The 7 Best Penis Gags to Keep Your Sub Satisfied
In this review, I’m bringing you all the details on the 7 best penis gags available right now! I’ve got a beginner-friendly penis ball gags as well as some more extreme ones for advanced level stuffing! I’ll share my top tips for how to use penis gags and guide on safe play.
Test winner | Cheapest | Beginner | Leather | Advanced | Inflatable | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
''My Two Ways'' Dildo Gag | Beginner Penis Ball Gag | Tantus Fantasy Gag | Bondage Boutique Dildo Gag | In and Out Penis Gag | Inflatable Dildo Gag | Inflatable Penis Gag |
Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons |
Table of contents (11)
Our Reviews of Penis Gags Explained
I spent over 20 hours researching and writing about these penis gags, so I could deliver a comprehensive review that has all the information you need in one place.
I rated the design, ease of use, and quality of each and every toy we reviewed to make it easy to get an over view. On top of that, I awarded each one an overall star rating out of 5, meaning that should you not have time to read through my full and thorough thoughts on these penis gags, you could still get a good overall idea of our unbiased findings!
I also thought about more specific features of penis gags, including the gag material, gag fastening, and size, so you can find one that suits your specific preferences.
Penis Gag vs Dildo Gag
Penises and dildos are often interchangeable objects that someone could use to bring themselves to orgasm, but when it comes to gags, what’s the difference between a penis one and a dildo one? Let’s take a look!
- Penis gag – Penis gags go into the mouth, and it replicates the sensation of giving oral sex. It fills your mouth up (and sometimes even your throat) and can be strapped around the head, so it can’t be removed easily.
- Dildo gag – These types of gags are the opposite of a mouth gag: they feature a gag with a dildo that is on the outside of the mouth. This dildo can then be used by someone else while the sub is still gagged!
Reviews of the 7 best penis gags
Test winner Dildo Gag With Ball ''My Two Ways''
The ”My Two Ways” Dildo Gag is perfect if you’re into humiliation play, as it will leave your sub drooling and unable to speak. It is made from a lifelike, smooth, and sexy silicone, and is soft enough for them to sink their teeth into without causing any damage.
Now for the reason it includes the words “my two ways” in its name: Not only can you use this toy as a penis gaga, but you also have the option of flipping it around, so the penis is on the outside for someone else to use while you’re kept quiet with the ball gag. I love the versatility!
Pros
- ✅ Can be used as a penis gag AND dildo gag
- ✅ High quality materials
- ✅ Adjustable strap to most sizes
Cons
- ❌ Penis may be too small for some
- ❌ Quite hard feeling
- ❌ Strap may slip up/down the head
My verdict
I chose the ”My Two Ways” Dildo Gag as the test winner for two main reasons. I love that you can wear it as a penis gag, or flip it around and use it as a dildo gag. Plus, the toy is made of a high quality silicone that won’t cause any damage and isn’t easy to damage, and even the strap is made of silicone!
The penis itself might be a little too small for those that prefer something longer or girthier in their mouth, and the single belt restraint might possibly slip and allow the gag to come loose. But overall it’s a great penis gag that will keep you silent yet satisfied!
Buy, if you...
- Prefer a silicone gag
- Enjoy the option of a dildo gag too
- Enjoy having your mouth completely full
- Prefer silicone straps
Don't buy, if you...
- Are looking for an extra girthy penis gag
- Prefer leather straps
- Aren't interested in the reversible feature
Show coupon
5% coupon available
Cheapest Dark Amour Beginner Penis Ball Gag
If you are looking for a penis gag on a budget or a for a first timer, the Beginner Penis Ball Gag from Dark Amour is a good place to start.
The penis gag, is a manageable 2 inches long and 1.25 inches in diameter, making enough to keep you quiet without being overwhelming.
The adjustable pink strap adds a pop of color and is great for sissy play!
Pros
- ✅ One of the cheapest penis gags
- ✅ Beginner-friendly size
- ✅ Adjustable strap
- ✅ Unique pink design
Cons
- ❌ Not the highest quality
- ❌ Gag is made of soft plastic
- ❌ Lockable but doesn't come with padlock
My verdict
I think this could be a great to see if you enjoy wearing a penis gag without investing too much in the beginning. I think the pink strap is fun but won’t be to everyone’s liking and it’s a shame that the gag isn’t made from silicone. However, at this price, I’m not that surprised! It’s definitely the cheapest penis gag in the review and that I’ve found online. It also has the smallest gag, making it very beginner-friendly.
