The 10 Best Weighted Butt Plugs for Fantastic Fullness
In today’s review, I’m bringing you the best weighted butt plugs for all levels of experience, budgets, and style preferences. Whether you need a stainless steel weighted butt plug, a budget-friendly weighted butt plug, or a vibrating weighted anal plug, I’ve got you covered! I’ve also included some helpful info to get you started once you’ve found the best butt plug for you. Today’s test winner is the b-Vibe Snug Plug 2, chosen for it’s top quality materials and satisfying weight. I tested it myself and it’s a sure fire winner in my books!
|b-Vibe Snug Plug 2||Jeweled Metal Butt Plug||b-Vibe Anal Training Set||b-Vibe Snug Plug 4||nJoy Pure Plug||Rosebuds Butt Plug||Vibrating Snug Plug 2||Snug and Tug||Pfun Prostate Plug||Weighted Inflatable Plug|
|Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price||Check price|
Table of contents (16)
How We Rated and Reviewed Weighted Butt Plugs
Every top-tier product you’ll see listed below has been rated and reviewed individually. This approach prevents direct comparison between plugs, instead allowing us to highlight the pros and cons of each toy without bias. Each conclusion we’ve reached has been a result of personal testing (when possible), researching the available manufacturer information, and reading real-user reviews.
Unlike some sites that only aim to show products in a positive light, we believe that it’s just as important to highlight why you shouldn’t buy a toy, in addition to why you should. It’s this combination of honesty, complete transparency, and accurate information that makes us your one and only source on the journey to better sex!
Some of the weighted butt plugs have also been tested personally! If you see someone holding the toy in the image, you can click the review link under the rating to read an in depth review from our tester!
Reviews of the 10 best weighted butt plugs
Test Winner b-Vibe Snug Plug 2
This weighted butt plug offers a quarter pound of full satisfaction. The weight is provided by two metal balls that rotate inside the plug, giving an extra element of stimulation.
The barrel shape, thin neck, and t-bar base are also designed to be comfortable for extended wear. I also love that it’s made of medical grade silicone and has a deliciously smooth silicone finish.
This beautifully designed weighted butt plug delivers in terms of design, quality, and stimulation! It was an obvious choice for the best weighted butt plug!
- ✅ Quality materials
- ✅ Weighted, rolling balls
- ✅ Smooth silicone
- ✅ Comfortable for extended wear
- ✅ Stays in place well
- ❌ Difficult to insert
- ❌ Can't really feel the balls rolling
- ❌ Silicone can retain smell so must be cleaned thoroughly
Having personally tested the b-Vibe Snug Plug 2 I can confirm that it is a top notch weighted butt plug! The barrel shape can make it a bit challenging to insert but on the flip side, I found it much more comfortable to wear as there was no pointy end to poke into you when you sit down. I also really love how thin and flexible the neck is, I could hardly notice it and it means the plug stays in place really well.
I could definitely notice the weight but didn’t notice a lot of sensation from the balls rolling. Some users report that the silicone can retain some smell but I haven’t found this an issue if I clean it very thoroughly and leave out to air dry for a decent amount of time.
Compared to the other weighted plugs in this review, I would say this is a great intermediate level weighted butt plug, both in terms of size and weight.
You should buy the b-Vibe Snug Plug 2 if you...
- have some experience with larger toys
- want a wearable butt plug
- love buttery smooth silicone
You should not buy the b-Vibe Snug Plug 2 if you...
- need a tapered butt plug
- aren't willing to clean it very thoroughly
- are looking for an extra large plug
Cheapest Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug
I love a little sexy sparkle and this cute crystal butt plug has plenty! The beginner friendly size and tapered tip make this weighted butt plug easier to insert, while the 145 g weight adds an extra layer of sensation.
I’m also a big fan of metal butt plugs as they can be gently heated or cooled for some tingly temperature play and it’s compatible with all kinds of lube!
- ✅ Beginner friendly size
- ✅ Tapered for easy insertion
- ✅ Can be heated or cooled
- ✅ Beautiful sparkly gem
- ✅ Cheap
- ❌ Too small for some
- ❌ The base could be wider
- ❌ Tapered tip can be uncomfortable when sitting
Overall I think this a great little butt plug for a great price! I would say the size is best suited to beginners or those who prefer small butt plugs. Although it’s small, the bulbed shape and added weight create a very nice sensation of fullness, especially as you move around.
As the plug is already quite small, I would like if the base was wider for peace of mind when wearing the plug. If you are concerned about this, I would recommend opting for one of the t-bar base plugs in the post, such as one of the Snug Plugs or the Pure Plug.
You should buy the Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug if you...
- Are new to weighted butt plugs
- Love the sparkly gem look
- Want to explore temperature play
You should not buy the Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug if you...
- Need an intermediate plug
- Want a weighted plug for extended wear
- Prefer silicone
Beginners b-Vibe Anal Training and Education Set
I can’t think of a better introduction to anal play than the b-Vibe anal training kit! Rather than jumping straight in with a weighted plug, you can gradually work your way up, starting with a softer, simple plug and moving onto a intermediate size plug, before reaching the pleasantly weighted large plug!
I love that the medium plug also features a thrilling range of vibration settings so you get to experience a range of sensations.
I’m also super impressed by the thoughtful extras in this kit! You also get an anal douche, lube injector, and handy educational guide for safe, pain-free anal, plus a cute storage bag!
- ✅ Amazing quality
- ✅ Three different size plugs
- ✅ 1 weighted and 1 vibrating plug
- ✅ Includes anal douche, lube injector, and guide book
- ❌ Expensive investment
- ❌ Not so satisfying for more experienced users
I don’t think the b-Vibe Anal Training Kit can be beaten when it comes to beginners butt play! It provides a lovely, gradual introduction to the more intense sensations of weighted butt plugs.
