How Long Can You Leave a Butt Plug In?

By Kevin Foley / June 10, 2022

Most manufacturers don’t recommend leaving a butt plug in for more than 2 to 3 hours max.

Let’s be honest though: if you’re on this page, you’re probably not too concerned with the manufacturer’s recommendations!

You just want to know how long can you leave a butt plug in! Still, safety is an important factor to consider when enjoying anal toys, so at what point should you draw the line?

Well, this article aims to answer all of your questions regarding long-term butt plug wearing, from important preparations to potential roadblocks.

Do you have your favorite plug at the ready? Let’s learn how to get the most out of it!

The Issues With Leaving Your Butt Plug In

First off, it’s important to note that extended butt plug use isn’t something that’s suitable for complete buttplug beginners.

If you’ve never worn a butt plug for more than an hour or so, you’ll want to work up to longer sessions before even considering an all-day session!

This is important because overdoing it can actually be harmful, perhaps more so than you may have thought.

The entire experience will be much more enjoyable if you’re genuinely prepared, rather than simply winging it.

Medical Issues

When inserted, a butt plug provides a certain level of pleasure and “fullness”.

However, this “fullness” is partially the result of the plug pressing against the inside of your anus, which can cause circulation issues if left in for too long.

Also, the anus itself isn’t self-lubricating so you’ll need to be routinely applying more lubricant. If you don’t, chafing, discomfort, and even bleeding could become an issue.

How long can you leave a butt plug in?

Well, it depends on how long you can comfortably wear your plug, as well as having sufficient lube on-hand.

Practical Issues

The act of wearing a butt plug throughout the day is both naughty and exciting, but you probably don’t want to share your erotic journey with your friends (or co-workers).

Obviously, the idea of your plug falling out mid-shift is a nightmare! You also don’t want someone to notice a “strange bump” on your bum while wearing a butt plug to work.

Fortunately, these potential problems can be addressed by wearing the appropriate undergarments and choosing the correct plug size!

Choosing the Right Plug for the Job

Now that you know the risks, it’s time to get down to business: choosing the right plug!

If you’re experienced enough to be attempting an all-day session, you probably know what size you prefer. However, it’s important to remember that comfort is a fairly considerable factor (especially if you may be moving around a lot throughout the day!).

We recommend choosing a T-base plug to reduce the risk of “losing” your plug in your butt, rather than a simple flared plug.

Silicone Vs. Metal

Chances are, you already have a favorite plug picked out for this special occasion. However, if you don’t, then you’ll need to decide what type of material you want for your plug.

Silicone and metal butt plugs are the most common choices for all-day wear (although you could also opt for a glass plug).

Each option has its advantages and disadvantages.

Silicone plugs are flexible, making them extremely comfortable for all-day use. The downside?

You can’t use silicone lubricant with these wearable butt plugs! This kind of sucks because silicone lube is the longest-lasting lubricant.

Most silicone plugs recommend only using water-based lube, although some may work with oil-based lubricants as well.

Metal plugs are rigid and temperature-reactive.

This means—unless you warm up your plug beforehand—it might be a bit cold the first time you insert the plug.

Thankfully, the plug will warm up rather quickly so this doesn’t present a long-term issue. Still, the lack of flexibility may be uncomfortable, especially if you’ll be sitting a lot. 

 

What If It Falls Out?

You can minimize the risk of your plug falling out by selecting a lightweight plug that you’ve previously used successfully.

Being familiar with the plug is helpful, as you can tell if it’s shifting excessively.

That said, being active throughout the day might cause a bit too much movement: what to do? Well, this is where choosing the right underwear can come in handy!

Skip the thongs, jock straps, and boxers. Instead, choose a set of underwear that not only covers your bum but holds it tight as well! Great choices include briefs, trunks, and boyshorts. You can even get a butt plug harness to keep it in place. Or, if you’re a penis owner you can buy a cock ring butt plug that attaches to your penis.

Selecting Lube for Your Plug

So far, we’ve selected the perfect plug and managed to match it with the right underwear.

What’s next?

Lubricant, of course!

Depending on personal preferences and plug material, you’ll have the option of using either water-based, oil-based, or silicone lubricant

Silicone lasts the longest; water-based lasts the shortest amount of time.

How Long Can You Leave a Butt Plug In Before Relubricating?

There isn’t an established time period between inserting your plug and relubricating it.

Essentially, if your plug starts to feel like it’s getting dry, it’s time to lube up!

Of course, you don’t need to wait until this point: you could also re-apply lube every couple of hours to be safe.

When going out in public wearing a butt plug, you’ll want to bring two things with you:

  • A bottle of lubricant
  • A plastic bag

The reason behind bringing the lubricant is self-explanatory, but what about the bag?

Well, if you decided you’re done for the day, the bag gives you a place to store your plug.

Remember, water-based lubricant doesn’t last as long as other types of lube, so plan accordingly!

Going to the Bathroom With a Butt Plug in Your Anus

So far, we’ve covered picking a plug, selecting underwear, and lubrication practices…

But what if you have to go to the bathroom!?

Not to worry: we have an answer for that too!

Potential Problem #1

It’s possible to leave your butt plug in while you pee. However, this requires absolute control over your pelvic floor, which is used both to hold the plug in AND release urine.

Generally speaking, it’s a better idea to just take the plug out.

This will reduce the likelihood of you dropping the plug into the toilet, which is not only gross but could also damage your plug.

Potential Problem #2

If you’re taking a poop, well, you’re gonna have to take that plug out: no questions asked.

That said, this is a great time to re-apply your lubricant!

Summary

So, how long can you leave a butt plug in? It’s entirely up to you and your personal comfort! Wearing your favorite plug all day is fine, but we don’t recommend wearing a plug overnight.

Contrary to what “some people” might have you believe, wearing a butt plug all day won’t turn your backside into a gaping hole. Your anus is pretty resilient, so once you take the plug out, it will quickly resume to its previous size. That said, your muscles will probably be a bit tired after a long day of butt plug play, so you should take a day or two off. Once your body’s well-rested, you can get back to enjoying discreet public butt plug use!