are many different sizes of plugs offered, so finding one that will work for you shouldn’t be too hard!

What is a Penis Butt Plug?

A penis butt plug is a type of butt plug that’s shaped like a penis. With some plugs, the entire bulb may be molded to mimic a penis. With others, only the head shape is used. These plugs are available in a wide variety of sizes. While the shorter ones function solely as plugs, the longer ones can also double as anal dildos.

Table of contents (14)

The 7 Best penis butt plugs in Test

1 Test Winner

Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug

Design:

Rating: Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 80 out of 100, which means it is designed very well.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

80/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is extremely easy to use and worked very well.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

90/100
Quality:

Rating: Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 100 out of 100, which means it is one of the absolute top quality toys.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

100/100
Price:

Rating: Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 3 out of 5, which means it neither expensive nor cheap.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

Medium
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 4.5 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug.

4.5/5.0

User rating:

Rating: Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 5.0 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

5.0/5.0

Sources
Rating star5/5SheVibe (4)

The first butt plug penis toy I’ll be showing you today is the Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug!

Being hand-poured by Hole Punch Studios themselves, every toy comes from a small batch of artisanal sex toys, ensuring that your new penis butt plug will be a top-tier product.

With a total length of 5.75 inches, an insertable length of 5.25 inches, and a maximum width of 2 inches, this plug should more than fill you up!

If you’re on the hunt for a quality silicone plug that can also double as a strap-on dildo, your search ends here: pick up the Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug today!

Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug test
Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug features
Recommended for the intermediate user

The Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug was rated 50 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug if you...
You should buyLove wider plugs
You should buyWant a semi-realistic toy
You should buyEnjoy the gradient design
You should NOT buy the Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug if you...
You should NOT buyPrefer longer toys
You should NOT buyPrimarily use silicone lube
You should NOT buyNeed a more affordable option
Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug features
Features
MaterialsSilicone 
Length5.5 inches
Insertable length5.25 inches
Diameter2 inches
FlexibilityExtra firm 
AllergiesPhthalate-free 
Pros
ProsMade of silicone
ProsHarness-compatible
ProsMax width of 2”
ProsHand-poured
Cons
ConsLimited color options
ConsMid-priced
Conclusion

As a solid all-around anal toy, the Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug easily earned the “Test Winner” title. Due to its unique dimensions, this penis shaped buttplug easily serves two purposes, either as a dildo or as a butt plug.

As a plug, it’s an excellent anal-safe option, complete with a flared base for safe insertion. This flared base also comes in handy when you’re using it as a dildo since it can be used for strap-on mounting.

However, as noted by a few customers, the length of these penis shaped butt plugs makes them slightly less optimal as dildos. While 5.25” of insertable length isn’t short, it’s definitely harder to work with than longer toys.

Still, I think this toy is an excellent general-purpose option. Held to the highest of standards and sizable enough to provide you with hours of pleasure, I can’t recommend the Hole Punch Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug enough!

2 Cheapest

Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug

Design:

Rating: Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 80 out of 100, which means it is designed very well.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

80/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is extremely easy to use and worked very well.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

90/100
Quality:

Rating: Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is one of the absolute top quality toys.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

90/100
Price:

Rating: Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is cheap compared to other penis butt plugs.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

Low
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 4.3 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug.

4.3/5.0

User rating:

Rating: Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 0 out of 5, which means it is a very bad product.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

N/A

Next up, we have the Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug. It may be a little bit less “true to life” than the competition, but it’s just as satisfying as the other options on this list!

This penis shaped buttplug has ridges in all the right places, paired perfectly with a tapered tip that helps make insertion easier.

Sporting a maximum diameter of 2 inches with an insertable length of nearly six inches, this toy is slightly larger than my first pick.

Even better? This toy has also earned the “Cheapest” title! Coming in at less than $30, you’ll definitely want to pick up one of these penis shaped butt plugs for yourself.

Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug test
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug features
Recommended for the intermediate user

The Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug was rated 55 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug if you...
You should buyPrefer lengthy toys
You should buyLove plugs with ridges
You should buyNeed a budget-friendly option
You should NOT buy the Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug if you...
You should NOT buyStruggle with thicker plugs
You should NOT buyPrefer smooth plugs
You should NOT buyWant advanced features
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Rocket Plug features
Features
MaterialsSilicone 
Length6.5 inches
Insertable length5.75 inches
Diameter2 inches
AllergiesLatex & phthalate-free 
Pros
ProsAffordable
ProsMade of Ultrasilk™ Silicone
ProsMax diameter of 2 inches
ProsTapered tip
Cons
ConsNo color options
ConsNot harness compatible
ConsCould look more realistic
Conclusion

Being so budget-friendly, you might be thinking that the bar was set pretty low for this particular penis butt plug. Fortunately, the truth is quite the opposite!

Despite the low price, this toy is made completely from UltraSilk Silicone. This offers a few different benefits, including a nice touch, a smooth surface, and a high level of long-term reliability.

I don’t really have many complaints about this toy. It doesn’t offer anything special, but it doesn’t try to either. True, the toy doesn’t quite offer six inches of insertable length. Still, that’s just nitpicking!

In truth, my only real complaint with this butt plug penis toy is the fact that it could have been designed to look a little more realistic. However, if you just want to pick up a high-quality toy on a budget, I think you’ll be more than happy with this option.

3 Vibrating

Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug

Design:

Rating: Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 85 out of 100, which means it is designed absolutely incredible.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

85/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is extremely easy to use and worked very well.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

90/100
Quality:

Rating: Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 80 out of 100, which means it is very good quality.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

80/100
Price:

Rating: Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is priced in the middle.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

Low
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 4.2 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the Vibrating Anal Plug.

4.2/5.0

User rating:

Rating: Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 0 out of 5, which means it is a very bad product.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

N/A

Plain in person but effective in practice, the Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug is a butt plug penis toy that vibrates.

Those who don’t like having to fiddle with controls they can’t see will appreciate this toy, as this penis butt plug uses only one button to control the single-speed bullet vibe.

The vibe itself slides up inside the plug, which is shaped like a penis and measures roughly six inches long.

With 4.5 inches of insertable length and a maximum diameter of 1.5 inches, this Tom’s toy certainly isn’t the biggest around. However, for those who just want something simple, this plug is the perfect option!

Recommended for the beginner and intermediate

The Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 30 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
The vibrations of the Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug are quiet, quite powerful, and somewhat buzzy
Sound:

Rating: Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is quiet.

What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug felt to the reviewer.

Sound ratingSound ratingSound ratingSound ratingSound rating
Power:

Rating: Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug was rated 3 out of 5, which means it is quite powerful.

What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug felt to the reviewer.

Sound ratingSound ratingSound ratingPower ratingPower rating
Buzzy
What it is: Buzzy vibrators have a high frequency that stimulates the surface (like a high pitch).
Rumbly
What it is: Rumbly vibrators have low-frequency vibrations that stimulate deeper into the tissue (like the bass in music).
You should buy the Vibrating Anal Plug if you...
You should buyWant a simple but effective toy
You should buyDon’t need color options
You should buyDon’t mind a single-speed vibe
You should NOT buy the Vibrating Anal Plug if you...
You should NOT buyNeed a waterproof toy
You should NOT buyWant a harness-compatible plug
You should NOT buyPrefer having multiple vibe speeds
Features
MaterialsSilicone, ABS plastic 
Length6 inches
Insertable length4.5 inches
Diameter1.5 inches
Vibration modes1 
RechargeableNo (powered by 2 x AA) 
AllergiesPhthalate-free 
Pros
ProsRealistically-shaped design
ProsAffordable
ProsEasy to clean
ProsFrom a reputable company
Cons
ConsSingle-speed vibrations
ConsPowered by batteries
ConsNo color options
Conclusion

The Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug is a simple penis shaped buttplug that you’ll either love or hate: no exceptions.

On the positive side, this plug is extremely easy to use. A single button can turn the vibrations on or off, and the plug’s size is “bigger” but still manageable. Cleaning is easy as well, and the toy can even be sterilized.

However, that’s just one way to look at it. Alternatively, these penis shaped butt plugs don’t offer any vibrational variety, are only offered in black, and are too small to satisfy those who’re after the most “filling” experience.