It is the most expensive weighted butt plug product in this review, but keep in mind you are getting not one but three top quality plugs, including a vibrating one, plus all of the added extras, so it’s actually pretty good value for money! That being said, it’s good to have some idea that you enjoy anal stimulation before investing in the kit.
The real icing on the cake for me, is the comprehensive guide to anal play. This lovely little book offers positions, tips, tricks, and everything you need to know for safe and pleasurable anal play.
You should buy the b-Vibe Anal Training and Education Set if you...
- Are curious about exploring anal play
- Want to work up to a weighted butt plug
- Are keen to explore different sizes and sensations
- Are ready to invest in a quality kit
You should not buy the b-Vibe Anal Training and Education Set if you...
- Already have considerable experience
- Prefer metal butt plugs
- Are on a budget
Largest b-Vibe Snug Plug 4
Now, while b-Vibe offers two sizes bigger than the Snug Plug 4, I think this XL size plug will satisfy most looking for a large weighted butt plug!
Boasting an impressive 9.7 ounces of weight, this heavily weighted butt plug has an insertable length of 5.2 inches and a juicy diameter of 1.73 inches. You are bound to get a satisfying stretch from this one!
Combine that with the 275 g weight and you are in for an intensely pleasurable feeling of fullness!
I love that even though the plug is XL, the neck is thin and flexible for comfortable wear.
- ✅ XL size
- ✅ Shape is comfortable for extended wear
- ✅ 257 g weighted balls
- ✅ Top quality silicone
- ❌ Will be too big for many
- ❌ Silicone needs to be cleaned and air dried thoroughly
I know! Another Snug Plug! But trust me, they really are the best weighted butt plugs out there! When a plug is this big, you really want to make sure it’s going to be comfortable to wear and the snug plug certainly ticks that box! The only thing to keep in mind is that it’s not as tapered as other butt plugs, so you will need to take some time warming up with smaller toys.
And it goes without saying that I would only recommend this to people with a lot of anal experience who have used bigger anal toys before!
Compared to the other weighted butt plugs in the review, the Snug Plug 4 is in the medium price range, but keep in mind, it also requires more materials to make a plug this size!
You should buy the b-Vibe Snug Plug 4 if you...
- Are an advanced user looking for a large fill
- Appreciate quality and affordability
- Want a wearable weighted butt plug
- Are ready for a more intense weight
You should not buy the b-Vibe Snug Plug 4 if you...
- Don't have experience with larger anal toys
- Aren't willing to spend time warming up
- Prefer a more tapered tip
Steel nJoy Pure Plug
I love the simplicity and impeccable quality of njoy’s stainless steel sex toys and the pure plug is no exception! Made of 316 grade stainless steel, the pure plug is one of the most durable weighted butt plugs you will ever come across — it really is a toy for life!
It’s designed for incredibly easy insertion – it will only need a bit of lube – and its metal make makes cleaning a snap. Weighing at 7 ounces, the Pure Plug is worth its high price tag as every single piece of this toy, from the box it comes in to the mold it was cast in, was built with your pleasure in mind.
- ✅ Great for temperature play
- ✅ Ergonomic loop handle
- ✅ Pleasantly filling weight
- ✅ Incredible quality
- ❌ Pricey
- ❌ A little small for some
- ❌ Can sit down while wearing
I love the elegance of the Pure Plug! And it’s not only beautiful, it’s incredibly functional! The bulb is relatively small, but the weight gives the illusion of a bigger, more filling plug. The loop handle also makes it much easier to insert and remove. I also love that it’s keeps the plug anchored securely outside the body.
The only downside is that the handle means you can’t sit down while wearing the Pure Plug, so if you are looking for a more wearable weighted plug, I would go for one of the Snug Plugs.
I would recommend this plug to beginners and those who enjoy smaller anal toys, but if you are thinking of sizing up soon, it might be a little too pricey.
You should buy the nJoy Pure Plug if you...
- Prefer sleek stainless steel
- Want to explore temperature play
- Are ready to invest in a quality plug
You should not buy the nJoy Pure Plug if you...
- Are likely to size up soon
- Want a plug for extended wear
- Prefer a flexible plug
High end Rosebuds Butt Plug
10% coupon available
I have never laid my eyes on a more beautiful or more luxurious butt plug than than this one! I love absolutely everything about it from the satisfying 295 gram weight to the bulbed shape, and of course, the sparkling Swarovski crystal on the base!
The Rosebuds Butt Plug is made from top quality stainless steel and hand-polish for the smoothest, shiniest finish! I also love that it’s available in three different sizes and with different colored crystals so you can find your perfect match.
- ✅ Incredibly beautiful
- ✅ High-quality materials
- ✅ Weighs 295 grams
- ✅ Very comfortable
- ❌ Expensive
Having had the honor of testing the Rosebuds Butt Plug personally, I cannot sing it’s praises highly enough! Yes, it is more expensive than the other stainless steel weighted butt plugs in this review, but it’s worth it for how incredibly sexy you feel when your booty is adorned with a Swarovski crystal!
I always also incredibly surprised by just how comfortable it is to wear, even when sitting down!
However, if this high-end butt plug is out of your budget for a weighted sex toy but you love the sparkly gem style, check out the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug, which was our best cheap weighted butt plug in this review!
You should buy the Rosebuds Butt Plug if you...
- Are ready to invest in a high-end weighted butt plug
- Want an intermediate size plug
- Enjoy temperature play
- Are looking for a gift for a butt plug loving partner
You should not buy the Rosebuds Butt Plug if you...
- Haven't explored anal play before
- Want a cheap weighted butt plug
- Need an extra large butt plug