Buy, if you...
- Are looking for a cheap penis gag
- Love the pink design
- Want a gag for sissy play
- Need a small, beginner-friendly penis gag
Don't buy, if you...
- Want a silicone gag
- Are looking for a more filling gag
- Prefer a plain black design
Beginner Tantus Fantasy Gag
If you’ve got a healthy fixation on pleasures of the oral kind, then the Tantus Fantasy Gag is going to be a brilliant match for you. Made of a high quality silicone, it is perfect for beginners, as well as being extra fun for those who are a little more experienced. The mouthpiece is large enough to keep you quiet while still allowing for a certain amount of movement, while the Velcro fastening on the durable yet comfortable strap ensures that the gag can be quickly and easily removed!
Pros
- ✅ Great for beginners
- ✅ Not loo girthy or long
- ✅ Quick release Velcro strap
Cons
- ❌ Might not be big enough for some
- ❌ Not really for penis gag experts
- ❌ Straps a little too thin and dainty
My verdict
For beginners to the world of penis gag play, the Tantus Fantasy Gag is a dream come true for a variety of reasons. Firstly it is made of a body-safe, great feeling leather. Secondly it’s just the right size – not too big and not too small. And thirdly it’s just as quick and easy to take off as it is to put on. Okay, it might not be ideal for those that are more experienced, or those that are looking for something bigger in their mouth, but for people who are new to the game, the Tantus Fantasy Gag will allow them to gradually work their way into the naughty penis gag world!
Buy, if you...
- Are just a beginner to using penis gags
- Want to start with something smaller
- Need a quick release feature
Don't buy, if you...
- Prefer to feel other materials
- Want something bigger
- Are more experienced with penis gags
Leather Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag
The Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag sounds as sexy as it looks! The adjustable leather strap secures around the head while the 2.5 inches long rubber dildo fits nicely into the mouth to keep your sub quiet!
A wide leather mount completely covers the mouth while the girthy penis sits in there, ensuring that your sub can’t make a sound! Want to make sure things are extra secure? Try adding a padlock to the back of the strap to make sure that your sub can’t remove it until you’re ready!
Pros
- ✅ The leather and studs look great
- ✅ Small but chunky penis fits nicely in the mouth
- ✅ Strap can be adjusted to suit the wearer
Cons
- ❌ The strap is kind of oversized
- ❌ The penis gag tastes bad
- ❌ Made from potentially harmful materials
My verdict
I think the Bondage Boutique Leather and Studs Dildo Gag looks amazing! I really like the style of the black leather strap and shiny studs, it looks like something straight out of your favorite porn star’s BDSM basement!
The penis is well sized and will sit in your mouth perfectly, filling you up but not going so far inside that it chokes you.
I am, however, disappointed that the gag is made of rubber, which is a lower quality material that is less safe and hygienic than silicone.
Buy, if you...
- Like the look and feel of leather
- Prefer the leather panel design
- Want a well-sized dildo
Don't buy, if you...
- Prefer a silicone gag
- Avoid leather products
Show coupon
15% coupon available
Advanced Stockroom In and Out Penis Gag
This formidable penis gag comes with a double-ended dildo that can stuff the wearer’s mouth while they use the other one to pleasure their partner.
I love the versatility of this penis mouth gag. The 6 inch dildo is held in place by four snaps but can be removed, so you can slip a finger or something else inside your sub’s mouth if you wish!
The strap is made of leather and can be adjusted from 10 – 23 inches.
Pros
- ✅ Quality leather strap
- ✅ Removable double-ended dildo
- ✅ Can be used to penetrate a partner
- ✅ Dildo available in beige or black
Cons
- ❌ Dildo materials not specified
- ❌ Pricey
- ❌ Nickel-plated snaps
My verdict
I would say this is definitely for those with more experience with gags. However, if the thought of being able to penetrate your partner and have them ride your face while you are completely gagged gets you excited, this is the penis gag for you! I also really like that the dildo is removable.
