The 8 Best Butt Plug Sets to Work Your Way Up to Amazing Anal
How We Selected Each Butt Plug Set
First, we wanted to make sure we could find a butt plug set that would meet everyone’s needs. As such, we’ve selected a wide variety of toys made from different materials and in different styles.
To help avoid brand bias, we’ve gathered our information from a variety of sources. We’ve sourced information from the manufacturers themselves as well as customer reviews; some toys we’ve also tested ourselves.
Judging each set using the same criteria, we’re able to give you an honest take on each butt plug set so you’ll know exactly what to expect before placing an order.
How Butt Plug Sets Can Help With Anal Training
“Anal training” is the process of training your anus to the point where you can comfortably enjoy penetration. The end goal may vary from person to person: you could be working towards anal sex with a partner, or anal penetration from your own dildo.
Either way, a butt plug set can help you achieve your goals. These kits generally contain a variety of plugs, ranging from smaller to larger sizes.
By starting with smaller plugs and working your way up to bigger plugs as you feel comfortable, you’re able to train your anus for more comfortable anal penetration in the future.
The best part about kits? You’ll be able to see where you’re at (and what you’re working towards next) to track your progress!
Different Types of Butt Plug Sets & What They Can Do
There are many different types of sets. Each butt plug set will have something unique about it which may make it the preferred option over alternatives.
First, you’ll need to consider the size range. While some kits are perfect for absolute beginners, they may be too small for more experienced users. Try to find a kit where the smaller size is one you already feel comfortable with.
Next, consider the texture. While rounded, smooth plugs are the go-to option for a lot of people, there are other alternatives—such as twirls or balls—that may be worth looking into.
Another consideration is the shape. Although not a requirement, we recommend tapered tips for beginners. This shape will help ease the plug into your anus, making insertion much less challenging.
Lastly, you’ll want to pick the right sex toy material. If you only use silicone lubricant then you’ll have to go with either glass or metal plugs. However, if you don’t mind using water-based lubricants then you’ll have a variety of softer materials available to you (such as silicone).
FAQ
What is a Butt Plug Set?
A butt plug set is a set or kit that contains multiple butt plugs. Generally, these kits will contain at least three plugs, often uniquely sized. This difference in sizing makes them useful for anal training, as one can start using the smallest plug in the kit and work their way up to the largest in the kit before graduating to even bigger toys (if desired).
Table of contents (15)
The 8 Best butt plug set in Test
b-Vibe Anal Training Butt Plug Set
Discreet shipping and billing15% off by email sign-upFree shipping on orders over $60
Discreet shipping & billing20% off by email sign-upFREE shipping on orders $50+
Discreet shipping & billingTheir website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+
Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+If you’re a complete beginner looking for a butt plug set, our top-rated recommendation is this butt plug start set from b-Vibe!
As with most other butt plug sets, this kit comes with various plugs of different sizes. However, the other included goodies are what sets this kit of trainer butt plugs above the competition.
Along with the plugs, you’ll also receive a lubricant applicator, anal douche, Complete Guide to Anal Play booklet, and even a travel bag.
Perfect for first-timers, start your anal journey right with the b-Vibe Rechargeable Anal Training and Education Butt Plug Set!
The b-Vibe Anal Training Butt Plug Set was rated 10 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Rating: b-Vibe Anal Training Butt Plug Set was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is silent.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of b-Vibe Anal Training Butt Plug Set felt to the reviewer.
Rating: b-Vibe Anal Training Butt Plug Set was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is gentle.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of b-Vibe Anal Training Butt Plug Set felt to the reviewer.
Are trying anal play for the first timeWant a variety of toysAre interested in anal training
Already own anal toysAre used to larger sizesNeed a budget-friendly option| Materials | Silicone |
| Length | (S) 3.9 inches, (M) 5.3 inches, (L) 5.4 inches |
| Diameter | (S) 1 inches, (M) 1.3 inches, (L) 1.6 inches |
| Rechargeable | Yes (USB) |
| Vibration patterns | 6 |
| Storage Bag Included | Yes |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
| Allergies | Latex-free , phthalate-free |
Made of siliconeIncludes anal guideSized for beginnersIncludes travel bag
Not for experienced usersNo color optionsNo size optionsThis butt plug training kit is designed with the complete beginner in mind. For that demographic, it works perfectly.
Admittedly, the price is a bit high, but we think that—for the convenience and extra educational information—this slight premium is justified.
The anal plug kit contains three different plugs in three different sizes, each made from silicone. Unfortunately, there aren’t any color or alternative sizing options offered. However, the included sizes should be fine for newcomers.
If you fall into the target demographic for this butt plug kit then we highly recommend picking it up! On the other hand, if you’ve experimented with anal play before then you may be better off going with a different kit that offers plugs in larger sizes.
Silicone Butt Plug Trainer Set
Next on our list is the budget-friendly Mood Naughty 1 Trainer Set from Doc Johnson.
