The 10 Best Realistic Anal Dildos for Lifelike Booty Sensations
| Test Winner | Cheapest | Beginner | Dual-Density | Glass | Butt Plug | Vibrating | Girthy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| Vixen Mustang | Lonehoney Curved Dildo | Vixen Spur | Lovehoney Dual-Density Dildo | Lovehoney Sensual Glass Dildo | Si Novelties Penis Plug | Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Dildo | Vixen Lonestar |
| Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
How We Tested the Realistic Anal Dildos
Here at Bedbible, we have the best expert tester team whose user experience reflects the reviews you’ll find further down this page. I’ve spent an additional 30 hours researching and writing this review in my quest to find the 10 best realistic anal dildos!
The product rankings are based on quality, price, how well a toy resembles real body parts, and suitability according to the level of experience.
If some of our lovely testers have tested one of the recommended products, you’ll find a link that says “Read Full Review”, where you can go see the individual testers’ opinions on the particular realistic butt sex toy.
Realistic Anal Dildo Materials
Just like I can be opinionated when choosing clothing materials (wool, ick), I have learned that I have to lean toward a similar approach when choosing sex toys. The most important difference is, however, that these materials most likely go inside your body parts. Therefore, I have listed materials to look for (and materials to avoid), when buying your realistic anal dildo.
Materials to look for:
Silicone – flexible, soft surface, used by most medicinal industries because bacteria cannot enter the material, easy to clean due to surface residue only, the material I’d recommend for a realistic anal toy.
Glass – non-flexible, smooth surface, made to withstand pressure and shifts in temperature, can be used with any lube, easy to clean due to surface residue only, great for hyper-allergic people.
Metal or steel – non-flexible, smooth surface, great if you like rigid toys, also easy to clean due to surface residue only. Be sure that the metal/steel doesn’t contain nickel.
Materials to avoid:
PVC – this is one of the materials I’d avoid because it oftentimes contains toxic additives. Although the material is pliable and soft to the touch, I’d keep my distance from any porous material.
TPR/TPE/Imitation flesh and jelly – also porous materials, and similar to PVC in that, it can contain toxic additives depending on the manufacturer. I’d consider anal toys in these materials a one-night stand.
Overall, I’d recommend you follow these general guidelines.
- They should be; non-porous, meaning fluids and/or other bacteria cannot enter the product.
- Realistic anal dildo material should be free from phthalates.
- If you choose a porous material, I’d use a condom to maintain optimal hygiene.
How to Choose the Best Realistic Anal Dildo
The universal rule when it comes to anal toys is, you should always choose one with a flared base, suction cup, or an actual stopper.
- Size – you are stimulating a muscle, so depending on your experience, I’d say start off small. This applies to both length and girth size.
- Shape – this depends on your area of exploration. If you so are looking to stimulate the prostate, I’d recommend you look for one that bents a little.
- Material – if you want your realistic anal dildo to last a long time, I’d go for one made of silicone, glass, or steel, or metal.
- Texture – consider whether you’d like it to be veiny or if you’d like added textures like bumps and ribs.
- Additional features – maybe you’d like a vibrating anal toy. Also, if you’re only doing solo play, a suction cup base allows you to maneuver hands-free.
FAQ
What is a Realistic Anal Dildo?
The reason it's called a "Realistic Anal Dildo" is that it mimics veins, sculpted heads, balls, and skin tones. For some, these features make the experience feel more realistic. You can use a realistic anal toy by stimulating your anus internally from penetration, but also externally by rubbing your dildo/toy on, or against your anus. Below you'll find a detailed list of the top 10 best realistic anal dildos along with information on where to buy one for yourself or a loved one!
Table of contents (15)
The 10 Best Realistic Anal Dildos in Test
Vixen Mustang VixSkin
Discreet shipping and billing15% off by email sign-upFree shipping on orders over $60
Discreet shipping & billingTheir website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+
Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+
Discreet shipping & billingShipping rate: $8FREE shipping on orders $99+This soft and flexible silicone dildo with a dual-density shaft feels like the real deal. With Vixen’s patented formula, this dildo consists of a soft outer layer and a rock-solid core.