The strap is made of high-quality leather, but I was disappointed to see that the materials for the dildo are nowhere to be found. This makes me think it’s made of a lower quality soft plastic. As this is the most expensive penis gag in this review, I would expect the dildo to be made of silicone.
Buy, if you...
- Want to explore more extreme penis gags
- Are interested in face riding with a dildo gag
- Prefer a leather harness
- Want a versatile penis gag
Don't buy, if you...
- Are allergic to nickel
- Prefer a silicone gag
- Don't have a lot of gag experience
- Don't use leather products
Show coupon
10% coupon available
Inflatable Bondage Boutique Inflatable Dildo Gag
Enjoy strapping your sub in and watching them get more and more filled up as you squeeze the pump! This inflatable penis gag from Bondage Boutique ticks all the boxes when it comes to gag power play!
I like the look of the panel gag that also functions as a muffler and the adjustable strap that holds it in place. The design of the inflatable penis is also very pleasing with a nice sculpted head.
I’m also happy to see there’s a quick release valve on the pump for safety!
Pros
- ✅ Leather panel and straps
- ✅ Dildo inflates up to 5.5 inches in girth
- ✅ Strap adjustable 16.5-22.5 inches
- ✅ Quick-release valve
Cons
- ❌ Gag is made of rubber
- ❌ Panel can be stiff at first
My verdict
I like the panel gag meets dildo gag design and the inflatable function really takes things up a notch! It could feel a little claustrophobic so I only recommend this gag to those who enjoy more intense gag play.
The pump is easy to use but you can only pump it a few times before it reaches it’s limit. I do like that it has the quick release function so you can quickly deflate the dildo without having to undo the head strap.
It’s cheaper than the other inflatable penis gag in the review and it’s not much more expensive than the regular penis gags, making it great value for money. The only thing that really lets it down is that the gag is made of rubber and not silicone.
Buy, if you...
- Love the idea of an inflatable gag
- Want a gag for power play
- Prefer a panel design
- Want an inflatable penis gag with a strap
Don't buy, if you...
- Are new to penis gags
- Want a very big inflatable gag
- You avoid leather products
Show coupon
15% coupon available
Stockroom Inflatable Penis Gag
Not only does this gag give you the satisfaction of seeing your subs mouth stuffed full, but you can also slowly inflate it to fill them up even more!
I like that it also features a tube that makes it easy to breath while gagged.
You can inflate the gag by squeezing the hand pump that’s connected by a 5.5 inch tube.
Pros
- ✅ Inflates for advanced play
- ✅ Tube for easy breathing
- ✅ Easy-to-use hand pump
Cons
- ❌ Made of rubber
- ❌ Will be too advanced for many
My verdict
Unlike the other penis gags in this review, the Inflatable Penis Gag from Stockroom doesn’t have a strap to hold it in place. Instead, it’s held in place by inflating the penis gag and completely filling the wearer’s mouth.
I think this is best suited to those looking for a more advanced gag for some serious power play. One thing to keep in mind is that the gag is made of rubber which is porous.
Buy, if you...
- Are into more extreme gag play
- Want an inflatable gag
- Need a gag for power play
Don't buy, if you...
