The 13 Best Tail Butt Plugs to Bring Out Your Inner Animal
How We Rated and Reviewed Tail Butt Plugs
It took us over 30 hours to write this list of the best tail butt plugs, and you might be wondering why. Every review is based on hours of research using personal experience, manufacturer websites, and user reviews to compile information. The products below aren’t the only ones we consider for this list; they’re just the only ones that made the cut!
Each product has been individually assessed using the “Bedbible Rating” system, a numerical system that makes it easy to see where products shine (and where they could use some improvement). There’s no such thing as a “perfect” sex toy, which is why—in addition to reading about the good points of a product—you’ll be able to read about the downsides.
Easy to skim but filled with helpful information for the curious reader, we’re sure you’ll be able to find the perfect tail butt plug using our list of recommendations!
How to Choose Your Ideal Tail Butt Plug
It might be tempting to click “Buy Now” on the first cute plug you see but you should actually put some thought into your next furry tail butt plug! Below, we’ve written a short list of factors for you to consider (as well as why they actually matter!) while searching for your new favorite plug.
- Plug Size – There are many different sizes of butt plugs available, so you shouldn’t have any trouble finding the right size. If you’re new to anal play then we’d recommend starting with more conservative options (you can always work your way up to larger toys!).
- Plug Shape – The shape of the plug will affect two things: how easy the toy is to insert & how it feels during insertion/removal. Plugs with taped tips are the easiest to insert, and those with a longer taper will be even easier. While many plugs are smooth, some companies do offer ribbed plugs that provide added stimulation during insertion/removal.
- Material – Silicone is the best soft plug material. However, glass and metal are also great options if you enjoy temperature play. All three of these materials are non-porous, meaning the plug can be sterilized after use. You’ll also want to consider the material used to make the tail. While some toys do use real animal fur, most utilize faux fur instead.
- Vibration – Although optional, many people find that using an anal vibrator is more satisfying than a simple butt plug. If you do decide to go with a vibrating toy, we’d recommend making sure that it offers enough functions (speeds & patterns) to make it worth spending the extra money for the feature.
- Ease of Cleaning – All plugs can be cleaned using antibacterial soap and warm water. Non-porous materials can be sterilized, but if your tail butt plug contains electronic components then you won’t be able to sterilize it using boiling water. Plugs with removable tails will be the easiest to clean, although it’s not too hard to clean a plug with a non-removable tail either.
- Price – Obviously, a large vibrating butt plug is going to cost more than a plain plug. Still, prices can vary quite a bit, which means you can usually find a great deal no matter what type of plug you’re after. It’s a good idea to compare prices from multiple websites if you want to get the best deals.
FAQ
What is a Tail Butt Plug?
A tail butt plug is a butt plug (which may be made from silicone, glass, metal, or another material) that has a “tail” attached to it. These come in many different designs, so whether you’re looking for a pig tail butt plug or a horse tail butt plug, chances are, there’s a toy out there that fits exactly what you’re looking for. While most of the tails are made of faux fur, some high-end tails are made of actual animal fur, making them perfect for bringing your fantasies to life! Like normal butt plugs, these toys come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and styles, allowing you to find the perfect plug for nearly any scenario.
Table of contents (21)
The 13 Best tail butt plugs in Test
DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug
If you want to feel a bit “foxy” then buying this fox tail butt plug should be a no-brainer! The long and fluffy tail is sure to tickle and tease your partner as you rub against them, perfect for any fox-based fantasies you two might indulge in.
Whereas some plugs are so light that you can barely tell they’re inside you, this DOMINIX tail butt plug weighs 6.7 ounces so you’re sure to notice the stimulating sensations in your rear! The added weight is sure to enhance orgasms, whether you’re having sex with your partner or using a vibrator on yourself.
Since the plug is made out of water-safe metal you can easily heat or cool this toy to your desired temperature before insertion, adding another level of fun to this foxy tail plug!
The DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug was rated 40 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Want to try temperature playNeed a detachable tailLove the fox design
Have no experience with anal play Want one-piece designPrefer silicone plugsWant 3+ inches of insertable length| Materials | Steel, faux hair |
| Length | 14.5 inches |
| Insertable length | 2.75 inches |
| Diameter | 1.19 inches |
| Adjustable | No |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
| Allergies | Latex-Free , Phthalate-Free |
Heavy plug weightPerfect for solo & partner playComes in a satin bagCan be gently tugged upon
Minimal insertable lengthNot adjustableSmall plug sizeNot as fluffy as photos implyThis is one of the best tail butt plugs for a very reasonable price, which is why I chose this as today’s test winner! The tail looks realistic enough for nearly any foxy encounters you might be planning, and the toy can even take some light tugging for added sensations.
