The 16 Best Butt Plugs for Total Bottom Bliss!
Review Method: How We Tested and Reviewed These Butt Plugs
When it comes to sex toys, we know that there’s no one-size-fits all – especially when it comes to butt toys! Without bragging, here at Bedbible we would consider ourselves true butt connoisseurs. With 500 sex toy reviews written by sexperts from all over the world, we know what makes a good sex toy.
And when it came to butt plugs, we really put the time in to find the best toys to recommend to our readers. This butt plug review was a labor of love – I spent over 50+ hours researching toys, reviewing every type of butt plug, analyzing the reviews and writing up all the important info for you to read here.
So, I reviewed each model according to the following factors: price, quality, body safety, design, and overall experience. The result? No spin, no fluff, no gushing over bad toys. Just the best butt plugs and authentic reviews from people like you. Let’s dive in, shall we?
How to Find Your Perfect Butt Plug
Before rushing off to spend some quality time with your butt plug, here are some of the most important factors to consider before settling on the toy you want:
- Size – One of the most important things to take into consideration before buying a butt plug is its size. If your butt plug is too small, it’s not going to feel great, but if it’s too big, you won’t even manage to get it in!
- Shape – The most common butt plug shape is slightly acorn-esque and girthy, but you don’t have to go straight for a girthy toy! Some butt toys have curved tips, making them more optimised for stimulating the prostate.
- Materials – When buying a toy that is going to be used exclusively in the anus, you’re going to want to prioritize the highest quality materials. We recommend opting for non-porous materials for butt plugs, like metal, silicone, glass, or ABS plastic.
- Functions – Do you want a vibrating butt plug, an inflatable butt plug, or a thrusting butt plug? The world is your oyster!
- Area of stimulation – If you want to stimulate the pressure nerves in the anus, a girthier butt plug is ideal. For p-spot stimulation, go for a curved tip!
- Experience level – Another of the most important factors to take into consideration – experience! It’s always best to start off with beginner butt plugs and work your way up to the more advanced anal toys.
- Price – If your budget is limited, we made to sure to include some cheaper alternatives in our review. You don’t need to compromise on quality when it comes to buying cheap sex toys – you just have to let us help you find the best ones!
What Size Butt Plug is Best for Me?
Size is one of the most important factors to consider when buying a butt plug. You can typically buy butt plugs in the following sizes:
- Extra small: for total anal first-timers.
- Small: ideal for beginners.
- Medium: best suited for beginners looking to level up their anal game.
- Large: ideal for providing more intense sensation.
- Extra large: suitable for advanced anal adventurers.
If you’re not sure what size butt plug is best for you, take a look at our blog post on picking the right size butt plug, where my colleague Isabelle will give you the low-down on butt plug sizing.
Types of Butt Plug
When it comes to butt plugs, it’s a bit of understatement to say that you’re spoiled for choice. Here are all the different types of butt plugs you can buy:
What is a butt plug?
A butt plug is a typically girthy sex toy inserted into the anus. A butt plug can be used to dilate the anus before anal sex or simply procure anal pleasure. A butt plug will usually come with a flared base in order to prevent the toy from getting stuck in the rectum. Butt plugs can be used solo or during sex with a partner, and come in different varieties. You can find vibrating butt plugs, jewel butt plugs, thrusting butt plugs and more!
Table of contents (27)
The 18 Best butt plugs in Test
njoy Pure Plug Stainless Steel Butt Plug
For intermediate butt plug enthusiasts, this stainless steel butt plug from the sexperts at nJoy is pocket-sized perfection. Completely smooth for easy insertion and weighted for enhanced sensations, this butt plug offers firm sensations and moderate fullness. The best thing about this butt plug? It adapts itself to your body temperature, so you don’t need to worry about cold steel hitting that delicate skin in and around your tush. Of course, if that sensation is exactly what you’re looking for, this metal butt plug can easily be chilled or warmed up a few minutes before you get down and dirty, so you can enjoy some titillating temperature play!
I am personally a big fan of stainless steel sex toys. Not only is it easy to clean and store, but high-quality stainless steel can truly go the distance with the right maintenance. That’s just one of the reasons I’ve selected the nJoy Pure Plug as the Test Winner of this review. With some proper TLC, it’ll be with you for decades to come.
Other pro points: the weighted feel makes it ideal even for advanced users, while intermediate users can also use it thanks to this model’s dimensions. The tapered tip also makes for easy insertion, so this toy gets an all-round thumbs up from me.
Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug
Getting started with anal play isn’t always easy – it can take time to work up to penetration. And when you do finally get there, this little butt plug by Doc Johnson is perfect. Smoothly textured and 0.9 inches in diameter, it’s ideal for those experimenting or finding their feet with butt play. Make sure to combine it with lots of water-based lube to ensure things run smoothly – pun absolutely intended!
This petit butt plug should be your first port-of-call if you’re a beginner wanting to up your anal play game. It’s so versatile and easy to use – just slide the butt plug in using the tapered tip (and lots of lube!) and guide yourself with the sensations. With a secure flared base, you can even wear this butt plug during foreplay. It’s even discreet enough to be able to wear in public – just make sure it’s lodged in firmly to avoid any awkward moments when walking up stairs!
b-Vibe Novice Plug
The b-Vibe Novice Plug is an ideal beginner butt plug for anyone looking to dip their toes into the amazing sensations of anal play! This silicone butt plug has a slim and tapered tip for easy insertion and a T-shaped base to keep the plug safely in place. The perfect size for extended wear and with a shape that feels comfortable to wear while using other sex toys. It has 21 vibration modes and a remote control to help you easily adjust the settings during use. Great for solo use but also ideal for use with a partner.
I’ve selected this a the best beginner butt plug out there because of its beginner-friendly shape and size, it’s overall quality, vibration features, and remote control.
The b-Vibe Novice Plug can of course be used with or without the vibrations. This is great for beginners who want to enjoy the shape and feel of the plug itself at first but wat the option to expand their anal repertoire and explore anal vibrations. The remote control is also a great way for users to easily adjust the settings while the plug is in use. A remote control also allows you to relinquish all the controls to your partner and let them decide which sensations you should enjoy!
b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug
The b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug is a powerful vibrating butt plug that also happens to be an adorable jewel butt plug! Made of body-safe silicone, this butt plug sports the perfect size for somewhat experienced anal adventurers. Bulbous and impressive enough to satisfy but not too much to take in even if you’re not into advanced anal. The 21 different vibration modes are there to powerfully pamper your butthole in all sorts of ways! Use the remote control to adjust the setting easily while wearing the plug, or let your partner take the reins and let them decide what sensation to let you enjoy.
The b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug has been selected as the winner of this category because the vibrations are VERY impressive. If you simply love anal vibrations (both external and internal) this butt plug may be what you’re looking for! Of course, the overall quality, shape, and size of this plug don’t exactly hurt the overall score. It’s suitable for a lot of different levels of experience and can provide impressive pleasure to a lot of different people!