Veiny textures and a pronounced head ensure ultimate anal pleasure. Smother it in your favorite water-based lubricant, and relax knowing the suction cup is at your service!
The Vixen Mustang VixSkin was rated 50 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Want realistic features Want an anal dildo with a suction cupSeek to experience authentic sensations Want a curved shaft for extra prostate stimulation 
Are a beginner Haven't tried anal penetration before | Length | 7.5 inches |
| Insertable length | 6.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.5 inches |
| Materials | Silicone |
| Flexibility | Medium |
| Colors Available | 3 varieties of skin color - 1 rainbow option |
Dual-density shaft Harness compatibleMade of silicone Suction cupTemperature responsive qualities 
Needs an 1.5 inch O-ring for harness use Some say the suction cup isn't the most powerful The Vixen Mustang is a great, versatile option for intermediate to experienced anal toy users. It’s also great for those who want to level up size-wise due to its flexible, soft VixSkin silicone!
Its pronounced head and like-line penis veins increase the level of intensity. The dual-density shaft makes for great prostate stimulation, and the suction cup provides room for creative solutions, such as maneuvering hands-free!
The silicone material makes it easy to clean and store. However, if you like more rigid anal dildos, this might not be the one for you.
Lovehoney Curved Suction Cup Dildo
This 5.5-inch people-pleaser is well-suited for curious beginners to intermediate users! If you’re still a little hesitant about extremely realistic features such as veins and prominent penis shafts, this curved cutie might be your perfect match.
Its slightly tapered shape provides multiple sensations with every thrust. The curved shaft stimulates your anal nerves, and can be rotated to help you reach powerful prostate orgasms!
Want to provide pleasure? The suction cup makes it possible to pair with a harness. Use a 1.25-inch O-ring to secure the pack!
The Lovehoney Curved Suction Cup Dildo was rated 20 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want a smooth silicone surface Want an anal dildo with a suction cupLike the realistic look, but don't want veiny textures Are looking for a harness compatible anal toy Want a curved shaft for extra prostate stimulation Want veiny textures Like a more pronounced head Are a complete beginner | Length | 6 inches |
| Insertable length | 5.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.1 inches |
| Materials | Silicone |
| Flexibility | Not very flexible |
| Colors Available | 1 - Black |
Soft and smooth surfaceMade of silicone Suction cupPerfect for beginner and intermediate levelSimple and sleek design Design may be too simple for some The shaft is not very pronounced You should go for this if you’re a beginner who wants to experiment with slightly bigger options! Its sleek and simple design makes for a compliant companion that provides you with tapered thrusts rather than textures.
This anal dildo is quite rigid because of the silicone material. This can improve navigation, which allows you to stay focused on all the tingly sensations!
The suction power is very strong and it’s great in a strap-on harness. It’s also waterproof, so you can bring it to the shower and get creative with temperature play, all while it’s stuck to the wall – sounds cozy right?
However, if you are searching for a more realistic-looking anal dildo, this toy might not be the one for you!
Vixen VixSkin Spur
Looking for the ultimate, beginner-friendly realistic-looking anal dildo? The Vixen Spur Slimline is here to please! Made with the life-like VixSkin material, you’ll get both soft and hard sensations that aren’t easily forgettable.
You can really get a feel of your inner natural contours due to the flexibility, all the while you enjoy the texture of veins and a perfectly pronounced shaft. It’s not the girthiest player on the field, however, the girth is perfect for practicing or just as a beginner’s anal toy.
Although it does have flared base, it isn’t hollow enough to produce a vacuum which means it doesn’t function as a literal suction cup.
