The 9 Best Silicone Butt Plugs for Silky Smooth Booty Action
| Test Winner | Cheapest | Beginner | Beaded | Vibrating | Jewelled | Rimming | Weighted | Training set |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| Lovense Hush 2 | Mood Naughty Small Plug | b-Vibe Novice Plug | ROMP Amp Silicone Beads | We-Vibe Ditto | Vibrating Heart Plug | Rimming Butt Plug 2 | Snug Plug 3 | They-ology 5-Piece Set |
| Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
How I Rated Each Silicone Butt Plug Product
Keeping things honest and unbiased is important when writing about any type of product. However, this is especially important when writing about something as personal as a silicone butt plug!
With that in mind, I’ve used a combination of sources when gathering information about these silicone anal plugs. From team-provided experiences to customer feedback and manufacturer information, a lot of research has gone into creating these ratings.
Fortunately, this means that you’ll have all the information you need to make an informed decision (conveniently located on one page)! All of the rubber butt plugs listed have been assessed using important factors like build quality and value for money.
Most importantly, I’ve made sure to include the negative points along with the positive ones. This should help prevent any unexpected issues with your upcoming orders.
Take some time, read through all the options, and then make your selection. After all, the best decision is an informed one!
Silicone vs. Other Sex Toy Materials
Silicone is a type of synthetic rubber that’s often regarded as the best sex toy material. But what makes these rubber butt plugs any better than the alternative options available? Well, let’s delve into that.
The primary advantage of silicone is that it’s non-porous. This is especially important when it comes to internal use toys like a silicone butt plug, as introducing bacteria internally can obviously pose potential health risks.
Silicone also has the advantage of being phthalate-free. Phthalates can be found in other types of materials like TPE or PVC, and can pose potential long-term health complications.
Lastly, silicone still offers the softness and flexibility that you’d expect from a sex toy. While other toy materials can also offer these characteristics, they do so with the possibility of potential health risks.
Silicone allows you to enjoy your sex toys worry-free.
FAQ
What is a Silicone Butt Plug?
As implied by the name, a silicone butt plug is a butt plug that’s made from silicone. Being made from silicone gives these toys a number of different advantages over non-silicone butt plugs, including being non-porous and sterilizable. However, since silicone is a more premium material, it’s not uncommon for these models to cost more than their non-silicone counterparts.
Table of contents (18)
The 9 Best silicone butt plugs in Test
Lovense Hush 2 Vibrating Butt Plug
Discreet shipping and billing15% off by email sign-upFree shipping on orders over $60
Discreet shipping & billing1-year warrantyAward-winning brand 
Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+
Discreet shipping & billingShipping rate: $8FREE shipping on orders $99+First on our list of the best silicone butt plugs is the Lovense Hush 2, a vibrating plug that’s received a few changes since its original version.
Designed to take full advantage of the compatible mobile app, this silicone butt plug offers a plethora of features including music sync vibes, remote controls, and unlimited settings options.
With four inches of insertable length and a diameter of 1.51 inches, this plug is sized appropriately for the vast majority of users.
When simple vibrations just aren’t enough for you anymore, switching to this silicone anal plug could mean the difference between enjoying anal play and loving it!
The Lovense Hush 2 Vibrating Butt Plug was rated 30 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Rating: Lovense Hush 2 Vibrating Butt Plug was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is silent.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of Lovense Hush 2 Vibrating Butt Plug felt to the reviewer.
Rating: Lovense Hush 2 Vibrating Butt Plug was rated 4 out of 5, which means it is very powerful.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of Lovense Hush 2 Vibrating Butt Plug felt to the reviewer.
Love vibrationsWant a waterproof plugNeed a remotely controllable toy
Only need simple vibrationsNeed a budget-friendly optionDon’t like app-centric toys| Materials | Silicone, ABS |
| Length | 4.78 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.94 inches |
| Diameter | 1.5 inches |
| Flexibility | Firm |
| Vibration speeds | 3 |
| Vibration patterns | 10 |
| Rechargeable | Yes (USB) |
| Battery Life | 210 minutes |
| Remote Controls | Yes (app) |
| Storage Bag Included | Yes |
| Waterproof | Submersible |
Extended battery lifeStrong vibrationsCan share patterns via appVibes can sync with music
ExpensiveMay be hard for tech-challenged peoplehosen as my overall “Test Winner”, the Lovense Hush 2 is one of the few silicone butt toys that excels across the board. Assuming you’re willing and comfortable primarily controlling your silicone buttplug via an app, the rest of the experience should be more than enjoyable.
Being somewhat thick, you should expect to use a decent amount of lube when inserting this toy. Fortunately, it does feature a tapered tip design, which definitely helps smooth the process.
One thing that makes this toy stand out from the competition is its ability to be controlled remotely. This gives it a lot of potential, from discreet public play to long-distance loving sessions with a far-away partner.
