The 3 Best Penis Gags to Keep Your Sub Satisfied

Josh Gill
by Josh Gill
best penis gag in test
Some people love to use balls gags…and others like to take things to the next level with penis gags! In this review we’re going to dive into three of the best penis gags out there, looking at each and every aspect of them! Our goal? To help you choose the perfect one for you! We also threw in some extra toys and accessories, and well as providing some hints and tips that will make your penis gag journey as exciting and arousing as possible! Enjoy!
Test winnerCheapestBeginner
''My Two Ways'' Dildo Gag
Bondage Boutique Dildo Gag
Tantus Fantasy Gag
''My Two Ways'' Dildo GagBondage Boutique Dildo GagTantus Fantasy Gag
Check priceCheck priceCheck price

Our reviews of penis gags explained

When we write our reviews here at BedBible, we often worry that if people are in a hurry they might not have enough time to read through our extensive and thorough reviews for each and every toy. Luckily we came up with a solution! As part of our review of the 3 best penis gags out there, we decided that we wanted to include a simple rating system that was easy to read at just a glance. That’s why we looked at the design, ease of use, and quality of each and every toy we reviewed, and rated them out of 100. We simplified it even further by coming up with an overall star rating out of 5, meaning that should you not have time to read through our full and thorough thoughts on these penis gags, you could still get a good overall idea of our unbiased findings!

Our reviews of penis gags explained

Penis Gag vs Dildo Gag

Penises and dildos are often interchangeable objects that someone could use to bring themselves to orgasm, but when it comes to gags, what’s the difference between a penis one and a dildo one? Let’s take a look!

  • Penis gag – Penis gags go into the mouth, and it replicates the sensation of giving oral sex. It fills your mouth up (and sometimes even your throat) and can be strapped around the head, so it can’t be removed easily.
  • Dildo gag – These types of gags are the opposite of a mouth gag: they feature a gag with a dildo that is on the outside of the mouth. This dildo can then be used by someone else while the sub is still gagged!

FAQ

Are penis gags safe?
Yes, providing you use them properly! Make sure you read up on exactly how you use these kinds of gags, and follow the manufacturer's instructions! If you do that, there's no reason why you won't have safe and naughty fun!
Can I use my penis gags like a dildo?
You can, but because they're not very long they might not leave you feeling too full. And if you do use them elsewhere, be sure to sanitize them when you're done. You don't want any gross or nasty surprises, smells, or tastes when the time comes for it to go back in your mouth!
Where can I buy penis gags?
In this review you'll notice that we have linked to a shop where you can buy every penis gag that we've talked about. We only work with the best, most reputable sex toy sellers out there, so you can shop in confidence that you're dealing with professionals!

What are penis gags?

Penis gags are a kind of BDSM toy that is characterized by a dildo or penis like toy that is put into the mouth to keep the sub quiet. It can be secured with a strap or harness around the subs head, meaning that it won't come loose and that they can't easily remove it. Both subs and doms can enjoy penis gags: the sub will enjoy having their mouth filled up with such a sexual object, while the dom will enjoy the sight of their sub being kept quiet while they use them in whatever other way they want!

Table of contents (0)

The 3 Best penis gags in Test

1 Test winner

Dildo Gag With Ball ''My Two Ways''

Design:

Rating:

What it is: 

80/100
Ease of Use:

Rating:

What it is: 

60/100
Quality:

Rating:

What it is: 

90/100
Price:

Rating:

What it is: 

Low

Bedbible rating:

Rating:

What it is: 

0.0/5.0

User rating:

Rating:

What it is: 

N/A

The ”My Two Ways” Dildo Gag is perfect if you’re into humiliation play, as it will leave your sub drooling and unable to speak. It is made from a lifelike, smooth, and sexy silicone, and is soft enough for them to sink their teeth into without causing any damage. Now for the reason it includes the words “my two ways” in its name: Not only can you use this toy as a penis gaga, but you also have the option of flipping it around, so the penis is on the outside for someone else to use while you’re kept quiet with the ball gag. Simply secure the toy – whichever way you want – around your head with the adjustable (and padlock-able) strap!

Dildo Gag With Ball ''My Two Ways'' test
Recommended for

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the ''My Two Ways'' Dildo Gag if you...
Love to use penis gags
Enjoy the option of a dildo gag too
Like the feel of silicone
You should NOT buy the ''My Two Ways'' Dildo Gag if you...
Prefer to use ball gags only
Aren't a huge fan of oral sex
Want a girthier cock for in your mouth
Features
MaterialsSilicone 
Length(belt buckle) 14 to 20 inches
WaterproofYes 
AllergiesPathalates free  
Pros
Can be used as a penis gag AND dildo gag
High quality materials
Adjustable strap to fit all
Cons
Penis may be too small for some
Quite hard feeling
Strap may slip up/down the head
Conclusion

We can see why the ”My Two Ways” Dildo Gag was the test winner when it came to penis gags, because you have plenty of options and choices to make. Use it as a penis gag, or flip it around and use it as a dildo gag. The toy is made of a high quality silicone that won’t cause any damage and isn’t easy to damage, and the strap is adjustable meaning that even those with the smallest or largest heads can enjoy it! The penis itself might be a little too small for those that prefer something longer or girthier in their mouth, and the single belt restraint might possibly slip and allow the gag to come loose. But overall it’s a great penis gag that will keep you silent yet satisfied!