- Are new to gags
- Prefer a gag with a strap
- Want a silicone gag
Show coupon
10% coupon available
Comparison of the 7 best penis gags
Best | Test winner | Cheapest | Beginner | Leather | Advanced | Inflatable | null |
Overall score | 4.7 / 5.0 | 4.3 / 5.0 | 4.0 / 5.0 | 4.5 / 5.0 | - | 4.4 / 5.0 | 4.7 / 5.0 |
Bedbible rating | 4.8 / 5.0 | 3.9 / 5.0 | 4.0 / 5.0 | 4.6 / 5.0 | 4.3 / 5.0 | 4.6 / 5.0 | 4.3 / 5.0 |
User rating | 4.5 / 5.0 from 22 users | 4.7 / 5.0 from 3 users | 4.1 / 5.0 from 11 users | 4.5 / 5.0 from 56 users | - | 4.3 / 5.0 from 27 users | 5 / 5.0 from 1 users |
Price | Cheap | Cheap | Affordable | Cheap | Pricey | Affordable | Pricey |
Design | 90 / 100 | 60 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 85 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 80 / 100 |
Ease of use | 80 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 75 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 85 / 100 | 70 / 100 |
Quality | 90 / 100 | 60 / 100 | 95 / 100 | 80 / 100 | 70 / 100 | 75 / 100 | 70 / 100 |
Sound | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Power | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Buzzy/Rumbly | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Materials | Silicone | - | Silicone and leather | Leather and rubber | Leather, nickel-plated snaps | Leather and rubber | Rubber |
Length | Strap: 14 to 20 inches | Straps: 17.5 to 24.5 inches | Strap: 17-23 inches | Strap: up to 17-23 inches | Strap: 10-23 inches | Strap: 16.5-22.5 inches | Breathing tube: 5.5 inches |
Waterproof | Yes | - | Yes | - | - | - | - |
Allergies | Pathalates free | - | - | - | Contains nickel | - | - |
Fastening | Buckle | - | - | Buckle | - | Buckle | - |
Insertable length | - | Gag: 2 inches | Gag: 2.7 inches | Gag: 2.5 inches | Dildo: 6 inches | - | - |
Diameter | - | 1.25 inches | 1.75 inches | - | 2 inches | Gag: up to 5.5 inches | Gag: 2-3 inches |
Prefer Something to Ride On?
Want something to ride on while your sub wears it? Then it looks like you need a dildo gag! Here are a few options for you to feast your eyes on!
In and Out Penis Gag
The In and Out Penis Gag features a nice 6 inches long and 2 inches wide removable dildo that can be easily slid through the metal ring that sits over your subs mouth. It actually forces them to keep quiet while they pleasure you with the outwards facing dildo. Want to remove the dildo completely? Not a problem, simply unsnap it and take it out. It really does mean you have endless possibilities when it comes to your sexual satisfaction. And maybe your subs. Maybe.
Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo
Combining the common ball gag with a 4.8 inches long flexible silicone dildo, the Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo is a great option for those that want to get freaky! The leather strap is adjustable and will hold it tightly in place. The dildo itself has been crafted for direct G-spot or P-spot pleasure, and the shaft features textures that will provide mind-blowing internal massages as you ride it. The Bondage Boutique Ball Gag with Dildo really does allow you to show your sub exactly who’s in charge!
The Accommodator Chin Strap Dildo
Okay, we’ll admit that the Accommodator Chin Strap Dildo might look a little weird, but it really does give you some naughty extras that the other face riding dildos don’t! It fits around your chin using stretchy and comfortable straps that will hold it in the perfect position. This toy frees up the subs mouth, meaning they can use their tongue to lick and stroke whatever part of your intimate anatomy that they can reach while you ride! Coming in at 5.5 inches long, this latex love length will feel nearly as good as your subs tongue does!
Penis Gag Safety
When using penis gags you’re going to want to make sure that you keep things as safe as possible. Here are a few hints and pointers that will hopefully help you understand what you need to think about while using these orgasmic oral objects!
Does the penis gag fit properly?
Making sure you have a penis gag that fits on your subs face and in their mouth is important. If the penis is too small it won’t have any effect; if it’s too big it might cause them to choke and have a lot of negative effects. You need to listen to what your sub wants, needs and feels when it comes to the size of the penis gag they’re using!
Can your sub breathe?
It goes without saying that breathing is essential if you want to stay alive! Because penis gags go into the mouth and towards to throat, there is a risk that the penis may become lodged in the throat and choke them or stop them from breathing. Once the gag is in, make sure they’re comfortable and good to go before anything else happens!
Do you have a safety signal?
Many times during BDSM play, couples have a safety word. This indicates that one of the participants wants to stop and take a break. Well when your sub has a penis gag in their mouth they can’t say anything, so having a safety signal is the next best idea. Choose something that you both understand and won’t be misinterpreted! And if your sub start’s to signal, DON’T IGNORE IT!
FAQ
What are penis gags?
Penis gags are a kind of BDSM toy that is characterized by a dildo or penis like toy that is put into the mouth to keep the sub quiet. It can be secured with a strap or harness around the subs head, meaning that it won't come loose and that they can't easily remove it. Both subs and doms can enjoy penis gags: the sub will enjoy having their mouth filled up with such a sexual object, while the dom will enjoy the sight of their sub being kept quiet while they use them in whatever other way they want!
Reviewed by:
Josh Gill