This is definitely a high-quality tail plug overall, although (as some users have noted) the actual tail isn’t quite as poofy as implied in the photos.
The tail is especially good for teasing your partner since the tail is long enough to cover the “goods”, driving your partner wild before they brush it aside. The tail uses a screw-on design so it can be removed for easier cleaning, but some people have struggled doing this. For an easier time, we’d recommend wiping off the plug to reduce lubrication before attempting to remove the tail from the toy.
Blush Temptasia Bunny Tail Pom Butt Plug
If you love a bargain, think bunnies are cute, and want a simple way to spice up your partner (or solo) play, then you might want to check out this bunny tail butt plug from Blush Tempasia!
Designed to look like the puffy tail of a little black rabbit, this toy is perfect for all-day use thanks to the soft fur & t-base design. The tail can also be removed for easy cleaning or plug-only use.
If you want a way to look cute and enjoy some anal stimulation throughout your play then this tail butt plug might be just the thing for you!
The Blush Temptasia Bunny Tail Pom Butt Plug was rated 20 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want something you can leave inPrefer a silicone plugLove bunniesAre on a budgetWant to use silicone lubeWant a vibrating toyAre looking for a lengthy toy| Materials | Silicone, faux fur |
| Length | 5 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.4 inches |
| Adjustable | No |
| Waterproof | Yes |
Cruelty-freeRemovable tailT-base designEasy to cleanOne color onlyShort insertable lengthToo short to pull easilySince it’s based on a rabbit’s tail this tail butt plug is relatively short and poofy compared to other tail plugs. The downside of that is you won’t be able to grab and lightly pull on it very easily, but the upside is that you can wear this toy discreetly throughout your day with much fuss!
If you love wearing a tail butt plug around the house as you clean but are worried about your tail getting caught, this poofy tail is a good option. The t-base design ensures day-long comfort, and the cute tail is sure to make your partner take a second glance at your derriere!
Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug
If you’ve never tried butt play before then a butt plug is probably a great place to start! Of course, there are many options out there, so if you want something besides a plain-looking plug then this pink bunny tail butt plug might be worth checking out!
At just under $20, this beginner-friendly toy is fairly priced, easy to use, and perfect as an introduction to pet play. Unlike some other models, the tail on this toy isn’t removable, which prevents you from losing your tail while “in the moment”!
Some users have even worn this plug all day, although we would probably recommend a t-bar base butt plug instead for that. Still, you can’t deny that this toy is both comfortable & stimulating as it sits nestled between both cheeks, so why not give it a shot? You definitely won’t regret it!
The Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Want to try your first butt plugAre planning on teasing your partnerLove pinkNeed a long tailAre looking for a detachable tailWant color choices| Materials | Silicone, faux fur |
| Length | 5 inches |
| Insertable length | 2.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.11 inches |
| Adjustable | No |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
| Allergies | Latex-Free , Phthalate-Free |
Tapered tipLatex and Phthalate-FreeBeginner-friendly girthEasy to insertOnly available in pinkTail can't be removedFur can wear out over timeThis toy is perfect for guys and gals who want to get into anal or pet play since its size is so small. On the other hand, that’s also why we probably wouldn’t recommend it for more advanced users. With a relatively thin width overall, this toy might not “fill” you up as much as you’d like (in that case, check out some of the other toys on this list!).
Still, it’s designed for beginners, and to that end, this bunny tail butt plug works quite well! It’s only available in pink, but the vibrant coloring is sure to catch your partner’s eye & have them chasing after your cute little tail!
Tailz Aluminum Anal Plug With Extra Long Black Faux Mink Tail
Are you ready to unleash your inner beast in the bedroom? If so, then this Tailz butt plug is exactly what you need!
At 33 inches long, this plug will keep your partner tantalized as it trails sexily behind you, swaying & switching with every movement.
Unlike the tail butt plug options listed above, this toy has a metal butt plug that not only provides some extra weight but also a unique smooth sensation inside of you.
While you’re feeling the “fullness” from behind, you’ll also feel the soft fur of your tail brushing gently on your legs, ensuring that your partner isn’t the only one who’s ready for some sexy adventures!
With a plug length of 3.25 inches, this model might not be the biggest on the market, but thanks to its metal design, you’ll hardly notice the difference!