2 Cheapest

Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag

Design:

Rating:

What it is: 

80/100
Ease of Use:

Rating:

What it is: 

80/100
Quality:

Rating:

What it is: 

80/100
Price:

Rating:

What it is: 

Low

Bedbible rating:

Rating:

What it is: 

0.0/5.0

User rating:

Rating:

What it is: 

N/A

The Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag sounds as sexy as it looks! The adjustable leather strap secures around the head while the 2.5 inches long rubber dildo fits nicely into the mouth to keep your sub quiet! A wide leather mount completely covers the mouth while the girthy penis sits in there, ensuring that your sub can’t make a sound! Want to make sure things are extra secure? Try adding a padlock to the back of the strap to make sure that your sub can’t remove it until you’re ready!

Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag test
Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag features
Recommended for

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the Bondage Boutique Dildo Gag if you...
Like the look and feel of leather
Can't resist something filling your mouth
Want a well-sized dildo
You should NOT buy the Bondage Boutique Dildo Gag if you...
Want a better tasting toy
Are looking for a higher quality penis gag
Strap possibly too oversized
Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag features
Features
MaterialsLeather and rubber 
Length(penis) 2.5 inches, (belt buckle) up to 25 inches
FasteningBuckle 
Pros
The leather and studs look great
Small but chunky penis fits nicely in the mouth
Strap can be adjusted to suit the wearer
Cons
The strap is kind of oversized
The penis gag tastes bad
Made from potentially harmful materials
Conclusion

The Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag looks amazing! With the black leather strap and shiny studs, it looks like something straight out of your favorite porn star’s BDSM basement! The penis is well sized and will sit in your mouth perfectly, filling you up but not going so far inside that it chokes you. Now let’s move onto the downsides, and there’s a pretty glaring one: the material that this toy is made out of could potentially expose you to harmful chemicals! Now that’s something you really don’t want! It might be cheap, and it might be great in a lot of areas, but we’d recommend paying that little bit extra to ensure your safety.

3 Beginner

Tantus Fantasy Gag

Design:

Rating:

What it is: 

80/100
Ease of Use:

Rating:

What it is: 

75/100
Quality:

Rating:

What it is: 

95/100
Price:

Rating:

What it is: 

Low

Bedbible rating:

Rating:

What it is: 

0.0/5.0

User rating:

Rating:

What it is: 

N/A
SheVibe
Discreet shipping & billing​Their website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+
Check price
Spectrumboutique
Discreet shipping & billingShipping rate: $8FREE shipping on orders $99+
Check price
Stockroom
Discreet shipping & billing​15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $99+
Check price

If you’ve got a healthy fixation on pleasures of the oral kind, then the Tantus Fantasy Gag is going to be a brilliant match for you. Made of a high quality silicone, it is perfect for beginners, as well as being extra fun for those who are a little more experienced. The mouthpiece is large enough to keep you quiet while still allowing for a certain amount of movement, while the Velcro fastening on the durable yet comfortable strap ensures that the gag can be quickly and easily removed!

Tantus Fantasy Gag test
Recommended for

BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
You should buy the Tantus Fantasy Gag if you...
Are just a beginner to using penis gags
Want to start with something smaller
Need a quick release feature
You should NOT buy the Tantus Fantasy Gag if you...
Prefer to feel other materials
Want something bigger
Are more experienced with penis gags
Features
MaterialsSilicone and leather 
Length(gag) 3 inches
WaterproofYes 
AllergiesPathalates free  
Pros
Great for beginners
Not loo girthy or long
Quick release Velcro strap
Cons
Might not be big enough for some
Not really for penis gag experts
Straps a little too thin and dainty
Conclusion

For beginners to the world  of penis gag play, the Tantus Fantasy Gag is a dream come true for a variety of reasons. Firstly it is made of a body-safe, great feeling leather. Secondly it’s just the right size – not too big and not too small. And thirdly it’s just as quick and easy to take off as it is to put on. Okay, it might not be ideal for those that are more experienced, or those that are looking for something bigger in their mouth, but for people who are new to the game, the Tantus Fantasy Gag will allow them to gradually work their way into the naughty penis gag world!

Comparison of the 0 best penis gags

Show More

Prefer Something to Ride On?

Want something to ride on while your sub wears it? Then it looks like you need a dildo gag! Here are a few options for you to feast your eyes on!

In and Out Penis Gag

In and Out Penis Gag

In and Out Penis Gag

The In and Out Penis Gag features a nice 6 inches long and 2 inches wide removable dildo that can be easily slid through the metal ring that sits over your subs mouth. It actually forces them to keep quiet while they pleasure you with the outwards facing dildo. Want to remove the dildo completely? Not a problem, simply unsnap it and take it out. It really does mean you have endless possibilities when it comes to your sexual satisfaction. And maybe your subs. Maybe.