Ultimately, whether or not you should pick up this toy depends on what you want. Looking for a large toy with tons of vibrations? If so, pass on this one.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a simple toy that will get the job done without any complications, the Tom of Finland Vibrating Anal Plug is worth a second glance.

After all, there’s a reason it won the “Vibrating” mention: even single-speed vibrations can be quite satisfying!

4 Glass

Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug

Design:

Rating: Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is designed absolutely incredible.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

90/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is extremely easy to use and worked very well.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

90/100
Quality:

Rating: Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is one of the absolute top quality toys.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

90/100
Price:

Rating: Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is priced in the middle.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

Low
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 4.5 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the Glass Penis Anal Plug.

4.5/5.0

User rating:

Rating: Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 5.0 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

5.0/5.0

Sources

The Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug is entirely different from any other penis shaped buttplug on this list.

Made completely out of glass, this non-porous plug is easy to clean and pretty to look at.

Unlike many other penis shaped butt plugs, this plug is also suitable for temperature play, giving you tons of more options when it comes to backdoor antics.

Despite being made of glass, this plug is still offered at a fair price, making it a great option for anyone who wants to buy their first glass plug.

Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug test
Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug features
Recommended for the intermediate user

The Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug was rated 50 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the Glass Penis Anal Plug if you...
You should buyPrefer easy-to-clean toys
You should buyLike using different lube types
You should buyEnjoy temperature play
You should NOT buy the Glass Penis Anal Plug if you...
You should NOT buyPrefer longer plugs
You should NOT buyWant color options
You should NOT buyAren’t comfortable with glass toys
Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug features
Features
MaterialsGlass 
Length5 inches
Insertable length4.5 inches
Diameter1.85 inches
FlexibilityRigid 
AllergiesNon-porous 
Pros
ProsMade of glass
ProsCan be sterilized
ProsLoosely resembles a penis tip
Pros1.85” of width
Cons
ConsOnly offered in “clear”
ConsNo sizing options
ConsDoesn’t include storage case
Conclusion

As our only glass plug on this list, it’s obvious why I’ve chosen the Prisms Erotic Glass Penis Anal Plug as my “Glass” pick. However, there were a few less obvious reasons why I chose this plug specifically.

First, the price is great. At less than $40, you receive a premium butt plug penis toy made of damage-resistance glass. Glass itself is an excellent sex toy material, providing both unique looks and a streamlined cleaning experience for the user.

It’s also effective at retaining temperatures, meaning you can heat—or chill—this penis butt plug to the ideal temperature before insertion. Essentially, what I’m trying to say is this plug offers a lot of value for the money.

Granted, it only has 4.5 inches of insertable length and is slightly skinnier than some of the alternative options. However, if you’re interested in having more play options available to you beyond simple silicone, I think you should add this plug to your collection.

5 Girthy

Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug

Design:

Rating: Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 100 out of 100, which means it is designed absolutely incredible.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

100/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is extremely easy to use and worked very well.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

90/100
Quality:

Rating: Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is one of the absolute top quality toys.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

90/100
Price:

Rating: Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 3 out of 5, which means it neither expensive nor cheap.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

Medium
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 4.6 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug.

4.6/5.0

User rating:

Rating: Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 5.0 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

5.0/5.0

SheVibe
ProsDiscreet shipping & billing​ProsTheir website ROCKS!ProsFREE shipping on orders $68+
Check price
Spectrumboutique
ProsDiscreet shipping & billingProsShipping rate: $8ProsFREE shipping on orders $99+
Check price
PeepShowToys
ProsDiscreet shipping & billing​ProsOnly body-safe materialsProsFREE shipping on orders $70+
Check price

The Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug is one of the most visually impressive penis butt plug toys you can get your hands on!

Offered in a bright rainbow blend as well as a plain black, this silicone butt plug penis toy is perfect for those who like realism in their toys.

The plug itself is highly detailed, taking the basic shape of a penis and adding in veins for a more stimulating texture.

Easy to clean, perfect for long-term wear, and offered in three different sizes, the Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug is an excellent option for those seeking a high-quality silicone plug.

Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug test
Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug features
Recommended for the beginner and intermediate

The Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug was rated 35 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug if you...
You should buyAppreciate realistic detailing
You should buyWant a choice in sizing & color
You should buyNeed a plug for long-term wear
You should NOT buy the Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug if you...
You should NOT buyPrefer using silicone lubes
You should NOT buyDon’t like textured toys
You should NOT buyWant a different color option
Oxballs Honcho 1 Rainbow Butt Plug features
Features
MaterialsSilicone 
Length4.75 inches
Insertable length4 inches
Diameter1.75 inches
Weight0.38 lbs
AllergiesPhthalate-free 
Pros
ProsOffered in multiple sizes
ProsTwo color options
ProsVery detailed design
ProsMade of silicone
Cons
ConsShorter than alternative options
ConsSomewhat pricey
ConsMax diameter of 1.75”
Conclusion

It’s hard to complain about this penis shaped buttplug. There aren’t any issues with sizing because it’s offered in three different sizes.

That’s actually the main factor that won it the “Girthy” mention. Although not every size is thicker than some of the other options, you do get to choose how thick you want the plug to be. That’s much better than being stuck with a single thickness!

You could complain about the color options, but you at least get the choice between a bright rainbow blend and a plain black (which is more choice than many other toys offer!).

Each one of these penis shaped butt plugs is handmade using platinum silicone, meaning they’re completely body-safe as well. Really, the only thing I can find fault with is the price.

Approaching $70, this plug is a bit more pricey than most of the alternatives. However, once you factor in the materials used and the fact that it’s handcrafted, even that seems like a fairly irrelevant complaint.

So, is this plug worth picking up? Well, if you like one of the two colors offered, want a choice of sizing options, and don’t mind using a silicone-friendly lubricant, I would say you should add it to your cart!

6 Fantasy

The Sentio 5" Silicone Dildo-Plug

Design:

Rating: The Sentio was rated 95 out of 100, which means it is designed absolutely incredible.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

95/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: The Sentio was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is extremely easy to use and worked very well.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

90/100
Quality:

Rating: The Sentio was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is one of the absolute top quality toys.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

90/100
Price:

Rating: The Sentio was rated 5 out of 5, which means it is very expensive.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

High
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: The Sentio was rated 4.5 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the The Sentio.

4.5/5.0

User rating:

Rating: The Sentio was rated 0 out of 5, which means it is a very bad product.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

N/A

This next plug earned the “Fantasy” title, and a single glance at it should tell you why: the colors look like something out of this world!

Swirls and ripples of blue and green brighten the head of The Sentio 5″ Silicone Dildo-Plug, making it easily stand out from the other penis shaped butt plugs in your collection.

Harness-compatible, extremely soft, and easy to clean, this penis shaped buttplug is a great option for those who want long-term comfort in a plug.

The cherry on top? The Sentio has the shape of the penis down to a T, complete with ridges around the head for added realism. Who knew fantasy could look this lifelike!?

The Sentio 5" Silicone Dildo-Plug test
The Sentio 5" Silicone Dildo-Plug features
Recommended for the beginner and intermediate

The The Sentio 5" Silicone Dildo-Plug was rated 35 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the The Sentio if you...
You should buyWant a colorful toy
You should buyPrefer a soft silicone
You should buyNeed a toy for Kegels
You should NOT buy the The Sentio if you...
You should NOT buyPrefer firmer silicone
You should NOT buyWant more than 4.5” of insertable length
You should NOT buyDon’t like flared bases
The Sentio 5" Silicone Dildo-Plug features
Features
MaterialsSilicone 
Length5 inches
Insertable length4.5 inches
Diameter1.67 inches
AllergiesPhthalate-free 
Pros
ProsBeautiful color scheme
ProsDual-purpose
ProsHarness-compatible
ProsAnal-safe
Cons
ConsExpensive
ConsNo sizing options
Conclusion

The main thing that will prevent people from adding The Sentio to their collections is the price. At nearly $100, this butt plug penis toy definitely isn’t the cheapest option around.

That said, you do get an extremely high-quality fantasy toy for the price. The actual design of The Sentio is beautiful, highlighting the blues and greens used in the handcrafted toy while leaving the toy as a whole open to interpretation (or inner fantasies!).

The plug is extremely soft, which is great for when you’re using it as a plug. However, this softness could pose some issues if you’re solely using the plug as a strap-on (it’s harness compatible).

