The 6 Best Small Anal Toys

Why I Chose It

I’ve picked out the b-Vibe Novice Plug as the Test Winner because of its overall quality, petite build, and special features. Our reviewer, Jess, mentioned that she “absolutely LOVED the B-Vibe Novice butt plug and I will recommend this to anyone who wants to start a journey in anal play, and even for anyone who just wants a really comfortable base anal plug.”

Not only is this a pretty small anal toy, the shape itself is made to assist newbies with insertion and general comfort during use. The tapered tip makes it a dream to insert and the slim body doesn’t feel too overwhelming. The T-shaped base with slightly rounded edges also makes it comfortable for wear during sex or for extended periods of time. Jess noted that the petite size made it possible for her to be “comfortably able to use a dildo and this plug at the same time and the feelings were AMAZING!”

The physical remote control adds a nice touch making it a lot easier to operate once inserted. This is always a plus in my book, since it can be a bit inconvenient to reach around to press the buttons. The 30 ft range of the remote makes it stand out as one of the remote controls with the longest range.

The price is quite steep for something so small. However, if I were looking for small or beginner-friendly anal toy but wanted to invest in something that would keep me interested for a lot longer after I graduated into intermediate anal play, I’d say it’s worth it! The vibrations are powerful and it’s a great unisex toy to share with a partner.

Why I Chose It

I’ve picked out the Lovehoney Jewelled Iridescent Metal Butt Plug as the best option for newbies because I always recommend anal beginners start out with a classic metal butt plug. Here’s why:

It is a manageable size for most people who have already experimented with a finger or two. The tear-drop shape is also perfect for easy yet stimulating insertion. I am always thankful for butt plugs that have a thin neck between the body and the base. This helps the plug stay in place even as pressure is applied during orgasm or double penetration.

My personal favorite thing about metal butt plugs is the slight weighted sensation they add to the mix. In my experience, a simple metal butt plug like this really enhances the sensations and gives you a satisfyingly full feeling. Not to mention, the firmness of the metal feels really nice with such a small anal toy.

In terms of design, I know that some people would prefer something more simple. I personally enjoy when sex toys offer a playful or cute design element, like the jewel on the base or the iridescent metal that this plug is made of. So, it’s ultimately a question of preference, but for the price you’re getting this plug at, I appreciate the extra design elements.

Why I Chose It

I’ve actually had the pleasure of testing the Fifty Shades of Grey Pleasure Intensified Anal Beads myself. I think they are an ideal choice for anyone who is on a budget but still wants a good quality anal toy that isn’t too large.

These were actually my very first set of anal beads and I’m so glad I started out with them. The beads all have this slimline design and gradually increase in size. They start out super small (like half the size of a fingertip small) so I definitely think it’s good for total beginners as well. You can obviously stop at whichever bead you feel comfortable at.

One point of critique I have about this product is that it actually is a bit too flexible. Of course, flexibility is usually nice when you’re a beginner. However, with this design, it actually makes it a little more difficult to insert. Once you’re past the learning curve, it’s pretty easy to operate, but I generally prefer beginner-friendly products to be super simple to use from the get-go.

This is my lightest anal toy, it weighs almost nothing. Since they also come with a storage bag, they’re easy to travel with. They’re also super easy to sterilize and keep clean in between uses. All in all, I think the Fifty Shades of Grey Pleasure Intensified Anal Beads are a great and affordable option for anyone who wants to explore small anal toys but want a little something extra!

Why I Chose It

I chose to include the njoy Pure Plug Small as my Expert Pick because it’s one of my all-time favorite small anal toys to recommend. Yes, it is definitely a premium quality butt plug sold at a premium level price point, I’m not going to lie. Although it is expensive, it’s the kind of product that’ll be there to please you for life. Made of 316 medical grade, hand-polished stainless steel, this butt plug is incredibly durable and long-lasting.

