9 Best Gay Male Sex Toys

Why I Chose It

The Colt XL Big Boy Butt Plug takes the cake as the Test Winner in this review because it’s a great crowd-pleaser as far as gay male sex toys go. It’s made of body-safe silicone so you know it’s very durable and long-lasting compared to to TPE or PVC toys. Our tester, Devon, who is very experienced with anal play, was very impressed as he found it “gives a unique feeling of being very filled without being overwhelming.”

Thanks to the slim neck, it is “more comfortable for longer term wear such as walking around the house or engaging in other physical activities”, so it’s also perfect to wear during solo play, or as a warm-up for sex.

Devon really appreciated how the large body could put pressure on his sphincters and prostate without being overwhelming. This constant pressure on the prostate also meant that “engaging in coitus is a wonderful and unique experience” while wearing this butt plug.

Why I Chose It

I actually had the pleasure of testing the Hankey’s Toys Nick Capra Dildo myself. Now, I didn’t conquer it fully, but that’s exactly why I included it in this review! Despite only attempting to use it vaginally, I immediately knew this dildo would be much better suited for more advanced anal play. I mean, I could have gathered as much for a huge dildo modelled after Nick Capra… It definitely deserved a spot in this list of gay male sex toys.

The shaft increases in girth halfway down the shaft which makes penetration feel slightly more dynamic compared to a regular dildo. The length and overall girth are also perfect for all size queens and power bottoms who finds everything bigger to be better.

I always prefer it when dildos have a suction cup base, and this, sadly, does not. Combined with the fact that it’s actually quite heavy and bulky to hold by yourself does make it a pretty unhandy dildo. Still, it’s made of high quality silicone and therefore super easy to keep clean in between uses. With very little maintenance, the Mr. Hankey’s Nick Capra Dildo could keep you happy for a long time!

Why I Chose It

The Lovense Hush 2 Large is a premium quality vibrating butt plug with an impressive size and some impressive app-controlled features. Looking for a gay male sex toy that will rumble you into oblivion? You’re in the right place.

I think the size is perfect for very experienced anal adventurers looking for an advanced level butt plug. The size and firmness of the plug is stimulating enough as is. Our tester, James, thought it felt amazing and especially liked how the tapered neck of the plug means that “it feels so good when it’s in place”.

In terms of vibrations, the sensations are powerful and super fun to use because of the app controlled settings. James and his partner had a lot of fun playing with these controls but “unfortunately the vibration is just too loud to use in public”, which was one of its main appeals to him originally.

The drawbacks are definitely the firmness. With something so large, the firmness can make it uncomfortable during insertion and removal. Luckily, the Lovense Hush 2 is available in a few different sizes!

Why I Chose It

I picked out the SquarePegToys Mega Milk’it as the best prostate massager out of all the gay male sex toys because of the intense pressure it puts on the prostate. That’s right, it’s not vibrations or rotations that massage the prostate directly, it’s the sensation of fullness and the unique pressure that stimulates the area. It is definitely not a beginner-friendly shape or size, but it’s a perfect match for those with plenty of experience looking for something a bit extreme to play with.

The unique egg-like shape with the spikey texture on one side felt amazing according to our tester, Allen. He already owns a few prostate massagers, and he noted that all work the same way and provide the same kind of stimulation that’s limited to one small area. When he first inserted the Mega Milk’It, he said: “I think my brain short circuited”. 

“The Mega Milk’it due to it’s overall size and its concave side with ample ridges felt like someone was simultaneously fisting me while trying to squeeze my prostate”.

Because of how soft and squishy the silicone is, it doesn’t feel as intimidating as it looks. However, along with the lack of taper, this does mean it’s difficult to insert at first. Allen did have to experiment with his approach a few times before he had some luck.

Why I Chose It

If you prefer vibrating prostate massagers over manual ones, I highly recommend the Nexus Revo Extreme. This gay male sex toy offers two-directional rotations as well as vibrations. All settings can be controlled independently of each other with the included remote control. The textured pad on the base also provides some additional stimulation to the perineum.

At first, our tester, Jason, had a hard time inserting the tip “due to how blunt the head is”, as well as the size and firmness of the toy. Even more advanced users might need some warm-up before embarking on this journey.