With 4.5” of insertable length and 1.75” of diameter, I would consider this toy closer to a penis butt plug than an actual dildo. Still, you can certainly use it either way.

If you’re searching for a premium toy that not only looks amazing but feels great during use, The Sentio is an excellent mid-sized option to consider.

7 Large

Titanmen - The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug

Design:

Rating: The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 90 out of 100, which means it is designed absolutely incredible.

What it is: The design rating takes into account the shape of the toy in both a visual and ergonomic perspective. We ask our reviewers to rate the overall feeling of the penis butt plug.

90/100
Ease of Use:

Rating: The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 80 out of 100, which means it is very easy to figure out and use.

What it is: The Ease of Use rating is a score given on how easy the toy is to operate and use. Aspects that are considered is the suitability for different kinds of people, intuitiveness, and potential learning curve of using the product for pleasure (or pain).

80/100
Quality:

Rating: The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 80 out of 100, which means it is very good quality.

What it is: The Quality rating is a score that takes into account the quality of the materials used in the toy, how well it was manufactured, the safety, durability and overall quality feel of the toy.

80/100
Price:

Rating: The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is cheap compared to other penis butt plugs.

What it is: The Price rating is indicated by 1-5 price icons. 1 indicate a very cheap product, while 5 indicate a very expensive product. The rating is a relative score compared to other similar toys.

Low
Price ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice ratingPrice rating
Bedbible rating:

Rating: The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 4.1 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The Bedbible rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. 1 indicates a very bad product, while 5 indicate a very good product. It is the overall rating given by our tester which makes it a very subjective score of the The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug.

4.1/5.0

User rating:

Rating: The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 4.5 out of 5, which means it is amongst the absolute best of toys that I can absolutely recommend you try out.

What it is: The User rating is indicated by 1-5 stars. The score is an aggregated rating of all online ratings. We find and aggregate all ratings based on a weighting system that takes into account how many reviews are available at each source.

4.5/5.0

Sources
Rating star4.5/5Lovehoney.com (66)

Want a butt plug penis toy that has both length and girth to offer? If so, then The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug is for you!

Measuring 7 inches long with a maximum diameter of 2.2 inches, this penis butt plug isn’t for the inexperienced.

However, experienced users will quickly fall in love with the dual-bulb design of this toy.

While the first bulb is modeled after a penis head, the second bulb is a simple bulb that will give you that filling feeling you’re after.

Sure, you could settle for a plug that has only length or width to offer, but there’s honestly no need.

Enjoy the best of both worlds with The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug!

Titanmen - The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug test
Titanmen - The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug features
Recommended for the intermediate and advanced

The Titanmen - The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug was rated 80 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug if you...
You should buyLove larger toys
You should buyDon’t mind using lots of lube
You should buyNeed something budget-friendly
You should NOT buy the The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug if you...
You should NOT buyWant a silicone plug
You should NOT buyPrefer a single-bulb design
You should NOT buyAren’t used to large toys
Titanmen - The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug features
Features
MaterialsPVC 
Length7 inches
Insertable length6.5 inches
Diameter2.28 inches
FlexibilityFlexible 
WaterproofSubmersible 
AllergiesLatex & phthalate-free 
Pros
ProsOversized
ProsDetailed head mold
ProsFlared base
ProsOver 2” of girth
Cons
ConsNot textured
ConsOnly for advanced users
ConsPorous
Conclusion

Easily earning the “Large” mention on our list, The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug has both the length and the width to back up this claim.

However, size alone isn’t everything. Fortunately, a decent amount of effort has been put into the design of this penis shaped buttplug, from the molded head up top to the flared base down below.

Unfortunately, this plug does have one thing that separates it from the other penis shaped butt plugs on this list: it’s made from PVC!

Being porous definitely isn’t a selling point, and it’s likely the thing that sways your opinion one way or the other when it comes to this toy.

Whether you’re ok with using a porous toy ultimately comes down to personal preference. However, if you’re looking solely for size, it’s pretty hard to beat the massive size and amazing “full” feeling you can get from The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug!

Comparison of the 7 best penis butt plugs

Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug
Fluke Silicone Dildo Plug