6 Best Male Butt Plugs

Why I Chose It

I had to pick the Aneros Progasm as the test winner because Aneros’s toys are specifically designed for prostate stimulation, and the Progasm is their bestseller! Thanks to its ergonomic shape and rigid build this male butt plug provides an intense prostate massage. I think one of its biggest highlights is the ABS plastic build, which offers that rigid, intense stimulation without the extra weight that you can find with glass or metal toys.

Our tester Moe highlighted the design of this toy saying “Its larger girth puts more pressure on the prostate so you don’t have to wait as long for the buildup that prostate massage usually takes to reach the pleasure.” He also pointed out that the ABS plastic felt “very smooth,” and made the insertion “super easy.” I also like that you can easily use the Aneros Progasm during sex! As Moe said: “My second favorite use of the Progasm is during sex. The more focused pressure makes sex and orgasm way more intense.”

Another feature that I like about the Aneros Progasm is the external “tabs.” They allow you to rock the massager back and forth inside you by contracting your pelvic floor muscles. This unique feature gives you an engaging way to stimulate the prostate completely hands-free!

Why I Chose It

I think the We-Vibe Vector+ is the best male butt plug for beginners because it’s a high-quality, beginner-friendly, and adjustable anal toy for men. Its size and tapered tip are perfect for those who are complete anal play newbies, it’s comfortable, easy to insert, but big enough to give your prostate a nice massage. I love that the neck itself is quite slim, making it comfortable to wear for longer periods of time. It’s also designed to stimulate both the prostate and the perineum at the same time.

Our tester Robbie really enjoyed the design of this butt plug. As he put it: “As soon as I put it in I feel the most incredible and breathtaking pressure on my prostate. It isn’t overwhelming and the shape of the vibrator’s stem stimulates my prostate very well, giving me intense pleasure.”

One of the main highlights of this product is the app compatibility, which means you use it as a wearable butt plug, and discretely control the vibrations, or share it with your partner! Robbie raved about the We-Vibe App saying: “I am a complete slut for the We-Vibe app and it’s in numerous personal settings each user can cater to themselves with.” I’ve tried many We-Vibe products, and I personally like the app, however, some of our testers said that the connectivity may be unreliable at times, but I know that’s a common issue with most app-controlled sex toys.

Why I Chose It

The Lovehoney Butt Tingler is a simple, and affordable option for those looking for a beginner-friendly male butt plug that can offer some buzz to your backdoor. Emiel, our Bedbible tester, who reviewed the Butt Tingler liked the design and mentioned that this butt plug is “comfortable to use and the wide base held it in place and made for a good grip.”

Emiel also pointed out that the vibrations aren’t super powerful, but he still enjoyed the stimulation it provided. He said that if he was “just getting into anal, this would be a phenomenal toy,” which I completely agree with! It might not be the most powerful anal vibrator on the market, but I think that those users who want to explore vibrating male butt plugs on a budget will enjoy it!

I really like how simple and easy to use this butt plug is, however, in my experience, butt plugs with very little difference in diameter between the largest point and the neck of the toy tend to pop out during use. So, if you’re looking for a more wearable option, I would recommend that you go for something that has a longer and slimmer neck, like the We-Vibe Vector+.

Why I Chose It

The b-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 is hands down one of the most innovative and pleasurable anal toys on the market. I chose for those who want to elevate anal pleasure and want to experience a realistic rimming sensation. Our Bedbible tester Edie said: “This is literally the best anal toy I have ever had the pleasure of handling.” And I can see why—this plug takes anal play to a whole new level with its unique rotating beads and vibrating functions. As Edie described, “The rotating metal beads in the neck of the plug are genius and mimic the feel of intense analingus.” It’s this combination of features that makes the Rimming Plug 2 stand out from the crowd!

What I love most about this toy is how well-designed and versatile it is. The plug itself is tapered and pretty firm, which provides targeted prostate stimulation. The vibrations are powerful, customizable, and remote-controlled, perfect for hands-free solo play and all kinds of couple’s play. Plus, its body-safe silicone and ergonomic shape make it comfortable to wear, even for extended periods.

Why I Chose It

The njoy Pure Plug is the best metal butt plug I’ve ever tested. There are much simple metal or glass butt plugs on the market, but the Pure Plug’s unique shape perfectly targets the prostate and provides that intense weighty pressure, which feels incredible! I also picked it out for more advanced users who are looking for a big male butt plug. 

Our tester Allen, who reviewed this toy for us loved the quality and design of this toy. As he put it: “Is there such a thing as a Rolls Royce of butt plugs? No clue, but I think the design of the Pure Plug makes it a good contender.” He also pointed out that the Pure Plug Large, despite its impressive size, is very comfortable to wear, and stays secure, which means you can easily use it during sex, or use it as a wearable plug: “The best part of it all was that I could wear it all day long, running errands, cooking and cleaning, and sitting at my desk working, the Pure Plug allowed me to do all of it with no issues.” While I agree that stainless steel butt plugs are super comfortable, the Pur Plug has a loop base, which was mainly designed for prostate massages, so it may not be as convenient to sit with as plugs with a T-bar base. 

All in all, as a professional sex toy reviewer, I have to say that njoy sex toys are one of the most luxurious on the market. Yes, they are a bit pricey, but if you are a fan of anal play, and want to splurge on a high-end experience, I would get totally get this butt plug! If the large version seems too intimidating, you can try the original njoy Pure Plug version.

Why I Chose It

The Lovehoney Triple Base Anal Training Kit is a simple, easy-to-use kit that I chose for those starting their anal training journey. I specifically chose this set, because all three butt plugs are tapered and have a slim T-bar shape that’s very comfortable to wear, even for extended time. Plus, all three sizes gradually increase in size making them perfect for getting your bum ready for anal fun. I like that two butt plugs feature vibrations controlled by the remote making your play much easier and more comfortable, especially during a couple’s play.

According to our tester’s review, all three plugs are “well-designed” and easy to use: “The silicone plugs are very easy to slide into place with just a little lube.” When it comes to the vibrations, Dani said that they are “fairly quiet and handled being used in the shower fairly well,” but they are not super strong and are quite buzzy, so I don’t recommend them if you are after strong, rumbly vibes.