Offered with either black or pink plugs, this butt plug kit includes three plugs ranging from 3 – 5 inches in length, with a maximum diameter of 1.25 inches.
Every plug in this anal plug kit is made from high-quality silicone, meaning you can safely enjoy these comfortable plugs as you work your way toward larger sizes.
Need a butt plug training kit on a budget? Then you can’t go wrong with the Mood Naughty 1 Trainer Set!
The Silicone Butt Plug Trainer Set was rated 20 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want something simpleDon’t need lube or other extrasNeed a budget-friendly optionWant an all-in-one kitPrefer other colorsRequire extra features (likes vibes)| Materials | Silicone |
| Length | (S) 3.25 inches, (M) 4 inches, (L) 5 inches |
| Insertable length | (S) 3 inches, (M) 3.75 inches, (L) 4.75 inches |
| Diameter | (S) 0.75 inches, (M) 1 inches, (L) 1.25 inches |
| Allergies | Phthalate-free |
Easy to useFlared baseThree sizesAffordableOnly for beginnersNo additional functionsNo extras includedThe Mood Naughty 1 butt plug set is a good option for a first-time anal player who already has some basic sex toy equipment on hand.
The kit is priced very affordably, giving you three high-quality plugs for less than $50. You also have two color options to choose from, which is a positive as it’s always nice to have options.
However, this butt plug starter doesn’t come with any extras. You won’t get a lube applicator, and you won’t get any lube like you might with other butt plug sets.
Still, if you already have these things on hand then there’s no need to pay for them twice. If you already have everything you need (sans the plugs themselves) then this kit of trainer butt plugs offers an affordable way to start out with anal play!
Crystal Glass Butt Plug Trainer Kit
If you’re looking for a butt plug starter kit but want the option to use any type of lube then it may be worth considering a glass option instead.
This Crystal Glass Butt Plug set includes three temperature-sensitive plugs. Being made from borosilicate glass, they can be safely used with any type of lube.
As the kit of trainer butt plugs includes three different sizes, it’s perfect for anal training with silicone lube.
Even better? This kit barely costs any more than similar butt plug sets, making it an excellent value for the money!
The Crystal Glass Butt Plug Trainer Kit was rated 30 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Use multiple types of lubePrefer weighty plugsEnjoy temperature playDon’t like the idea of glass plugsPrefer lightweight plugsWant vibes or other functions| Materials | Borosilicate Glass |
| Length | (S) 3.25 inches, (M) 4.25 inches, (L) 4.5 inches |
| Insertable length | (S) 2.75 inches, (M) 3.75 inches, (L) 4.25 inches |
| Diameter | (S) 0.8 inches, (M) 1.2 inches, (L) 1.6 inches |
| Allergies | Phthalate-free |
Perfect for temperature playExcellent range of sizesMade of borosilicate glassWorks with any lubeNo colored optionsNot ideal for all-day wearThe main selling point of this butt plug training kit is the fact that each plug is handblown using borosilicate glass. Worried about the glass breaking? No need: borosilicate glass is completely safe for anal use!
Aside from the fact that the plugs in this butt plug kit can be used with any type of lubricant (which is already a huge win for those who love silicone lube), the option to enjoy temperature play may be enticing.
Since the glass is extremely temperature sensitive, you can use this anal plug kit to enjoy chilled or heated sensations on top of the pleasures of anal penetration.
Sure, it might not have any additional features like vibrations, but we definitely think that temperature play enthusiasts will love these plugs.
Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug Set
If you’ve ever looked up butt plugs before, chances are, you’ve seen the ones with jewels before. Fortunately for you, that’s exactly what we’re looking at next.
Introducing the Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug Set! This butt plug training kit features three different sizes of plugs, which has each plug adorned with a faux jewel at the end.
Affordably priced but pleasant to look at, this butt plug kit offers a cheap way to enjoy anal play while also giving your partner a show.
With sizes ranging from little to large, you’ll have a decent amount of variety with this butt plug kit.
The Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug Set was rated 20 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Are starting anal trainingLike the cute factor of the jewelsNeed a budget-friendly optionWant weighted plugsAre used to larger sizes alreadyPrefer a t-base design| Materials | Metal |
| Insertable length | (S) 2.5 inches, (M) 3 inches, (L) 3.5 inches |
| Diameter | (S) 1.11 inches, (M) 1.35 inches, (L) 1.59 inches |
| Allergies | Latex-free , phthalate-free |
Smooth and body-safeGood range of sizesEasy to insertMade of aluminumNo jewel optionsNo plug color optionsNot weightedLike many Lovehoney products, this butt plug set is a good option for beginners and intermediate anal enjoyers. The smallest plug measures 1.11” across; the largest has a width of 1.59”.
This difference in sizing should give buyers a long time to enjoy these trainer butt plugs, assuming they don’t intend to go to larger sizes right away.