Check price
Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo

Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo

Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo

Combining the common ball gag with a 4.8 inches long flexible silicone dildo, the Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo is a great option for those that want to get freaky! The leather strap is adjustable and will hold it tightly in place. The dildo itself has been crafted for direct G-spot or P-spot pleasure, and the shaft features textures that will provide mind-blowing internal massages as you ride it. The Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo really does allow you to show your sub exactly who’s in charge!

Check price
The Accommodator Chin Strap Dildo

The Accommodator Chin Strap Dildo

The Accommodator Chin Strap Dildo

Okay, we’ll admit that the Accommodator Chin Strap Dildo might look a little weird, but it really does give you some naughty extras that the other face riding dildos don’t! It fits around your chin using stretchy and comfortable straps that will hold it in the perfect position. This toy frees up the subs mouth, meaning they can use their tongue to lick and stroke whatever part of your intimate anatomy that they can reach while you ride! Coming in at 5.5 inches long, this latex love length will feel nearly as good as your subs tongue does!

Check price

Penis Gag Safety

When using penis gags you’re going to want to make sure that you keep things as safe as possible. Here are a few hints and pointers that will hopefully help you understand what you need to think about while using these orgasmic oral objects!

Does the penis gag fit properly?

Does the penis gag fit properly?

Does the penis gag fit properly?

Making sure you have a penis gag that fits on your subs face and in their mouth is important. If the penis is too small it won’t have any effect; if it’s too big it might cause them to choke and have a lot of negative effects. You need to listen to what your sub wants, needs and feels when it comes to the size of the penis gag they’re using!

Can your sub breathe?

Can your sub breathe?

Can your sub breathe?

It goes without saying that breathing is essential if you want to stay alive! Because penis gags go into the mouth and towards to throat, there is a risk that the penis may become lodged in the throat and choke them or stop them from breathing. Once the gag is in, make sure they’re comfortable and good to go before anything else happens!

Do you have a safety signal?

Do you have a safety signal?

Do you have a safety signal?

Many times during BDSM play, couples have a safety word. This indicates that one of the participants wants to stop and take a break. Well when your sub has a penis gag in their mouth they can’t say anything, so having a safety signal is the next best idea. Choose something that you both understand and won’t be misinterpreted! And if your sub start’s to signal, DON’T IGNORE IT!

How to use penis gags?

If you or your sub wants to use a penis gag, it’s important that they do it safely! That’s why we’re going to go through some tips to keep things safe and keep everyone okay!

How to use penis gags?

Make sure nothing will get in the way!

Make sure nothing will get in the way!

Because penis gags are strapped around the head and secured that way, it’s important to make sure any facial jewelry is removed. That includes earrings, nose rings, lip piercings, or anything that could get caught on the straps. After all, you don’t want a ring getting ripped out. They’re the only holes you DON’T want destroying!

Make sure you don't have a cold!

How to use penis gags?

Everyone knows that you breathe through your nose, but what do you do if you have a cold or your nose is otherwise blocked? You breathe through your mouth! Having a penis gag in there makes that pretty impossible, so never use penis gags if you have a cold or your nose is blocked up. Because after all, you don’t want to die!

How to use penis gags?
How to use penis gags?

Take a time out if you need it!

Take a time out if you need it!

Here at BedBible we’re all for having long, awesome sex sessions, BUT we also like to recommend taking a break every now and again! Remove the penis gag and allow your mouth, jaw, teeth, and tongue to relax for a while! It also gives you the opportunity to breathe completely uninhibitedly! Take a few mins to relax and rest before getting back into it again!

How to clean penis gags

Your penis gags are going to need a good clean after every use, but how do you do it? How on earth do you keep them clean, sterilized, and good to go each and every time that you need them? Well we've put together a few really useful resources that will help you keep your penis gags clean and ready to use!

Porous
materials

Soft plastic, hard plastic, jelly, rubber, Cyberskin are all porous materials, meaning that small particles and bacteria can penetrate the surface. This makes it impossible to completely clean these types of materials.

Therefore, it is recommended that you use a condom with these types of toys, especially if you are sharing them. Clean these toys with mild soapy water and dry gently with a towel. These materials are more easily damaged, so be sure to be gentle and make sure your toys are completely dry before storing.

Non-propous
materials

Silicone, glass, stainless steel and some hard plastics can all be washed using a mild soap (like you would use on your body) and warm water. Just be careful if your toy contains electrical parts.

Silicone and stainless steel toys without any electrical parts can also be boiled for sterilisation.

The toys with electrical
components

If your toys contain electrical components, be extra careful when cleaning them and always check the instructions provided with the toy. You can use a gentle cloth and soap to wipe or sex toy cleaner or cleaning wipe to down your toy, making sure that no water comes into contact with the electrical parts.

Author
Josh Gill
Josh Gill
Age: 33
Gender: Male
Sexual orientation: Heterosexual
Sex toy experience: Intermediate
All-time favorite sex toy: Fleshlight Review
All articles and reviews