The Vixen VixSkin Spur was rated 20 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Are a beginnerWant an ultra realistic anal dildoLike a softer, more flexible surfaceWant a slimmer option Want a harness compatible dildoEnjoy larger anal toysWant a more rigid toy| Length | 6 inches |
| Insertable length | 5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.2 inches |
| Materials | Silicone |
| Flexibility | Very flexible |
| Colors Available | 3 - vanilla, caramel and chocolate |
Perfect for beginnersVery realistic-looking Slim design Made of VixSlim siliconeNo suction cup This is the ideal realistic anal dildo for beginners! Its soft surface provides flexibility and realistic sensations.
It’s slim with a slight bend, which makes it easy to insert and navigate whilst being used. It doesn’t have a lot of veiny features, however, the dual-density shaft makes up for that.
It’s not the cheapest option out there, but if you like the realistic feel and look, this one is for you!
Lovehoney Dual-Density Dildo with Balls
If you need a big boy like SZA, you might be looking at the one! With a strong suction cup, you can play with this however you’d like.
The sculpted pronounced head provides exceptional stimulation from the get-go. Add the veiny details, testicles, and an ultra-sturdy suction cup, and you’ll be having intense anal sensations.
Made from silicone and fully waterproof, you can use it in the shower with a generous amount of water-based lubricant.
However, it is a big fella. So I’d recommend a proper warm-up and lots of lube! But if you’re looking to size up your realistic anal dildos, this girthy dual-density one is a great option.
The Lovehoney Dual-Density Dildo with Balls was rated 60 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Are looking for a larger anal dildo Like an ultra-realistic anal toyPrefer a more rigid material Want a harness compatible dildoWant a toy with testicles Are a beginnerWant a more flexible toy| Length | 8 inches |
| Insertable length | 7 inches |
| Diameter | 1.6 inches |
| Materials | Silicone |
| Flexibility | No |
| Colors Available | 1 |
Dual-density Suction cup base Very realistic-looking Harness compatible Too large and girthy for some Too rigid for someLack of different skin color tones A great anal toy for the experienced ones! The suction cup and balls make it easier to use solo, or with a partner. Pair it with a harness, and you’ll get even more playful options.
The head is quite pronounced, however, the veiny details don’t give much difference in texture sensations. So if you want an intense feeling from the beginning of penetration, this offers just that.
For some, the detailing of the veins may be a little too vague. Otherwise, it’s a really great option for larger anal penetration.
Its non-porous silicone makes it rigid but also ultra-hygienic since no liquids can get through it.
Lovehoney Slimline Sensual Glass Dildo
This sleek and beautifully detailed realistic glass dildo is perfect if you want to take anal stimulation to another level! Its got enhanced realistic features like curved head and shaft textures. Perfect for a deep prostate massage. Although, if you are looking for a hyper-realistic anal toy, you might wanna keep scrolling.
Heat it in warm water or cool it down in an ice bath, and immerse yourself in all the different sensations this glass toy has to offer.
If you’re new to anal play, I’d recommend you start off slow and gentle. And remember, you don’t have to insert the full length. Additionally, I’d be a little careful with this if you’re into anal penetration with fast friction since the flared base is a little small.
The Lovehoney Slimline Sensual Glass Dildo was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Want to play with different temperatures Enjoy intense anal stimulation Like or are curious about glass toysPrefer a soft anal toy Are looking for hyper-realistic anal dildos | Length | 7 inches |
| Insertable length | 6.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.1 inches |
| Materials | Glass |
| Flexibility | No |
| Colors Available | 1 |
Incredible details for deeper sensations Handblown glass Waterproof Hyperallergenic Compatible with both silicone and water-based lubricants The flared base is a little small Tends to be slippery with lube I wouldn’t call it an ultra-realistic anal dildo, however, the details on this beauty mimic a penis very well. You can look forward to natural contours, smooth curves, and a rock-hard toy!
The head is suitable for prostate stimulation which makes it a great option for exploration. The length and girth are suitable for beginners as well as experienced users.
It does demand a little more control because of its smaller base, as well as its slippery tendencies. On the plus side, it’s compatible with all types of lube. And it’s just simply gorgeous!