The faux jewels themselves are a nice touch, although it would be nice to see some color options here. Still, if jeweled is the look you’re going for then this option is preferable to other butt plug sets.
Like the previous option, these metal plugs can also be used for temperature play, though within a smaller range of temperatures (you don’t want to melt the jewel!).
Overall, for less than $60, we think this set offers a nice aesthetic and good value for the money.
Aneros Peridise Beginner Anal Set
Offering the opportunity to achieve what Aneros has dubbed the “Super-O”, the Aneros Peridise butt plug set is perfect for the person who wants to give their current orgasms a little boost.
Although these toys aren’t trainer butt plugs, their modest sizing and ease of use make them a great option for complete beginners.
Measuring 1” wide and 4” long, the sizing is big enough to offer good stimulation without being visually intimidating.
Designed to transfer the natural movements of the body into powerful internal stimulation, the Aneros Peridise manages to offer powerful orgasmic potential in a small butt plug starter set!
The Aneros Peridise Beginner Anal Set was rated 50 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Are new to anal playWant stronger orgasmsNeed a budget-friendly optionAre used to larger toysDon’t want a white anal toyWant vibrations| Materials | ABS Plastic |
| Length | 4 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.25 inches |
| Diameter | (S) 3/4 inches, (M) 1 inches |
| Allergies | Phthalate-free |
T-bar baseDesigned for p-spot stimulationUnique, white coloringWaterproofMade of ABS plasticOne size onlyThe majority of feedback we were able to find for this butt plug kit was positive. In fact, only one person was left dissatisfied (their main complaint was the small size). As such, we wouldn’t recommend this anal plug kit to more experienced users.
However, if you’ve never used a butt plug training kit or other type of anal toy before, you shouldn’t run into any sizing issues. Although modest, the design and shape of this toy are what really make it perform.
It is made of ABS plastic. This isn’t ideal (as ABS isn’t completely non-porous) but it is a better option than PVC. Priced at less than $25, the Aneros Peridise kit offers a great way to enjoy stronger orgasms during routine sexual encounters while also getting some anal experience at the same time.
Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Kit
The Lovehoney Bumper Booty butt plug kit is a six-piece kit that offers multiple toys at an affordable price.
Inside this butt plug training kit, you’ll find two plugs, anal beads, a prostate massager, an anal douche, and a bullet vibe.
The bullet vibe can slide inside the included toys, adding an extra layer of stimulation to this simple anal plug kit.
Sized with the beginner in mind, the Bumper Booty Bundle offers an easy, body-safe way to get into anal play without needing to break the bank.
The Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Kit was rated 10 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Rating: Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Kit was rated 3 out of 5, which means it is fairly quiet.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Kit felt to the reviewer.
Rating: Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Kit was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is gentle.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Kit felt to the reviewer.
Are new to anal playWant to start anal trainingLove varietyWant strong vibrationsHave anal experiencePrefer using silicone lube| Materials | Silicone |
| Insertable length | 2.2 inches to 5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.03 inches to 1.27 inches |
| Rechargeable | No (requires 1 x AAA battery) |
| Vibration modes | Various |
| Allergies | Phthalate-Free |
Great value for moneyFour unique toysBullet vibe includedMade of siliconeSmall range of sizesVibrator can be hard to removeRequired AAA battery not includedAs a butt plug starter set, the Bumper Booty Bundle really shines. The butt plug set offers various toys within a small range of sizes, which is ideal for complete beginners.
However, if you’ve previously used a butt plug set before, you will likely find that the toys included in this kit are a bit too small.
Most kits with trainer butt plugs go larger than the plugs included in this kit, making the Bumper Booty Bundle a poor choice for those who have already started anal training.
That said, this butt plug set does offer an excellent value for the money. With four toys, a bullet vibe, and an anal douche included, you’ll only need to grab a little lube before giving this kit a test run!
Satisfyer Booty Call Anal Plugs
Discreet shipping & billingTheir website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+
Discreet shipping & billing4.7/5 rating of 100k reviewsFREE shipping on orders $59+
Discreet shipping & billingOnly body-safe materialsFREE shipping on orders $70+The next butt plug set we’ll be looking at is the Satisfyer Booty Call Anal Plugs set!
This set is less of a kit of trainer butt plugs and more of a variety pack. It features a two-bulb, a three-bulb, and a spiral butt plug in the package.
With sizing running from small to medium, this kit can function as the perfect butt plug starter set (since it gives you something to work up to before graduating to larger sizes).
The kit may not offer the widest range when it comes to sizes, but what it lacks in sizing it more than makes up for with variety.
If you’re trying to find the butt plug sets that offer the most sensations in a single package, you can’t go wrong with the Satisfyer Booty Call Anal Plugs!
The Satisfyer Booty Call Anal Plugs was rated 20 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want a variety of plug designsP