This toy isn’t exactly cheap (although it’s far from the most expensive toy on this list). Even taking that into consideration, I’d still say this toy is worth adding to your collection. With how many different ways the toy can be used, it’s definitely still a good value for the money.
Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug
Discreet shipping and billing15% off by email sign-upFree shipping on orders over $60
Discreet shipping & billingTheir website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+Discreet shipping & billingShipping rate: $8FREE shipping on orders $99+Next up is the Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug. Priced to sell and sized with the complete beginner in mind, this easy-to-use, non-threatening toy is a great budget buy.
Despite costing less than many other silicone butt toys, Mood Naughty hasn’t cut many corners on this little plug.
While the silicone buttplug may lack advanced features like vibrations, it’s more than enough for the first-time buyer who doesn’t want to spend a lot on a new plug.
If your priorities are comfort, ease of use, and overall affordability then the Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug is a solid choice!
The Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Are new to anal playFind larger plugs intimidatingNeed something cheapHave used and prefer larger plugsPrimarily use silicone lubeWant advanced features| Materials | Silicone |
| Length | 3.25 inches |
| Insertable length | 3 inches |
| Diameter | 0.75 inches |
| Flexibility | Firm |
| Waterproof | Yes |
| Allergies | Phthalate free |
Sized for beginnersTapered tip & t-bar base designEasy to insertAffordableOnly two color optionsToo small for experienced usersThanks to its extremely low price point, this silicone butt plug easily earned the “Cheapest” title on this list. However, you shouldn’t hold this fact against it: the little plug actually offers a great bang for your buck!
Like other silicone butt plugs, this plug uses a soft, silicone blend that’s somewhat flexible, comfortable to the touch, and easy to clean. Design-wise, the t-bar base makes the plug suitable for long-term use as you won’t have a round base biting into your butt cheeks.
Combined with the tapered shape, the t-bar base also makes inserting and removing the toy a breeze, as you’ll have plenty of toy to grab onto for easy adjustments.
Really, the only downsides of this silicone anal plug are the lack of color options and the absence of any advanced features like rimming or vibrations. However, considering the price, I think these sacrifices are small enough to overlook.
b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy
Discreet shipping & billingTheir website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+
Discreet shipping & billing20% off by email sign-upFREE shipping on orders $50+
Discreet shipping & billing4.7/5 rating of 100k reviewsFREE shipping on orders $59+Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+The b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy is a silicone butt plug that’s designed as a complete package for the complete beginner.
Offering fifteen vibration patterns at six different speeds, this toy has more than enough options to keep a complete newbie satisfied for quite a while.
Don’t worry about needing to constantly replace the batteries either. This silicone anal plug is USB rechargeable, going from dead to fully charged in under three hours.
With a battery life of up to 90 minutes and a remote that can control the toy from 30 feet away, it’s easy to see why newcomers would choose the b-Vibe Novice Plug over other silicone butt plugs!
The b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy was rated 0 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Rating: b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy was rated 2 out of 5, which means it is quiet.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy felt to the reviewer.
Rating: b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy was rated 3 out of 5, which means it is quite powerful.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of b-Vibe Novice Plug Remote Control Toy felt to the reviewer.
Are buying your first butt plugNeed a travel-friendly plugWant a rechargeable toyDon’t want vibrationsWant more color optionsNeed a submersible toy| Materials | Silicone |
| Length | 3.5 inches |
| Insertable length | 3.35 inches |
| Diameter | 1 inches |
| Vibration speeds | 6 |
| Vibration patterns | 15 |
| Rechargeable | Yes (USB) |
| Battery Life | 90 minutes |
| Charging Time | 150 minutes |
| Travel Lock | Yes |
| Remote Controls | Yes (handheld) |
| Storage Bag Included | Yes (travel case) |
| Waterproof | Splash proof/shower-friendly |
| Allergies | Latex & phthalate-free |
Splashproof30-ft. remote range15 different vibration patternsIncludes travel caseCan’t be controlled via appExpensiveOnly offered in pink & blackAlthough the previous plug was certainly a great option for newbies, the b-Vibe Novice Plug wins the “Beginner” award because it offers more than simple plug functionality. It also incorporates vibrations into the mix!
This combination makes this silicone buttplug a solid offering for beginners, as they won’t quickly outgrow the toy from lack of stimulation.
With a plethora of vibration modes that can be easily changed at the click of a button, this plug will be easy to incorporate into any solo or partnered activities.
Although the lack of an accompanying app does put it behind some other silicone butt toys in the remote controllable department, I think this relative simplicity is what makes it the smarter choice for beginners.
Whereas apps introduce technical problems and potential learning curves into the mix, having only a handheld remote makes the entire process more streamlined (especially for the less tech-savvy).
