The 5 Best Rubber Floggers with Delicious Drag
The Slap ‘n’ Tickle Rubber Flogger came out on top, but that’s just one of the five rubber floggers I cover in this article! Keep reading if you want to learn the pros and cons of each toy, why a specific rubber flogger might work better for you, and learn more about the differences in flogger designs.
Table of contents (11)
How I Compared These Rubber Floggers
Every rubber flogger you’ll read about below has been researched in-depth to ensure that you’ll have the most comprehensive and accurate information instantly at your disposal! I’ve sourced information from a few different sources, including fellow Bedbible reviewers, the manufacturers, and real customers!
I took a number of different factors into consideration, focusing heavily on value, build quality, and design. I’ve made sure to cover both the positives and negatives of each pick, so you’ll know exactly what you’re getting before making a purchase.
By having all of this information right at your fingertips, it will be easy to do your own research and make sure that the next rubber flogger you pick up is perfect for you!
Reviews of the 5 best rubber floggers
Test Winner Slap 'n' Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger
The first rubber flogger I have for you today is the Slap ‘n’ Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger from Bondage Boutique!
Affordable, beginner-friendly, and created solely for dishing out a sharp bite, this simple rubber flogger is ideal for someone’s first introduction to impact play.
The rubber fronds can easily be used to tantalize the skin, working their way up from a gentle tickle up to sharp strokes with every swing.
If you need something cheap, portable, and easy to use then the Slap ‘n’ Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger is definitely one worth picking up!
- ✅ Affordable
- ✅ Beginner-friendly
- ✅ Sharp sting
- ✅ Portable
- ❌ Porous
- ❌ Incapable of “thud” impacts
In the end, I chose the Slap ‘n’ Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger as my “Test Winner”. True, it’s not the most capable or impactful flogger, but it is very approachable, even for complete beginners! I believe that this is its true strength.
Costing less than $20, it’s no surprise that it’s made of cheaper materials. Still, the combination of plastic and rubber works perfectly fine for external impact play, so this shouldn’t pose much of an issue.
As mentioned above, this rubber flogger is primarily used for delivering sharper, stingy strokes. This makes it inadequate for those who prefer deeper “thuddy” impacts instead.
That said, I believe that most BDSM beginners will enjoy this toy. Lightweight, easy to use, portable, and extremely affordable, the Slap ‘n’ Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger is the perfect way to start your impact play toy collection!
You should buy the Slap 'n' Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger if you...
- Are new to BDSM
- Need something budget-friendly
- Love sharp stings
You should not buy the Slap 'n' Tickle 10 Inch Rubber Flogger if you...
- Prefer “thuddy” impacts
- Are experienced with floggers
- Want a high-quality toy
Cheapest Sportsheets Rubber Tickler
Next up is the Sportsheets Rubber Tickler, a simple, budget-friendly rubber flogger!
This toy is offered in three different colors, giving you all-black, red, and purple floggers to choose from.
The tassels themselves measure seven inches long, while the remaining 15 inches are all handle.
This extended handle means that you’ll never have to worry about the toy escaping from your grasp, putting you in complete control!
Whether you’re hoping to tease your partner by gently tickling them with the fronds or giving them a few sharp strikes instead, the
Sportsheets Rubber Tickler makes it easy to do so on a budget!
- ✅ Cheap
- ✅ Offered in multiple colors
- ✅ Perfect for sensory play
- ✅ 22” in length
- ❌ Limited to sharp impacts
As my “Cheapest” selection, this rubber flogger is also a great option for beginners. Particularly those who don’t want to invest a lot in an activity they may or may not continue with!
The main thing I like about the Sportsheets Rubber Tickler is that it actually offers color options! Sure, all-black is great, but if you have an outfit in a different color, it’s nice to be able to make a complete set with the right colors.
Design-wise, this rubber flogger focuses heavily on the extended handle, which gives you better reach and the potential for a harder swing. Of course, this toy can’t dish out “thuddy” impacts, but it should be able to sting quite a bit.
All things considered, I think this rubber flogger is a great option for someone who wants something they can pick up on a tight budget. While it might not be the most luxurious option out there, it will definitely get the job done!
You should buy the Sportsheets Rubber Tickler if you...
- Need something affordable
- Are new to BDSM
- Love sensory play
You should not buy the Sportsheets Rubber Tickler if you...
- Prefer heavier impacts
- Don’t like the extended handle
- Want something premium
Silicone Tawse It Overboard Silicone Love Whip
So far, I’ve mainly shown you more beginner-friendly toys. Looking for a rubber flogger that’s a bit more heavy-duty? Then you’re sure to love the Tawse It Overboard Silicone Love Whip!
Made completely of high-quality silicone, this toy is actually a two-in-one device. For impacts, the four thick tongues are perfect, capable of delivering heavy thwacks to whoever is on the receiving end.