Si Novelties Small Penis Butt Plug
Don’t be fooled by this rather innocent-looking butt plug. For most parts, its width matches its length providing you with a feeling of fulfillment! With a very pronounced head and veiny details, it looks quite realistic.
A handsome little one, perfect for those of you who are looking for a wearable plug. It’s also a great option for beginners. Especially if you want to train your anal muscles since the width changes slightly.
It is, however, made of non-porous materials, so I’d pair this with a condom. Add your favorite lube and you’re good to go!
The Si Novelties Small Penis Butt Plug was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Are a beginner Want continuous anal stimulationWant a smaller option with pronounced features Enjoy deeper penetration Prefer larger anal toysPrefer non-porous anal toys| Length | 4.5 inches |
| Insertable length | 4 inches |
| Diameter | 1.4 inches |
| Materials | Soft Plastic |
| Flexibility | Medium |
| Condom safe | Yes |
| Colors Available | 1 |
Really pronounced head T-shaped base Perfect for beginners The center hole is suitable for a mini bullet vibrator Made of soft plasticSome say it falls out easily Lack of different skin color tones This is a great option for beginners and for those of you who’d like a wearable butt plug! It looks realistic, however, it’s only available in one skin tone.
It’s equipped with a nice T-shaped stopper, providing grip and thrust control. Since the material is non-porous soft plastic, I wouldn’t count on this being in your toybox for years. Clean it with a good sex toy cleaner, and keep it individually stored for optimal hygiene.
Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Rechargeable Dildo
Eager for that butt buzz? Look no further babes! This realistic anal dildo has 6 vibrations to send your backdoor on a pleasure trip. The slightly curved, well-defined head can be targeted toward the prostate or the backside of the g-spot for extra intensity!
With a handy remote control, you can control it without fumbling around. You can also let loose, and have a partner handle the remote for you. This, of course, requires some communication.
Its solid core makes movements much easier, while the surface is soft and smooth! Almost like the real deal.
The Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Rechargeable Dildo was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Rating: Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Rechargeable Dildo was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is silent.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Rechargeable Dildo felt to the reviewer.
Rating: Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Rechargeable Dildo was rated 3 out of 5, which means it is quite powerful.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of Lifelike Lover Luxe Realistic Rechargeable Dildo felt to the reviewer.
Want a vibrating realistic anal dildoLike clear, defined veinsEnjoy strong vibrations Aren't a complete beginnerPrefer larger anal toysPrefer less pronounced realistic features | Length | 6 inches |
| Insertable length | 5.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.6 inches |
| Materials | Silicone |
| Flexibility | Medium |
| Colors Available | 1 |
| Vibration modes | 6 |
| Rechargeable | Yes |
Remote control makes it easier to use soloUSB rechargeable Strong core 6 vibrations Looks very realistic Suction cup isn't the strongest Not waterproofOn/off button is difficult to find If you love realistic-looking anal dildos and want to spice up your collection, this vibrating option is just the right one! The remote control is a super fun addition that enables freedom to maneuver and adjust with ease.
The lifelike lover has 6 vibrations modes and patterns, and it can be recharged with a USB. However, there’s only one color option available. Some reviews mention that it’s a little too big for beginners, so keep that in mind!
The curvy head is great for massaging the p-spot or stimulating the g-spot from behind! An important note is to never use the same dildo for vaginal and anal penetration. Stay hygienic!
Vixen Creations Vixskin Lonestar
This grandiose girthy realistic-looking dildo could be a jaw-dropper for some! This is for experienced users only.
If you are comfortable with anal play, this could be a great addition to your collection. It’s made of the fabulous VixSkin, ensuring realistic textures with a sturdy center. Now, this Lonestar just needs a partner who can handle its many nuances.
Judging by the looks of it, the suction cup isn’t the strongest. Maybe someone might prove me wrong eventually? With that being said, I’d say it’s compatible with a harness. So if you want to strap it on and play with fulfilling anal sensations, this is your sign!
Warm up, and get comfortable – the Lonestar is here to stay.