Overall, I’d recommend this to any beginner who wants to get a single toy that can keep them satisfied for months, rather than buying a simple one now just to upgrade in a month or two.
ROMP Amp Silicone Anal Beads
Next on our list of silicone butt toys is something a bit different, the ROMP Amp Silicone Anal Beads!
These beads can effectively function as a silicone plug since the beads are all connected together. However, being beads, they offer the benefit of increased stimulation upon insertion and removal.
Increasing gradually in size from 0.8 to one inch in diameter, this 5.25” long silicone buttplug beaded toy is a great size for first-time bead users.
Perfect for enhancing your orgasms, this affordably-price toy is one that you won’t regret adding to your collection!
The ROMP Amp Silicone Anal Beads was rated 50 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for someone with some experience
Want to try anal beadsNeed a new bedroom toyUse smaller sizesDon’t like purpleNeed larger beadsPrefer regular plugs| Materials | Silicone |
| Length | 6 inches |
| Insertable length | 5 inches |
| Diameter | 1.11 inches |
| Flexibility | Flexible |
| Waterproof | Submersible |
| Allergies | Latex & phthalate-free |
5 inches of insertable lengthAffordableGraduating bead sizeGreat for first-timersNot ideal for extended wearSmall for more experienced usersNo color optionsAn obvious shoo-in for the “Beaded” category, the ROMP Amp Silicone Anal Beads is a fairly simple toy overall. Even so, I think it’s a solid option for anyone who finds themselves on the fence when it comes to anal beads.
Being relatively small, this silicone anal plug toy won’t offer much to more experienced users. However, for wary beginners, the non-intimidating sizing helps decrease any fears while increasing ease of use.
With a decent difference between the diameter of the neck and the diameter of the beads themselves, users will definitely enjoy strong sensations despite the overall small size of the toy itself.
The toy is affordably priced, making the item even more accessible. While it may not have much to offer for more advanced users, it’s a good beginner-friendly option that won’t break the bank.
We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug
Discreet shipping and billing15% off by email sign-upFree shipping on orders over $60
Discreet shipping & billing2-year warrantyFREE shipping on orders $50+Discreet shipping & billingTheir website ROCKS!FREE shipping on orders $68+Discreet shipping & billing15% off with email sign-up FREE shipping on orders $79+Designed to bring the experience of a premium vibrating silicone butt plug to beginners, the We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug is a unique offering.
Controllable via the included remote or through the feature-filling mobile app, this soft butt plug gives you over ten different vibration modes to choose from.
Even better, this model is completely submersible, meaning you can enjoy backdoor pleasures no matter where you are!
If you’re planning on sticking to the smaller silicone anal plugs and want a premium toy that will last for a long time without getting boring, the We-Vibe Ditto is certainly a compelling option!
The We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug was rated 15 out of 100 meaning that it is most suitable for a complete beginner
Rating: We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is silent.
What it is: The sound rating provides a visual representation of how loud the vibrations of We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug felt to the reviewer.
Rating: We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug was rated 1 out of 5, which means it is weak.
What it is: The power rating describes how fast and strong the vibrations of We-Vibe Ditto Vibrating Butt Plug felt to the reviewer.
Prefer less intense vibrationsPlan on sticking to small plugsNeed a waterproof toyHave used vibrating plugs beforePlan on sizing up soonStruggle with apps| Materials | Silicone |
| Length | 3.5 inches |
| Insertable length | 3 inches |
| Diameter | 1.19 inches |
| Flexibility | Flexible |
| Vibration modes | 10 |
| Rechargeable | Yes (USB) |
| Battery Life | 90 minutes |
| Charging Time | 120 minutes |
| Remote Controls | Yes (physical & app) |
| Flexibility | Flexible |
| Storage Bag Included | No |
| Waterproof | Submersible |
| Allergies | Latex & phthalate-free |
Multiple control optionsComfortable to useComes with lubricantNearly silentOnly two color optionsExpensiveNot for experienced usersAs noted in our user review, this silicone buttplug is best for beginners. Its small size makes it a poor choice for those with a bit more experience, and its high price tag makes it a bad investment for those planning to size up soon.
That said, if you’re not planning on graduating to larger plugs, the We-Vibe is pretty much the best premium option you could ask for. Easily earning the “Vibrating” award (thanks to its plethora of beginner-sized vibes), using this plug won’t get old any time soon.
I also like the fact that this plug is completely submersible.
While splashproof silicone butt toys are great for the shower, they won’t stand up to full submersion in a bathtub. Having this extra level of waterproofing greatly increases your potential usage options.
In summary, would I recommend this product? Well, if you’re planning on graduating to larger plugs then definitely not. The toy simply costs too much for a month or two of use.
However, if the sizing is perfect and you don’t plan on switching things any time soon, the We-Vibe Ditto can offer the performance you need at the size you want.