The handle is easy to hold on to, thanks to the texture. However, this handle can also be used as a dildo, offering satisfaction with every rib and bump!
Perfect for those willing to pay a bit more for a premium experience, the Tawse It Overboard Silicone Love Whip is a great addition to any sex toy collection!
- ✅ Made of silicone
- ✅ Delivers heavy impacts
- ✅ Can double as a dildo
- ✅ Four thick tongues
- ❌ Costs over $35
- ❌ No color options
- ❌ Not for sensation play
Being made completely of silicone, this flogger was the obvious choice for the “Silicone” mention. While being made of a non-porous material is great, this toy has much more to offer than materials alone.
Being able to be used as either a flogger or as a dildo gives the toy a lot of potential, helping justify the slightly higher asking price. This flogger features four thick tongues which dish out a lot of punishment, even with a light swing!
For that reason, it might not be the best option for complete beginners. Those hoping for sharp pains will likely also want to steer clear, as that’s not this toy’s specialty.
Overall, I’d strongly recommend the Tawse It Overboard Silicone Love Whip to anyone who prefers blunt impacts, wants a non-porous toy, and doesn’t mind spending a tiny bit more on a new toy!
You should buy the Tawse It Overboard Silicone Love Whip if you...
- Love heavier impacts
- Want a dual-purpose toy
- Prefer silicone toys
You should not buy the Tawse It Overboard Silicone Love Whip if you...
- Prefer sharp stings
- Need something for sensation play
- Prefer thin tassels
Tickler Sex & Mischief Whip & Tickle
Want a rubber flogger but also fancy getting your hands on a tickler? Kill two birds with one stone by picking up the Sex & Mischief Whip & Tickle!
This toy may be simple, but even so, it opens up a lot of options for whoever is wielding it. On one end lies a faux feather tickler; on the other are rubber fronds.
Whether your sub needs to be tickled or punished, this rubber flogger toy can do both! Simply switch ends to dish out a new sensation: no toy switching required!
Small enough to be portable and easy enough that even a complete beginner can wield it with confidence, the Sex & Mischief Whip & Tickle is definitely one worth adding to your toy box!
- ✅ Three color options
- ✅ Two-in-one toy
- ✅ Reasonably priced
- ❌ Price varies widely
- ❌ No storage case or bag
This toy ended up being my “Tickler” choice. Despite not being designed solely for tickling, this rubber flogger is effective at both tickling and dishing out light punishment, making it a good all-around toy for light impact play.
You get a few different color options with this one, which is nice. The design is fairly simple, but it works well enough for its intended purpose. That said, it’s worth noting that you won’t get a storage bag with this one!
At roughly 16 inches long, it’s not exactly small, but it’s still short enough that you should be able to transport it without much issue.
While I definitely wouldn’t recommend this to people who prefer more intense impact play, I think the Sex & Mischief Whip & Tickle is a good option for those just starting out with impact play that already loves sensation play & tickling.
You should buy the Sex & Mischief Whip & Tickle if you...
- Love impact & sensation play
- Like faux feathers
- Want a 2-in-1 toy
You should not buy the Sex & Mischief Whip & Tickle if you...
- Prefer non-porous materials
- Need the cheapest toy possible
- Have a latex allergy
Looped Multi-Loop Flogger
Last but not least is the Multi-Loop Flogger. If you’ve been waiting for a rubber flogger that can really dish out some harsh lashes then this is the one for you!
Its all-black look lends a somewhat modern appeal to the piece, which measures roughly 18.5 inches long from end to end.
Each fall is actually a 22” looped piece of rubber. Since it’s looped, this means you get twice the striking power per each of the ten falls!
Accurate and unforgiving, the Multi-Loop Flogger will do whatever you ask of it. Whether you want to slightly thwack your partner and give them sharp, intense strokes, this rubber flogger puts the moment in your hand!
- ✅ Intense stingy strokes
- ✅ Ten loops of rubber
- ✅ Easy to use
- ❌ Expensive
My “Looped” pick might not be for everyone. If you prefer less intense sensations then this toy isn’t for you. You also might just prefer the look of traditional fronds.
However, if the look and intensity of this rubber flogger are appealing to you then I think you’ll be more than happy with the toy! Really, the only downside is the price, which is considerably more than the other options we’ve looked at so far.
One bonus of the double loops is that this toy can actually deal some heavy swings, in addition to sharper strikes. This helps make the toy more valuable, as it can accommodate a variety of punishment preferences.
All things considered, I would recommend this mainly to those who’ve tried BDSM before, liked it, and want a toy that they can use for a long time.
You should buy the Multi-Loop Flogger if you...
- Love intense, sharp strikes
- Want a unique look
- Don’t mind spending a bit more
You should not buy the Multi-Loop Flogger if you...