Once the Nexus Revo Extreme is in all the way, though, “you will have an amazing very full feeling with really good contact to the prostate.” As far the motorized elements go, Jason was taken a bit aback by the sensations:

“The combination of the size and the double whammy of the vibrating and rotating motors made me get lost in a world of pleasure that lasted as long as I could take it.”

Why I Chose It

The Oxy Ass Anchor Expanding Butt Plug is one of the best hollow butt plugs that we’ve tested here at Bedbible. It’s made of super smooth and soft silicone so it durable, easy to sterilize, and not as intimidating as a metal or glass one. It’s a high quality gay male sex toy that has a pretty good size for most experienced anal adventurers.

Our tester, Felicia, was surprised by how much she loved the feel of the plug once it was in, and expanded: “The large base it has is far more comfortable than I expected it to be, and the hole in the bottom made it so that there was a bit of a “breeze” coming up the tunnel. This was a wild sensation for me, and definitely shivered my timbers!”

This hollow design helps with the ‘full’ sensation but also gives full access to the rectum so you can explore more creative anal play.

Since you have to squeeze the bulb together to insert the plug, it can be difficult to do alone. As far as cleaning goes, it can also be tricky to clean as you have to get in between each “petal” and they natural want to be in an expanded position.

Why I Chose It

Of all the inflatable anal toys I have seen in my time as a sex toy reviewer, the b-Vibe Expand Plug is one of the most impressive ones I’ve encountered. It doesn’t offer the largest size ever, but it is without a doubt a high quality item with some wonderful added vibrations. Most inflatable toys are made of latex, so the b-Vibe Expand Plug starts off by getting some points from being made of non-porous silicone. This makes it super easy to keep clean even though it’s only splashproof.

Allen, our tester, loved this plug. After years of trying to find a plug that would fit perfectly and stay put during use, he found the perfect product. Although, he didn’t find the vibrations to be quite powerful enough and the size wasn’t satisfying: “I love the creativeness, but sadly for a size king like myself, the expanding element doesn’t really feel like much for me”.

Still, I think the features could be a hit for less experienced users. The vibrations are felt in both the shaft and the perineum stimulator, and they’re even controlled by a remote that works form up to 30 ft away! The ergonomic shape is designed to put pressure on the prostate even when it isn’t inflated.

In my humble opinion, this plug is very much worth trying out as a gay male sex toy. Luckily, Allen also shared that “the Expand Plug is still one of the best plugs I’ve used to this day, so I don’t really mind if all the other features aren’t instantly sending me into orgasmic bliss.”

Why I Chose It

I picked out the Oxballs Tri-Sport Cock Ring because it’s a great quality product. It’s one of the most sturdy yet comfortable cock rings we’ve tested here at Bedbible. Even though it can look a bit complicated to use, our tester, James, “didn’t really have much of an issue and although it might look slightly intimidating in photos, it’s surprisingly easy to use and feels great!”.

Putting it on actually is a “a nice experience because the material of the Oxballs Tri-Sport is incredibly stretchy”. While I would prefer this to be made of non-porous silicone, this kind of stretch is mostly available with TPE products. Since it’s not being used internally, the porous material shouldn’t be a huge problem if cleaned properly between uses.

“The Tri-Sport felt very much like a regular cock ring and I liked how thick the rings were because they provided more pressure over a larger area. Overall, it felt snug and like everything was supported”.

It doesn’t feel too bulky during sex but keep in mind that the thick rings do sacrifice a bit of penis length.

Why I Chose It

The best masturbator in a review of the best male gay sex toys had to be an anal fleshlight. Not just any anal fleshlight. I’ve picked one that, in my expert opinion, best replicates the sensation of anal sex. Introducing the Fleshlight Ice Butt!

The Fleshlight Ice Butt is a clear fleshlight that still has realistic design features. The opening looks like an anus and the clear material allows you to see your penis going in and out of the sleeve. Having tried a few clear Fleshlights with my partner, I know how great the added visuals are for partnered play.

As far as the performance goes, our tester, Andrew, describes that “the soft sleeve has a suction feeling that grips your shaft tightly and it is lined with 4 intensity chambers along with dozens of ticklers, teasers, pleasure nubs and ribs”. The “Crystal”-sleeve is pretty impressive, especially with the internal diameter of 0.4 inches. It feels nice and tight, just like the real thing.