Now, how is this one different from most other metal butt plugs? The bulb has a unique shape that’s meant to target the prostate for some firm massage. The shapes is also nice and stimulating to insert yet very comfortable to wear long-term because of the slim neck. I know that this also helps prevent the plug from popping out under pressure, so that’s a huge plus for me! The base is also slightly more sophisticated than your regular old flared base. It has a T-shaped loop that both sits comfortably between the cheeks and makes it a lot easier to grip during insertion and removal. Here’s how it worked for Rachel, who tested it for us:

“I found the njoy Pure Plug surprisingly easy to use. I say surprisingly because when I first looked at its bulbed tip, my butt clenched in fear. However, my fear was mostly unfounded. The super smooth steel makes inserting this butt plug a breeze.”

I also just love stainless steel anal toys in general. They are temperature responsive, compatible with all lubes, and provide firm massage and weighted sensation. As a sex toy expert, I cannot recommend this little thing more. It’s worth splurging on, in my humble opinion. As a regular consumer, however, I do recognize that it’s not very budget-friendly.

Why I Chose It

The Fun Factory Limba Flex S is my top recommendation if you’re looking for a small anal dildo. Felicia tested it for us and was very impressed with the overall versatility of such a seemingly small and simple dildo.

“The feel of the Limba Flex S is similar to most silicone; silky and almost creamy to the touch. It’s made with 100% body safe, waterproof silicone and has a strong suction “Y” shaped base.” Having tried a fair share of Fun Factory products myself, I can attest to the quality of the materials. Although, in my experience, they can be very prone to attracting lint and dust, and definitely require a rinse before use.

Felicia’s biggest bone to pick with the Limba Flex S was that the stem was almost too short if you wanted to use the suction cup base. “[…] it’s too short to stick to the floor and have some personal fun. I’m a chubby girl, so it could’ve just been too much of myself in the way, but I was quite sad I wasn’t able to use it like that at first.” It seems as if this dildo is best suited for hand-held solo play, assistance from a partner, and strap-on fun.

 “Another thing I’d like to point out is though it’s very flexible, having the metal rod in the centre makes the Limba Flex on the harder side, and the tip can feel a bit sharp on certain angles, so I would suggest taking things a bit slow until you get a feel for it. On the positive side, it 100% kept its shape!”. That said, firmer dildos are, in my experience, a lot better suited for anal play than super flexible ones, since they’re easier to insert.

In terms of price, I think this dildo is relatively affordable. It’s not super cheap but I think the price is fair for the quality and adjustable feature you’re getting. “All-in-all, I feel the Limba Flex S is a good addition to anyone’s secret stash. It’s stylish, sporty, sleek, versatile, and best of all, you can form it to hit the right spot.”

Why I Chose It

“I absolutely love the We-Vibe Vector+. I think it is an amazing modern addition to anyone’s collection especially if a long distance partner is in the picture. I have never used a more powerful, well designed, comfortable, or fun vibrator before this one. The features this toy packs in such a small and convenient package blows my mind.”

As you can tell, Robby, who tested this prostate massager for us, really enjoyed this small anal toy. I can certainly understand that as it is, from a sex toy expert’s perspective, a very well-made product with impressive features and performance.

First, I want to emphasize that the design is amazing for first-time prostate explorers. While the diameter of 1.1 inches perhaps does require that you’ve at least experimented with one of two fingers, that’s still a relatively small size for an anal toy.

The device itself is slightly poseable so you can adjust the angle to fit your body better. The perineum vibrator is also designed to line up perfectly with your body. “There is nothing more difficult than finding a vibrator that fits your body well and is comfortable to use. (The WeVibe Vector+) is a slam dunk in comfort and it fits my body very well due to its shape and slenderness.”

What makes this prostate massager stand out is the remote control and app control features. “Really what it comes down to is the customization the app allows me to have. I am a complete slut for the We-Vibe app and it’s innumerous personal settings each user can cater to themselves with.”

Even though it is significantly more expensive than some of the other products in this review, this is an example of a small anal toy that offers just as much luxury and high tech play than larger toys. I can vouch for it and so can Robby: “I love this toy and I highly recommend it to anyone who is looking for a prostate vibrator that is high tech, comfortable, extremely portable, and well designed.”