- Have a small budget
- Prefer heavier strikes
- Don’t like the look
Comparison of the 5 best rubber floggers
|Overall score||4.6 / 5.0||4.7 / 5.0||4.8 / 5.0||4.5 / 5.0||-|
|Bedbible rating||4.6 / 5.0||4.5 / 5.0||4.5 / 5.0||4.5 / 5.0||4.5 / 5.0|
|User rating||4.6 / 5.0|
from 100 users
|4.8 / 5.0|
from 24 users
|5 / 5.0|
from 7 users
|4.4 / 5.0|
from 5 users
|Design||90 / 100||85 / 100||90 / 100||90 / 100||90 / 100|
|Ease of use||90 / 100||95 / 100||90 / 100||95 / 100||90 / 100|
|Quality||90 / 100||90 / 100||95 / 100||88 / 100||90 / 100|
|Materials||Soft plastic, rubber||Silicone, Nylon, Rubber||Silicone||Natural Turkey Feathers, Silicone, Nylon, Rubber||Rubber, hard plastic|
|Length||10 inches||(Total) 22 inches, (tassels) 7 inches||(Total) 17 inches, (tongue) 8.75 inches||16 inches||(Handle) 7.5 inches, (falls) 10 inches|
|Colors Available||-||Black, Red, Purple||-||Black, Red||-|
|Diameter||-||-||(Handle) 1.48 inches||-||-|
|Width||-||-||(Tongue) 0.4 inches||-||-|
Rubber & Silicone Spanking Paddles
Now that you’ve picked out a rubber flogger, why not add to your toy collection and grab a spanking paddle as well? Here are a few options you’re sure to love!
Thwack Paddle Silicone Love Spanker
Thick, simple, and vegan-friendly, the Thwack Paddle Silicone Love Spanker is the perfect way to dish out some sexy punishment to a partner! The silicone of this paddle is excellent at transferring your entire swing, making sure that your partner is sure to know who’s boss!
Fetish Fantasy Rubber Paddle
Perfect for beginners and intermediate players alike, the Fantasy Rubber Paddle is a textured piece of discipline. Made of PVC and easy to use, this is a great paddle for the price!
Thuddy vs Stingy Impacts
When trying to pick out your next rubber flogger, it’s important to recognize the difference between thuddy impacts and stingy ones. The easiest way to explain them is by comparing them to sensations you’re likely already familiar with!
Thuddy impacts are essentially deep-tissue impacts, similar to being punched. Alternatively, a stingy impact would be closer to having a rubber band snapped against your skin.
If you prefer stingy impacts then you’ll want a lighter flogger, whereas those who prefer thuddy impacts should opt for a heavier rubber flogger. I recommend starting with stingy impacts first, as thuddy impacts have a much higher potential for inflicting serious damage.
How to Use a Rubber Flogger
Using a rubber flogger is fairly straightforward, but let’s quickly go over the general process anyway!
Option one is to tease your partner using the rubber flogger! To do so, simply run the fronds over their skin. Sensitive areas such as the neck, chest, or legs are great options. Experiment with different pressures and speeds to see what works best!
The obvious use of a rubber flogger is for impact play! Remember, it’s important to have a “safe word” in place, even if your impacts will be light. With that established, you can start swinging the flogger. You’ll need to experiment a bit to get the impacts exactly how you want them. Additionally, try different body parts to see which ones work the best.
How to Clean a Rubber Flogger
Cleaning your rubber flogger is fairly simple, requiring only warm water and antibacterial soap. Clean the surface using soap and water, then wash off any remaining soap using water only. If your toy is made of silicone only then you can also sterilize it by dropping the flogger into a pot of boiling water for five minutes. Once done, pat your flogger down using a dry towel. From there, leave the toy out to dry completely before storing it away. Avoid storing your toy away while it's still damp, as doing so can allow bacteria to begin to grow in the leftover moisture!
Soft plastic, hard plastic, jelly, rubber, Cyberskin are all porous materials, meaning that small particles and bacteria can penetrate the surface. This makes it impossible to completely clean these types of materials.
Therefore, it is recommended that you use a condom with these types of toys, especially if you are sharing them. Clean these toys with mild soapy water and dry gently with a towel. These materials are more easily damaged, so be sure to be gentle and make sure your toys are completely dry before storing.
Silicone, glass, stainless steel and some hard plastics can all be washed using a mild soap (like you would use on your body) and warm water. Just be careful if your toy contains electrical parts.
Silicone and stainless steel toys without any electrical parts can also be boiled for sterilisation.
If your toys contain electrical components, be extra careful when cleaning them and always check the instructions provided with the toy. You can use a gentle cloth and soap to wipe or sex toy cleaner or cleaning wipe to down your toy, making sure that no water comes into contact with the electrical parts.
What is a Rubber Flogger?
A rubber flogger is a type of BDSM toy that’s made from rubber and has multiple strands (also called tails). These toys are especially popular for lighter impact play and sensation play. They tend to provide a sharper sting in general, although this can vary from toy to toy.