The Tailz Aluminum Anal Plug With Extra Long Black Faux Mink Tail was rated 30 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Like feeling “full”Want a long, sexy tailNeed something to tease your partnerWant a detachable tailAre looking for something lightweightDon’t want a black tail| Materials | Aluminum, polyester |
| Length | 33 inches |
| Insertable length | 3 inches |
| Diameter | 1.5 inches |
| Adjustable | No |
| Allergies | Phthalate-free |
Metal plug materialEasy-to-clean designPlug can be sanitizedPerfect for roleplayingNon-detachable tail3-inch insertable lengthRecommended for use with water-based lubeAlthough Tailz says this model is good for beginners, we probably wouldn’t recommend it if you’ve never shoved anything up your butt before. While the size of the plug itself isn’t very big, the weight caused by the metal may be somewhat uncomfortable to first-timers, so we’d probably recommend getting it as your second play toy instead. Still, if you decide that this is what you want then you’ll probably be OK as long as you take things slow and use a lot of lube. While the metal—in theory—should be able to work with any type of lube, Tailz specifically recommends water-based lube, which we thought was a bit odd.
DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur Animal Tail Butt Plug
If making your partner lust after your kitty sounds like fun, then why not take things to the next level with this animal tail butt plug from DOMINIX?!
The 17-inch fur tail will sway and swish with every movement, driving your partner wild while providing the inner stimulation you need to stay in “the mood”.
Unlike the plugs above, this tail butt plug is made from borosilicate glass which means you can heat or cool it to your liking before insertion.
The plug is a bit on the thick side which may not be ideal for first-timers, but that depends entirely on the tightness of your anus. With a bit of effort and a lot of lube, you’re sure to enjoy hours of sexy pet play using this luscious tail plug!
The DOMINIX Deluxe Glass Faux Fur Animal Tail Butt Plug was rated 35 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Want a temperature play toyLove pet playWant to tease your partnerHave a tight anusDon’t care about temperature playPrefer shorter tails| Materials | Borosilicate glass, faux fur |
| Length | 21 inches |
| Insertable length | 4 inches |
| Diameter | 1.43 inches |
| Adjustable | No |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
| Allergies | Latex-Free , Phthalate-Free |
17-inch tailPerfect for temperature playSoft faux fur materialTapered tipTail quality seems inconsistentTail can be hard to cleanMay be too wide for beginnersTail doesn’t detachAt 1.43 inches wide, this glass butt plug may be a bit thick for some people, but thanks to the tapered tip design, you should eventually be able to have your own slice of bum heaven (albeit with a lot of lube!).
Assuming it arrives in mint condition, people seem to love this sexy cat tail butt plug! However, consistency does seem to be an issue, with some users reporting perfect tails & others describing their experiences as sub-par.
In addition to the tail plug, you’ll also receive a velvet bag for discreet storage, which we thought was a nice touch.
Happy Rabbit Bunny Tail Butt Plug
This bunny tail butt plug may look similar to the one listed above: after all, they’re both bright pink! Still, there is one important difference—this one is bigger in size, making it a great option if you are ready to size up!
The silicone construction of the plug is easy to lube and insert since it’s flexible, it’s nice and comfortable even when you are moving around.
Since the tail is relatively small, you can even wear a skirt with it for some added, semi-revealing roleplays. As you would hope, this toy can be easily cleaned using only water & soap. Just make sure to let the fur dry out before storage and you’ll be all ready for future pet play!
The Happy Rabbit Bunny Tail Butt Plug was rated 30 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Love bright pinkPrefer flexible plugsWant an extra-comfy plugOnly use silicone lubeWant to explore temperature play Don’t like pink| Materials | Silicone, faux hair |
| Insertable length | 3.5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.43 inches |
| Adjustable | No |
| Waterproof | Splashproof |
| Allergies | Latex-Free , Phthalate-Free |
Flexible materialPoofy tailVibrant coloringOnly available in pinkA bit big for beginnersLube easily gets on tailThe sizing of this toy is a point of debate. With 3.5 inches of insertable length & a max width of 1.43 inches, it seems to be “just right” for most people, but some users still found it a bit larger than expected! I’d recommend this plug if you’ve tried smaller anal toys before and are ready for a little more.
Fortunately, this plug has a tapered tip, which should aid you when inserting the toy. As a silicone toy, you’ll only want to use water-based lube with this toy, but once you apply the lube liberally, you shouldn’t have any trouble getting this toy through the door! The silicone is semi-flexible, which can definitely help reduce any discomfort, either from insertion or from long-term wear.
Tailz Bad Kitty Black Silicone Anal Plug With Bendable Black Cat Tail
Using a tail butt plug is a great way to spice up your sex life, but after a while, it seems like all the toys are the same! Fortunately, this cat tail butt plug has changed things up a bit, offering a few extras that make this toy more-than-worth its already-low price.
Whereas some toys give you a plug, a tail, and that’s it, the Tailz Bad Kitty plug has a bendable tail which means you can adjust it to whatever activity you’re doing. Want to be a tease? Lift your skirt up a bit with the bendable tail! Need to sit down? Bend the tail between your legs for maximum comfort!
In addition to the bendable tail, this tail butt plug also has two bullet vibrator holders molded into the base, which is sure to take your backdoor experience from good to great!
